EDITORIAL: How a Nintendo Cinematic Universe Could Work

EDITORIAL: How a Nintendo Cinematic Universe Could Work

A shared video game movie universe sounds impossible, but I have some ideas that can make it work.

Editorial Opinion
By StewartGGriffin - Aug 11, 2014 02:08 AM EST
Filed Under: Other

Okay, before I begin, I would like to state some things.

1. I'm new to this website, this is my first editorial. I don't really know what I'm doing or if I'm doing it right, so I wouldn't be surprised if this ends up getting removed. But I'll try my best.

2. This topic may be controversial, but I stand by my opinions, no matter how crazy they sound.

Okay, now we begin.

So Marvel has been extremely successful at building their cinematic universe over the past six years. DC is beginning to shape theirs, and now I even hear of a cinematic universe of classic movie monsters is in development. But for almost two years, I have envisioned another shared movie universe that could actually be pulled off: a shared video game movie universe. 

I know that film adaptations of video games have for the most part been unsuccessful. Super Mario Bros., Resident Evil, even a recent film adaptation of the game Need for Speed received a negative reception from critics and fans. But I feel like this could be popular.

I'm not the first one to think of this. I googled "Nintendo Cinematic Universe" and was surprised to see others have thought of this. Some of their ideas have influenced mine. 

I first envisioned a Nintendo Cinematic Universe back in 2012. It was after I saw The Avengers, and I was playing Super Smash Bros. Brawl with my brother. We were roleplaying as characters from the game and we came up with this story where some characters form a team named "Super Smash Bros." and ever since then, I've always wanted something like that to happen on the big screen. But because of the failure of movies based on video games, and the many changes that would have to happen to make it work, I didn't think it would ever happen. 

So why am I writing this right now?

A couple of months back, a Sonic the Hedgehog film was revealed to be in development. After I found that out, I was like "Oh cool! Hope it doesn't suck." But about a month after that, I once again began thinking of my vision for a Nintendo Cinematic Universe. Once again some thoughts were "It's probably not gonna happen." But then I sat up and realized a Sonic movie was in development, and I immeadietly thought to myself "This is a great opportunity to start a shared video game universe!" And I got excited. But then I realized not a lot of people were even thinking about that even happening. So I'm writing this to tell you how a Nintendo Cinematic Universe could work, and which films could be used to lead up to a team up movie. So I have a few tips for how it could work, let's begin with the first one:

1. Make The Films CGI or Motion Capture

There are many characters I envisioned existing in the Nintendo Cinematic Universe (NCU), that would need CGI to make it work on screen. Take Sonic for example. The Sonic movie is slated to be CGI/Live-action. Which would be fine to me, if it were only CGI. The fact that there will be live-action mixed with CGI is just a terrible idea in my opinion. Taking that route, they might end up with another Smurfs or Alvin and the Chipmunks, movies I (and many others) personally disliked. I mean just imagine Doctor Robotnik (if they do a movie, he should be called Robotnik, not Eggman) being a live-action human. Not only would he look terrible, but it'd be weird to see live-action Robotnik with CGI Sonic. I think it would actually look kind of campy, I mean that's my opinion, others may think differently. But other films (like Starfox, which I would include in "Phase 1" of the NCU) would need to be CGI because they would look down-right terrible in live-action. So all the films being CGI would be perfect for an NCU. But there's one thing, one major thing that would need to be changed a lot to make an NCU work. Which leads me to my next point:

2. Setting

Major changes to the setting would have to happen in order for these characters to interconnect. Hyrule and the Mushroom Kingdom would have to exist in the same universe, while somewhere else in the universe, there would be the Pokémon regions. It sounds like that would be hard to make happen, and it would be. But I have one idea that seems like the only way it could work, and I bet this is what is going to be the most controversial topic in this editorial:

It's all in one galaxy.

Let me explain a little more. My vision is that there's a galaxy, and in that galaxy, a bunch of planets, and on those planets, certain landmarks that exist within video games. For example, one of the planets contains both Hyrule and the Mushroom Kingdom. Another planet, I thought, would be an entire planet containing all the Pokémon regions. And yes, I know there's only six so far, but who knows how many more will be introduced in the future. Other planets include Zebes, anyone whose played Metroid should be familiar with that. Corneria, Venom, all those are from Starfox. And there would be others, I'm sure, I don't know what they could be at the moment. But the whole galaxy would have a name too. In Starfox, that galaxy of planets is called The Lylat System. In the NCU, to tie into Starfox, the entire galaxy containing all these planets would be called Lylat.

Of course, a lot of space travel would be needed to travel from planet to planet. Which I'm sure will also be controversial, at least for certain characters. The Starfox crew is obviously no stranger to space travel, but say the Super Smash Bros. needed to assemble to stop a threat on a certain planet, they'd need to use space travel to get there. So characters like Link would need to use spaceships... I bet I lost a couple readers after saying that. But that's the one main thing that would need to happen to make these worlds connect, at least in my opinion. Well those are some of my main points. I will now talk about which films would have to happen in order to start this franchise. 

3. Films That Would Be In "Phase 1" of the NCU

Well the rest of this is gonna be a list, so just hang tight. 

The first film in the NCU would obviously be Sonic the Hedgehog. 

It's already in development. Everything in this movie and the others would be CGI. I would want the story to be based on Sonic Adventure. Because it and Sonic Adventure 2 have the best stories of all the Sonic games in my opinion. It would be a good start of the franchise and hopefully a way to set up the characters. Oh, and the post-credits scene. Similar to the first Iron Man, Sonic is approached by R.O.B. (who I want to gather the team), who wants to talk about a plan of his called the "Super Smash Bros." 

The next movie would be Super Mario Bros.

Once again, it would be CGI. So don't worry that it could end up like the abomination that was the live-action Mario movie. Villain would be Bowser, obviously. Bowser kidnaps Peach and Mario and Luigi go to save her. Yoshi and Toad would be there to help Mario and Luigi. Also to help them would be... Donkey Kong? In my opinion, Donkey Kong should be introduced in this movie. Him and Mario have a connection in the games, so I figure him and Mario should be like "old rivals", and Donkey Kong helps him on his quest to save the princess. This movie also contains THREE people who I would put on the Super Smash Bros. team. Mario, Luigi, and Donkey Kong. So R.O.B.'s plan now has four people involved.

Third movie would be The Legend of Zelda.

CGI. Villain is Ganondorf. Link is trying to save Zelda and Hyrule from Ganondorf, who seeks to find the Triforce. Post-credits scene? R.O.B. asking Link to join his team. Oh yeah, and Ganondorf is the villain in Super Smash Bros.

Fourth movie is Metroid.

CGI. Samus Aran volunteers to go to the planet Zebes to stop the evil Mother Brain. R.O.B. asks her to join his team. The usual.

Fifth movie is Starfox.

Obviously CGI. Fox McCloud and his crew, called "Starfox" travel to the planet Venom to stop Andross. Falco, Slippy, Peppy are part of the Starfox crew, of course. Wolf is also in the movie, working with Andross. R.O.B. asks Fox to join the team. Now the entire roster of the Super Smash Bros. team is complete.

Final movie of a Phase 1 is obviously Super Smash Bros.

Did I mention CGI? Ganondorf is the villain. The team consists of Mario, Sonic, Luigi, Link, Samus, Fox, and Donkey Kong. Yeah, that's pretty much that I guess.

Other films I had in mind for the future are:

Sonic the Hedgehog: Project Shadow (Sonic Adventure 2 storyline)
Pokémon (Red is protagonist, NOT ASH! Also instead of being 10, trainers are 16-19 years old)
Kid Icarus (cause Pit is cool)
Kirby (cause people will kill me if Kirby's not involved with this)
F-Zero (cause Captain Falcon has to say "Falcon Punch" on the big screen)

Also I'd want Mewtwo to be the villain of Super Smash Bros. 2

And yes, all the movies I mentioned above would also be CGI.

Well that's my editorial. If you read to this point, then thank you. I just spent the past hour and a half writing this, so thanks to whoever reads this. I think a Nintendo Cinematic Universe could actually happen, maybe if the fans make it clear that it's possible, it could happen. Also reminding you all again this is my first editorial, if I do more they'll probably be better. Thanks so much :)


 

THE 4:30 MOVIE Interview: Filmmaker Kevin Smith On How His Passion For The Theater Shaped New Film (Exclusive)
Related:

THE 4:30 MOVIE Interview: Filmmaker Kevin Smith On How His Passion For The Theater Shaped New Film (Exclusive)

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking
Recommended For You:

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Snotzo
Snotzo - 8/11/2014, 4:23 AM
Oh please no. However, they are very well known IPs. Still no thank you.
GizmoEl
GizmoEl - 8/11/2014, 4:48 AM
I don't think it'd ever happen. That being said, all I want in this world is a properly done Legend of Zelda movie in live action. Adapt Ocarina of Time, Majoras Mask, Twilight Princess, Windwaker, Skyward Sword, A Link to the Past.. [frick] it. Make everything. I need this movie franchise in the same scale as The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. GIVE IT TO ME PLEASE.
kong
kong - 8/11/2014, 5:09 AM
LOL what a copy of the MCU. What's next, Super Smash Bros: Age of Metal Sonic. Official!!! Confirmed!!!! Super Smash Bros 3 is titled "Super Smash Bros: The Chaos Emeralds" with them as the MacGuffin of the film.
Alphadog
Alphadog - 8/11/2014, 5:12 AM
Nope, I don't see this working at all. The idea of an MCU is that there's a story going through all of it. It's not just things connecting. All these series could make cool movies but I don't think you can have a serious story going through them. You can have crossovers but you can't have a shared universe. Something like Wreck It Ralph works but it's not a shared universe like Marvel.
McGee
McGee - 8/11/2014, 5:20 AM
Drakenxtreme
Drakenxtreme - 8/11/2014, 6:43 AM
I like the idea but your ideas n concept of it was not good..first you really dont kno your gaming history...Eggman is the true name of the Sonic villain. It was changed to robotnik for commercial reasons but as Japanese culture became more accepted they went back to callin him eggman...2..Sonic maybe owned by nintendo but he should not be the irob man to this series...Nintendo started wit mario it should always start wit him...
GizmoEl
GizmoEl - 8/11/2014, 6:45 AM
@TheMexicanSuperman That's like saying, why not make an original story for a Lord of the Rings movie? I mean, I'm assuming they'd take some liberties with the source material (just as Peter Jackson did with LotR and Hobbit), but they have such a rich story to start from, it'd be a shame if it wasn't adapted. I mean I'm all for new stories, however there are a few that NEED to be told.. namely Ocarina of Time.
GizmoEl
GizmoEl - 8/11/2014, 6:46 AM
Also, I've been secretly praying that Disney/Apple buys out Nintendo.. combining everything I love in one giant studio.

Even though Nintendo is struggling a bit right now, they have SOOOOO much money that they can last for years and years without making anything.
yossarian
yossarian - 8/11/2014, 7:27 AM
I like to think everything is part of a shared universe. I like knowing that the Golden Girls exist in the same make believe universe as Return of the Killer Tomatoes.
tvor03
tvor03 - 8/11/2014, 7:36 AM
I would absolutely LOVE to see a live-action Zelda. One of my favorite franchises of all time. I've even dabbled with the screenplay myself just for kicks. But Nintendo is notorious about refusing adaptations of their characters after the Mario film disaster. They've been approached many, many, MANY times about a LoZ film, and it never happens. Perhaps if these Halo projects or Assassin's Creed go well, it might open the door for Nintendo to change their minds. But the fact that there has never been a good video game to film adaptation really hurts the chances we'll see this in the next decade or so.
01928401
01928401 - 8/11/2014, 12:50 PM
I think it sounds like a cool idea. I love all those franchises and I love movies and shared universes. The idea of a Smash Bros movie sounds amazing.
yossarian
yossarian - 8/11/2014, 1:06 PM
@deth - That sounds cool as shit. I will check it out.
Wolf38
Wolf38 - 8/11/2014, 1:47 PM
Nicely written editorial. I'm not sure that it makes sense to me to include Sonic the Hedgehog in this, though, even if the character is playable on Nintendo these days.

Also, a lot of these characters seem like odd fits for an interconnected universe. But then, I'm someone who isn't really a fan of the sort of characters-together thing from the Lego Movie (good film, and granted the Lego premise explains a lot of it).

However, I definitely think that there is a franchise waiting to happen that basically includes the characters from the Mario Kart games, i.e. the Mario Bros. group crossing over with Donkey Kong, and maybe a few others. That could be great fun, and has plenty of film potential.

Also, Legend of Zelda seems like a obvious choice for film adaption (live action) considering the popularity of fantasy these days, and as a sci-fi fan, I would very much like to see Starfox, Metroid and Mega Man in cinema.

RoyRodgersMcFreely
RoyRodgersMcFreely - 8/11/2014, 3:56 PM
So basically you want to make a Captain N the game master movie? Wasn't that the equivalent? He had mega man, simon Belmont, kid Icarus, and the princess.
Baddies were mother brain and king hippo
Download the series so you don't need Nintendo avengers
superherofan21
superherofan21 - 8/11/2014, 5:37 PM
While I like the idea of a connected universe of video game movies, Sonic should not be apart of it. He's a Sega character, not Nintendo...
Tainted87
Tainted87 - 8/11/2014, 6:18 PM
There are worse ideas for sure.

Here's the deal with Sonic, and why people are recoiling at the idea of him included/featured prominently.
His time with Nintendo dates back 7 years ago, when they bought the rights to the character - but not entirely. He's as much a Nintendo character as Commander Shepard is a Playstation property. Note how Sonic games are up for download on Xbox Arcade. Secondly, he's dull.
====

As for an "NCU", people are very quick to dismiss it - not for the worst reasons, but let's take a look again at what Smash Bros is. Oh Jesus, when the first game came out, I totally breezed over it, didn't have an N64 at the time, and when I eventually did, I only had it for GoldenEye. So let's go to Melee, which includes quite a few obscure characters.... Captain Falcon being one of them, yes, he is.

Melee was one of the most successful decisions Nintendo ever made, simply because the entire game can be regarded as a giant extended commercial advertisement for upcoming and existing video games, exclusive to Nintendo systems. More of these games sold than before BECAUSE of Smash Bros. We describe what is called "the Avengers effect" as bolstering the standalone films like Iron Man 3 (passed a billion) and Thor: the Dark World (surpassed the first one by a half) since they had each appeared in the 2012 blockbuster, which few moviegoers missed.

That said, it'd be better if it were a cartoon show.
MightyZeus
MightyZeus - 8/11/2014, 8:20 PM
I think it can work. I would like to see an NCU.
MuttonMan
MuttonMan - 8/13/2014, 8:05 AM
I would totally watch those...
MuttonMan
MuttonMan - 8/13/2014, 8:07 AM
They should bring all the characters together for a Mario-Kart movie in there somewhere...
StewartGGriffin
StewartGGriffin - 8/24/2014, 2:33 PM
I don't think people are still reading this, but I just want to make some points.

1. Some are complaining that a Sonic movie comes before Mario. Well the only reason that's happening is because the Sonic movie is already in development. No Mario movie is even in development. If Sonic hadn't already been announced I totally would've put Mario as the first film in the NCU. Actually, I wouldn't even include a Sonic until like Phase 2.

2. For that one person that said I ripped off whatculture's list, I didn't. I envisioned my NCU back in 2012. Take a look at the date on that whatculture list.

3. For those saying I'm ripping off the Marvel Cinematic Universe, that's not my intention. Of course something like this is going to be very familiar to the MCU. The DCCU is probably going to contain many similar elements, so the NCU should to. Also, I wouldn't want the Super Smash Bros. to fight Metal Sonic. I don't even know if I would include Metal Sonic in this.

4. To that one guy who said Eggman is the true name of the Sonic villain. I don't care. I never said Robotnik was his real name, I just said that's what I would want him to be called in the movies.

5. And finally, to all those who are saying Sonic isn't a Nintendo property. I. Know. But Nintendo and SEGA have worked together in the past. And being that Sonic HAS ALREADY BEEN ANNOUNCED, that's why he would be part of it.

Well I guess those are the things I wanted to clear up. I doubt anyone will comment back. But thanks to those who do.
View Recorder