Why Marvel/DC Would Benefit From Producing Black Superhero Standalone Films

Why Marvel/DC Would Benefit From Producing Black Superhero Standalone Films

Box office Numbers suggest that Black Superhero movies would in fact attract massive audiences.

Editorial Opinion
By phantom1527 - Jan 25, 2014 12:01 PM EST
Filed Under: Other

People often argue that DC and Marvel shy away from creating movies with Black characters as the protagonists because most moviegoers couldn’t relate as well to it. Many also argue that the two publishers don’t possess any characters popular enough to bring to the big screen.

Box office numbers of several action/superhero movies debunk the theory that the majority of audiences couldn’t relate to black superheroes on film and wouldn’t buy tickets. For example, in 2008 Sony Pictures (who owns Spiderman cinematically) created a movie essentially created around a black Superman called “Hancock”. I will be the first to admit that movie was far from great, but it was able to make over $950,000,000 (adjusted for inflation) in theaters, which is more than films with well known white protagonists made like: “Thor”, “Thor 2”, “ Man of Steel”, “Batman Begins”, “Captain America: The First Avenger”, “The Amazing Spiderman” and others.

A few more examples of action/superhero movies with black protagonists that performed at the box office are “Django Unchained” and “The Book of Eli”. “Django” was basically The Punisher if the punisher was a former slave in the 1850’s. Nearly half of the movie was centered on a black bounty hunter shooting white people and it still made over $430,000,000 (adjusted for inflation) in theaters. “The Book of Eli” was about a black, blind swordsman who was killing his way through America until he reached the west coast. On a relatively small budget and with a modest marketing campaign the movie was still able to make nearly $170,000,000 (adjusted for inflation).

Some also argue that there just aren’t any popular enough characters to put on the big screen. The “Blade” franchise made over $500,000,000 (adjusted for inflation) in theaters and contributed to the rise in the popularity of the superhero genre. Batman, The Punisher, Superman, The Hulk and Spiderman have all had reboots in the past few years, so why not reboot Blade? Special effects have improved immensely since the last movie, and the horror/vampire genre is much more popular than it was 10 years ago. Also, both publishers have seen black characters like John Stewart, Black Panther, Cyborg, Static, Icon, Aqualad and Miles Morales rise in popularity through comic books and television shows. These characters might not be icons like Batman and Superman, but I imagine they have similar if not better name recognition than Ant-Man and The Guardians of the Galaxy.

Your Thoughts?

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking
Related:

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking

REAGAN Interview: Jon Voight On His Approach To Playing A KGB Agent And Pandemic Challenges (Exclusive)
Recommended For You:

REAGAN Interview: Jon Voight On His Approach To Playing A KGB Agent And Pandemic Challenges (Exclusive)

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

BenjiWest
BenjiWest - 1/25/2014, 12:38 PM
Kevin Hart for Cyborg.
kinghulk
kinghulk - 1/25/2014, 12:39 PM
i have never heards someone say a black super hero movie cant work
JorEllinator
JorEllinator - 1/25/2014, 1:47 PM
Not many great black characters, especially on the DC side. John Stewart never had much development, Static was always annoying to me, Mr Terrific was a bit bland so the only great one was Black Lightning, oh and frick Cyborg, just frick him, frick his bland boring dumb ass.
Pedrito
Pedrito - 1/25/2014, 1:51 PM
People seem to be very confused about race and movie characters.
If the character is black, but being black never factors into the story, then the character's race is irrelevant.
Without an interesting story it's difficult to make relatable characters. White children identify with white superheroes just like girls identify with female superheroes. But if the audience is treated like adults, and the characters are fleshed out, then perhaos anyone can relate to whatever character.
It's the way Magneto being a Holocaust survivor helps him be understood as an antihero in First Class. His being Jewish didn't get in the way, but actually helped the audience relate to him.
kong
kong - 1/25/2014, 2:02 PM
Love this article! Needs to be on main. I totally agree and was us prided about the Hancock box office versus the other CBM's. We need Black Panther, Luke Cage, and even Miles Morales to have their own solo films eventually.
kinghulk
kinghulk - 1/25/2014, 2:07 PM
redhood-watched hancock yesterday loved it call me an asshole one more time
Steelmatic
Steelmatic - 1/25/2014, 3:41 PM
I agree wholeheartedly with your sentiments. "Django is basically the Punisher" made me lol though. Wee bit of a reach there... still, good post!
BlackIceJoe
BlackIceJoe - 1/25/2014, 7:04 PM
I agree wholeheartedly with this. I know in the past Terrence Howard wanted to do a Black Lightning movie and now that he is not doing Iron Man he could star in that movie. If a BL movie is made though it also has to star his daughters Anissa and Jennifer Pierce. I want none of the new 52 crap that says Jefferson can't have any kids.

I was thinking some of these guys could handle the job for either Cyborg, Azrael or Guardian. But I think there is a far greater chance of seeing Cyborg before Guardian. Plus I don't think the next Solo Batman will show Azrael.

Ashley Walters


Devon Anderson


Robert Gilbert


Elliot Knight


I so would love to see a DC Comics movie showing Icon. The character very rarely gets any love from DC. I totally could see an Icon and Rocket movie doing well. But sadly that movie is years from happening.

But Marvel is a different story. I can't understand why Black Panther is not in the cards yet. I hope after Guardians of the Galaxy comes out that will be one of the 2016 movies that comes out. I also would like to see Isaiah Bradley be in Captain America 3 when that comes out. Also if there is to be another Hulk movie it would be cool to see Tyrone Cash in that film too.
naterator
naterator - 1/25/2014, 7:56 PM
Shoot..... Instead of rebooting BLADE... I would just as soon see Marvel introduce Wesley Snipes'BLADE in one of Marvels future films as cameo or part of a wider Avengers cast. We already have very decent films for that character. It would be sweet to see Snipes reprise as BLADE... what does it matter if he's older? That shows diversity. It really doesn't make any of sense to have all the heroes / villains around the same age. Just my opinion opinion.
MightyZeus
MightyZeus - 1/26/2014, 8:47 AM
I really do agree with this article. The success and great job from the film Hancock and Django always made me think that a film based on a black hero would be amazing. John Stewart would be interesting if he where to get his own solo film. Also Black Panther would be great.
MuttonMan
MuttonMan - 1/26/2014, 10:06 AM
I don't think you can reboot Blade right now... I think that people are too "vampired" out right now... you're going to have to give it at least five more years, if not longer...
CharlesLord
CharlesLord - 1/26/2014, 1:08 PM
really quick, I dont think Eli in "Book of Eli" was blind. I think he just knew how to read brail. Anyway...

I still say a BP movie is being announced for phase 3, theres been a lot of fans asking for it. Plus I think with Ultron being introduced so early, we might get a cameo in AoU.

Regarding Blade, Id love to see a Blade movie reboot. I think everyone being "vampired" out will help it cuz its not the twilight or true blood type of vampire movie. Its vampires getting the shit killed out of them so I think itll have the advantage of "finally someones here to kill these assholes" angle going for it. But I dont want a blade movie until im ready to be cast in the role lol
naterator
naterator - 1/26/2014, 2:27 PM
@mutton man.. That's why you don't reboot BLADE. JUST CAMEO WESLEY SNIPES IN CURRENT MARVEL UNIVERSE. THAT WOULD MAKE THE MOST SENSE.it would be vampire over kill to reboot him.
Doughdzm
Doughdzm - 1/27/2014, 11:09 AM
Man this is sad. Introducing a Black superhero is not the problem. I think the problem is more having a black lead character non-sidekick really just be badass is what people are opposed to. I mean think aboutr it we have Black widow, Hawkeye, and now Antman. You cannot tell me Black Panther is more relevant than this. Marvel started with Blade because they had no expectations for the film it was a money grab for them. Now that CBM are all the rave. They will not make a black lead for (insert whatever you like). We are going to be bombarded with lesser heroes until the genre goes way of the Western and then we will see more black heroes when money is no longer the issue. Now as far as people being in an uproar about which Hero. I ask that you do me a favor and show me where in the comics do we see an agent Phil Coulson.. Make one
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 3:24 PM
Havoc rode the wave of will smith fame wich since has waned considerably. Basicaly he was at the hight of his box office powers at that time. Studios know this and that movie would fail today. Dejango sold on the streanth of quinton Tarantinos name. That movie rreleased by any other director besides Scorsese is a flop. Book of eli.... thanx Denzel and your training day fame, now too old he can not carry a super hero movie.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 3:27 PM
Black people make up a small portion of a movies audiance. They only represent 12% of the American population. That being said they serve well as an addition to a franchise and for getting blacks paying for movie tix.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 3:31 PM
In the manner of involving them into the story line but not carrying a solo movie. As an exsample we need look know further than red tails. A lucas production that no studio would touch cause they know the numbers. He lost so much on that gamble he sold starwars to Disney shorty after that turky floped.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 3:37 PM
There are countless attempts at doing this, black horror, blackploytation films, comidy but the numbers just dont jive unless the production costs of producing the movie is low. Hence black comidy movies. But hundreds of millions of dollars in fx n post production is a bad bet on a black super hero. Look at spawn.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 3:40 PM
There would be a much better chance of bringing sucsess to a black comic book hero via a telivision series. Contingent upon that sucsess than maybe a lead movie.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 5:13 PM
A much safer bet for studios producing an ethnic hero would be the latino lead woman or man. Shazam! Wonderwoman. Not kazam! Thank you Shaq. Lmao but yes a latino
Lead super hero. One there is not this weight of having to have it, like a black hero . And two. Latinos represent a much much larger portion of the american populace. Also south america is an emerging market place as far as ticket sales on a global scale, much more of a player to Carter to as opposed to africa. Also the transition from the comon place eurocentric face we are accustomed to seeing in a hero`s roll is less abrasives. In essence a gradual darkening of our heros is more paletable than a bold jump from white to black. So a broader audiance is accepting of the change, in more parts of the world. Spanish is americas second language so it would be nice to see that utalized as well. Ebonics is a colorefull change as well yet it only apeals to the least common denominator amoungst us. So concluding it is a no brainer that studios refocus there more inclusive efforts on the Latin comunity and not the black comunity as there small demographic dose not call for a need to make a black hero befor that of a latin hero its priority.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 5:24 PM
Hemo goblin only speaks the truth...... and remember the movie business is just that.... a business first. So money talks and BS walks so untill a black lead can cary a big budget supper hero movie and make bookoo bucks we wont see one.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 5:31 PM
How ever there is a chance. Studios make turkeys on purpose to show an economic losse to there ac[foo foo]ants and investors at the end of the fiscal yr. It is a nessasary evil to report economic liabiliry and loss at tax time especially in big business. That being said some flops are made to balance the books so to speek. Of course there will be no intentional turky in this cash bonanza of comicbookmovies untill the geners slows its sucsess. Thats when you will get the black panther.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 5:45 PM
Knowing the business of movies makes it easier to predict what the studios are planing NNext. Think like a business man and not a fan and it all becomes much more transparent. Lots of genres come and go. Blacksploitation films, westerns, karata movies, car movies smokie and the bandit, mad max, musicals and the list goes on. They all have comebacks from time to time but esentionaly die. Swim movies, beach movies in the 1960s they all cycle out. Watching what hapens in those trends


trends and you will spot the next cycle comming. Right now is the comicbookmovie golden age
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 5:50 PM
So the inevitable is upon us. Bad movies and gimmicks to invigorate lagging sales. Hollywood beats every horse till it dies. Its all verry formatted so its easy to predict. Sorry to say that a black lead hero movie will be a gimmick to revive a dieing horse but it will. If history dose anything it repeats it self. Maybe one day we will learn from its mistakes.
Hemogoblin
Hemogoblin - 1/28/2014, 6:00 PM
Any one remember bruce lee movies. They made tons of money mostly produced in china. Then produced in america and then he dies. The next thing you know there are movies with guys named bruce lee that aren't him. Threw out the 70s then in the 80s you get bruce leroy and the the genra ends. Enter big 80s action heros. Leprican goes to the hood killed that franchise. I could go on and on.... but why, trust me a black lead in a non black movie usealy siganels the death of a genere. And big shot movie honchos no this. So you wont see it not yet anyway.
Doughdzm
Doughdzm - 1/29/2014, 3:57 PM
First off Hemoglobin, learn how to spell. Secondly are you out of your mind with these statements. Do you not remember Will Smith who was the most surefire hitmaker along with Tom Cruise during the 90's and 2000's do you not remember Denzel. Or better yet do you not remember what started the modern day CBM's with Blade and Spawn. Do you not remember Marvel superheroes not making anything near decent like the first Captain America or the Punisher. Do you not remember Batman Post Michael Keaton with the all white cast that may be regarded as some of the worst CBM's of all time. The quality of the movie in dependent on the effort involved. If you want to make a movie succeed take your time and do the work. that is all that is needed. As cliche as Hancock was, it was actually a good movie. Go dig in the crates and learn more about the movies Hemoglobin
View Recorder