EDITORIAL: Why Taylor Momsen Should Be Gwen Stacy

EDITORIAL: Why Taylor Momsen Should Be Gwen Stacy

USER SPOTLIGHT: AverageCitizen99's explains at length why this Gossip Girl should be Spidey's girl.

Editorial Opinion
By AverageCitizen99 - Jul 01, 2010 10:07 PM EST
Filed Under: The Amazing Spider-Man

Taylor Momsen may come from Gossip Girl but she is one of the top fan choices for the role of Gwen Stacy in Marc Webb’s upcoming Spidey-boot. She also happens to be my #1 choice for the role. For anyone who might not know her, here is a background description:



“Taylor Momsen was born July 26, 1993 in St. Louis, Missouri to Michael and Collette Momsen. Her younger sister Sloane Momsen is also an actress. She has attended the Professional Performing Arts High School (P.P.A.S.) in New York City and COCA in St. Louis where she took dance and martial arts classes at a young age.

Taylor has been acting professionally since the age of three when she was just starting out in commercials. She was most known at the age of seven for playing Cindy Lou Who in Jim Carey’s 'How the Grinch Stole Christmas.' Her other film credits include ‘Hansel & Gretel,’ ‘Saving Shiloh,’ ‘Underdog,’ and ‘Paranoid Park.’ On television she was cast as the lead of the never-aired WB series 'Misconceptions.' At thirteen she auditioned for the title role of Hannah Montana, and was one of the top three actresses, but lost the role to Miley Cyrus. She is, as of 2007, currently starring in the popular CW series ‘Gossip Girl’ as Jenny Humphrey.

Ms. Momsen is also a singer-songwriter. She’s confessed to have been writing songs since she was five. In 2002 she recorded 'Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer’ and ‘One Small Voice’ featuring Myra and Camille Winbush for the Christmas album ‘School’s Out! Christmas.’ In 2009 she formed her band, the Pretty Reckless. The hiatus of ‘Gossip Girl' and the absence of her character for most of its fourth season will give her enough time to tour and promote their first album, ‘Light Me Up.’”



Those of us that chose her have pretty good reasons why she should be considered for the part. So to follow up with my recent Gwen Stacy articles, I’ve decided to write an editorial showcasing my personal reasons why ‘Lil Jenny’ Taylor Momsen should be Gwen Stacy in Marc Webb’s yet-to-be titled Spider-Man!


Appearance

Taylor fits the requirements perfectly. She’s cute, she’s young, she looks blond -- she’s the girlfriend you would want if you ever spent a class session with her.

Ms. Taylor is also a young lady with style. At fourteen, she signed on to IMG models and as of now is the face of the Britain fashion chain New Look, for their Spring/Summer 2010 collection. That and she was voted number 76 on People Magazine’s 100 Most Beautiful People list for 2009.

I know this is trivial and expected, but in my opinion she does look like Gwen Stacy would if she was a teenager. As I said, this is my opinion. We all have them, especially in fan casts.

She can bring audiences the look and personality of the classic Gwen that Peter fell for…



And, if they ever decided to, could even bring in the grungy attitude of the Ultimate Ms. Stacy.



Don’t misread me. I want the classic Gwen to appear on the big screen as much as the rest of you fine folks do. I am simply pointing out that Taylor’s style of clothing could be best described as bipolar: switching from the precious, delicate looking Jenny Humphrey of Gossip Girl to the down-and-dirty garb that she envelopes over herself as lead of the Pretty Reckless. As the classic Gwen, she can be there for Peter when he needs someone there for consoling; but as the ultimate Gwen, she can be there ready to break someone’s nose for him if she had to.


Age

This is a personal pet peeve of mine. An issue that is the most redundant in the teen genre is the casting of older actors rather than performers of, or around, the same age range. It is a trend that has been going around since the genre even started. Whether this reboot is supposed to be set in high school or college, I expect there to be actual teenagers playing teenage characters.

Andrew's announcement as Peter Parker has come with word that the setting could change from high school to college, so why would there still be the need for teenage actors? When you start high school you are a teenager, and when you leave high school and go to college you are still technically a teenager. Taylor is at the right age to be playing a teenager, and a college student at that. She is barely going to be seventeen in a few weeks. When filming begins she will be seventeen and once the film finally premieres she will be a few weeks shy of being eighteen. The only concern left visibly is the age difference between them both as Andrew is ten years Taylor's senior. Taylor's appearance and figure have recently been filling out quite nicely so I think, despite the age gap, they could both pull it off.

Quid Pro Quo

Taylor’s involvement in Spider-Man could bring in publicity for both parties.

Taylor is most familiar to teens and tweens, mostly tweens, as Jenny on the CW’s hit drama Gossip Girl. This series has a huge following amongst female audiences, so Taylor playing Gwen could influence both her fans and fans of the series to come see the film. Basically, this could be the same outcome that could come out of Blake Lively’s involvement in Green Lantern. Most people have no clue who Green Lantern is, but they’ll soon know when they see Serena Van Der Woodsen come to the aid of our GL rookie, Hal Jordan. Being part of the Spider-Man franchise could also make Taylor more recognizable than before.

Most boys probably aren’t interested in seeing what their girlfriends are watching on television: shallow sex-crazed vampires, the hundredth medical drama to have come out, rich girls back-stabbing each other time and time again for the sake of creating entertainment or the dumb but pretty teens that mustn’t have been raised to believe in either shame nor common sense from their own parents. They might not know who she is unless they happened to have caught sight of that cute/hot possibly-over-eighteen looking blond girl on TV while flipping channels. Once the boys see her as Spidey’s big crush, he won’t be the only one crushing on her.

For people who don’t know about director Marc Webb’s past credentials behind (500) Days of Summer, he directed music videos. He chose to cast actress/musician Zooey Deschanel as hapless Joseph Gordon-Levitt’s former manic pixie dream girl Summer Finn; who was described in the original script as being blond rather than brunette. She is the vocalist for the indie group She & Him. I’m not saying that Taylor should sing in this film… here come the unnecessary Spider-Man 3 flashbacks. Maybe Marc still has a soft spot for musicians. Giving the role to Taylor would allow her to include a song of hers onto the soundtrack. It could simply be a song she had already recorded for one of her albums or one she could create specifically for the film. Having part in the film is a tit-for-tat for Taylor whether she’s starring or just donating a song. In an interview on Celebrity TV Lounge she had openly confessed that she and her band mates are “… all big comic book fans;” like we haven’t heard that line before, but the proof is on the guitar.




Talent

Taylor was born into talent. She started acting when she was just a toddler and had been writing songs since the tender age of five. She hasn’t been in many films that could let you see her acting ability up, front and center besides the Grinch, but she did appear in the 2007 Gus Van Sant film, Paranoid Park. She played Jennifer (What a coinki-dink), the troubled protagonist’s girlfriend. She was possibly the only professional actor out of the whole film, which mainly consisted of random people Mr. Van Sant had casted from social websites like MySpace. I thought she was okay in it.

Then there’s the Pretty Reckless. I remember hearing about them when Taylor stopped by the Alexa Chung Show. Yes, I did watch that show at the time. If it makes you feel better, I started to dislike it with everything else associated with MTV. Then KICK-ASS came out and I decided to check out the soundtrack. Under the track listings down at number six was "'Make Me Wanna Die’ by ‘The Pretty Reckless.’" I had sworn I had heard that name before. I previewed the songs on YouTube and then I instantly remembered who they were when I clicked on the video displayed to me. This isn’t the exact video that I discovered at the time, but I was in utter shock and awe while listening to this song.



A voice like that can come out of a girl my age!? No one would expect something like that to come out of a teenage girl’s mouth unless they mixed something up at the recording studio. In case you happen to be a doubter, here is a live acoustic version from a session that they performed from London:



This single had the honor of being featured at the beginning of the closing credits; right when the film finished itself with off with a bang. The song has garnered good reception so far. It was #16 on the UK Singles Chart and #1 on the United Kingdom Rock Chart for six weeks. Digital Spy’s Nick Levine gave the single 4 out of 5 stars, calling it “…a bit of a blast… As for that singer - Taylor Momsen, name fans - well, she gives good enough 'tude here to suggest those Serious Music Fans might just be cutting off their sneering gear.” The EP hasn’t particularly inherited any similar praise. Christian Hoard of the Rolling Stones gave it 2 out of 5 stars, describing it as “long on generic hard-rock riffs and gothic poetry.”

The rest of the above, despite mixed reactions to her singing stint, supports my opinion that Taylor is a versatile enough performer who could do justice to the role, with the right push. Under Marc’s supervision, I believe Taylor could successfully bring Gwen Stacy to the big screen.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If you are finished, answer down on this poll whether or not you would like it if Taylor Momsen was picked by Marc Webb to be Gwen Stacy in his Spider-Man film.



------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Thank you all for giving up some time to read my editorial and thanks again to all of you who continue to read my material. I’d like to give a special thanks to Osiris for pointing out the image of Taylor as the ultimate version of Gwen. Answer down on the comments section concerning what you thought about this. Do you still like Taylor as a choice for Gwen Stacy? Before I finally sign off, remember when I brought up that idea about Taylor putting one of her songs into the soundtrack? I think the lyrics of this next song fit in with the “gritty and contemporary” emotions of the new Peter Parker and the challenges he faces in his lives as himself and Spider-Man. To end this editorial, I’d like to present you all with an encore presentation from the Pretty Reckless with their song ‘Heart.’

Until next time, this has been your Average Citizen!



Lyrics:

Never wanted to feel
Never wanted to feel my heart
Never wanted to go
Never wanted to show I’m weak

I'm fallen all over myself
Tryin’ to be someone else
I Wish you would dare to walked me home
I don't wanna have to be alone

Always wanted to be
Always wanted to see my heart
Always wanted you're love
Always wanted but never was

I'm fallen all over myself
Tryin to be someone else
I Wish you would dare to walked me home
I don't wanna have to be alone

I'm fallen all over myself
Dyin' to be someone else
I wish you would dare to walk me home
I don’t wanna fight the world alonnnneeeee. . .

(Musical Break)

Always told you before
Never loved you more. . .

I'm fallen all over myself
Tryin’ to be someone else
I Wish you would dare to walked me home
I don't wanna have to be alone

I'm fallen all over myself
Dyin' to be someone else
I wish you would dare to walk me home
I don’t wanna fight the world alonnnneeeee. . .

I don’t wanna fight the world alonnnneeeee. . .
I don’t wanna fight the world alonnnneeeee. . .
Alonneeee. . .

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If any of you want to check out some other content of mine like pictures or vids, check out my main page right here:

MY Library for Any Little Thing

Or check out my articles right here:

ARTICLES
POLL: A Gwen For Jamie
VOTING RESULTS: A Gwen For Jamie
REVIEW: The Spider-Man Reboot Script


EDITORIALS
Correctly Handling Venom, Without Any Health Problems
VENOM: the Lethal Spin-Off


FAN CASTS
MY Spider-Man Reboot(s): What Could Have Been and What Could Be
Hot Toys Celebrates THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN With Spectacularly Detailed New 1/6th Scale Action Figure
Related:

Hot Toys Celebrates THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN With Spectacularly Detailed New 1/6th Scale Action Figure

THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN Returns To Theaters With Spidey's Lowest Re-Release Haul To Date
Recommended For You:

THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN Returns To Theaters With Spidey's Lowest Re-Release Haul To Date

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

TANKGIRL
TANKGIRL - 7/2/2010, 2:33 AM
great article i love it and i support your cast for gwen

she 's really talented but this day taylor is such miley cyrus copie cat

AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 5:52 AM
@TANKGIRL
Thanks a lot for your support! :)
And I support Amanda Seyfried for Gwen too. ;)
Taylor and Miley are something I'm thinking of mentioning in my second part. This part was meant to address the positive aspects of what could come from her casting. The next part, if I ever make it since I'm stuck and need to take a brake, will focus on the negative aspect of what could impact the film. Thank you so much for reading. I worked really hard on this for what's been going two weeks now. Thank you so much. :)
TANKGIRL
TANKGIRL - 7/2/2010, 6:18 AM
AverageCitizen99 no probleme
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 7/2/2010, 6:25 AM
AverageCitizen @ Congrats dude, you made MAIN! ; )

And you've sold me!

I liked AMANDA SEYFRIED better but TAYLOR is more pefect foe GWEN now, especially with the new SPIDEY guy cast!

Yeah I'll still hate the reboot with a passion lol, but fingers crossed you get your wish! ; )



LEEE777
LEEE777 - 7/2/2010, 6:34 AM
GR8 read man!
TANKGIRL
TANKGIRL - 7/2/2010, 6:41 AM
no it's your turn to read mine AverageCitizen99

check this

can jessica alba plays a wild gal?

congrats you made to the main
zeonsdemon
zeonsdemon - 7/2/2010, 7:19 AM
she look way better than the chick from spidey 3
JoshWilding
JoshWilding - 7/2/2010, 7:42 AM
Wow, amazing article man! :) The casting editorials I do look lazy in comparison to this epic, lol! I think she'd make a brilliant Gwen Stacy...or a pretty good Liz Allen if she loses out on that role!
UnfriendlySpidey
UnfriendlySpidey - 7/2/2010, 7:50 AM
Great article @Avereage! I agree w/you 100% she'd play an amazing Gwen....Y'HEAR THAT MARC WEBB??!! WE WANT TAYLOR MOMSEN FOR GWEN!!! HEED OUR CALLS!! haha
flames809
flames809 - 7/2/2010, 8:11 AM
she looks the part and can act so why not
mk
mk - 7/2/2010, 9:18 AM
too young :))
droopy1317
droopy1317 - 7/2/2010, 9:32 AM
what about taylor swift? kanye west can be the villain. lol. na, great article, she looks the part
OmegaBlack13
OmegaBlack13 - 7/2/2010, 9:35 AM
She looks the part, right age, and she can actually act, so I vote yes. Her for Gwen and Emma Roberts for MJ in a sequel!
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 10:12 AM
Wow! Thanks to all of you for making all that hard work pay off! :D

@LEEE777
I didn't think I'd make main. Thanks again for supporting me through and through. I can't believe it had an impact on you, it's an awesome feeling. I hope we do get either one for Gwen. It's a shame you feel the way you do about the reboot, but who knows. Thanks again my friend! :)

@TANKGIRL
I'll be sure to check it! Just a little quid pro quo. ;)

@JoshW
It means alot coming from someone like you. I think you're editorials are still great. I guess I just had a lot of thoughts and ideas about her that I wanted to put on and show you all. It was supposed to be an observation of the good and bad that could come from her involvement but I'm still stuck on the 'negative' opinion (been for a week). With a lot of the editorials that come out on this site, I just decided to split them up all together. It might come in a copule of weeks, but who knows. Thanks for your support! Even if she misses out, she'd still make a good Liz. :)

@UnfriendlySpidey
Thanks so much! I'm also working on a second part that showcases my one reason why she shouldn't be the part but it doesn't compare to the positives that could come from what I just wrote. I'm just gonna take a long brake from it at the moment just to rest my brain and for the upcoming family time. If there was an internet poll or, I forgot what it's called, that could show support for the actor/actress to play the part I would sign it in a heartbeat. I hope your reading or listening to this Marc! ;)

@pig
Yeah, but if you check out my picture gallery or some of her recent pictures she actually looks more mature for her age. She could pull off being a college student... she did finish high school after all. ;)

@droopy1317
Thanks alot!

@OmegaBlack13
I'm right behind you on that!

Thanks again for everyone who read and voted! This took a long time to make and I'm glad to see it was worth it. :)
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 10:14 AM
Oh! And thanks again to the editors of this great site! I've been coming here since possibly 2007 or somewhere around that time and I've been coming here ever since. I can't see any other site but this to go check out my daily news on. Thanks again and keep up the great work. :)
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 10:20 AM
Now it's time for a new poll. With the reception I'm getting so far with this, I just want to know if you want me to make a second part. This was originally supposed to focus on the good and bad that would come from Taylor's casting. Since a lot of editorials come by this site I decided to just upload the positives first and work on the negative another time. The other reasons were because it might've been too long and I've been stuck on working on the other half or third for about a week. So after this do you want me to work on the other half?



Leave your comments below and I will be getting back to cleaning once I'm finished looking around this site. Thanks.
TANKGIRL
TANKGIRL - 7/2/2010, 11:17 AM
just take break think of other subject to talk about i really loved this one i hope to see more of your work

your article in google news i just googled taylor momsen as gwen

http://www.google.com/search?q=taylor%20momsen%20gwen%20stacy&hl=en&gbv=2&ndsp=20&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=iw
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 12:03 PM
@TANKGIRL
Thanks for the pat on the shoulder. It's on Google?! Oh my God! :D

I just checked it out, and it is on Google! Thanks for the news! I hope Marc, some of the casting agents, or Taylor herself check it out. (Keeping fingers crossed!)
:)
GoGoGadgetsBruh
GoGoGadgetsBruh - 7/2/2010, 12:47 PM
haha dude thats awesome it's on google :D
good job and nice article i'd accept her as either version of MJ
but I dont think i'd want a 16 year old Gwen and a 26 year old Peter :/
Sony really dropped the ball with that one (again)
TANKGIRL
TANKGIRL - 7/2/2010, 2:30 PM

AverageCitizen99 if taylor si going to check thi i should deleted the word miley copie cat
sevenolecram
sevenolecram - 7/2/2010, 3:13 PM
Taylor would be great if they had cast Logan Lerman to play Spidey.

With 27 year-old Andrew Garfield playing Peter, we need an older Gwen.

I would go with Amanda Seyfried. She's blond, beautiful, 24 year-old and can act.

In the sequel MJ should be Mary Elizabeth Winstead. She's 25 and one of the hottest young actresses. Dye her hair and she's the perfect MJ.
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 4:26 PM
@Gotbatman
Thanks buddy! It's okay about what you think about the whole age thing. This was written weeks before the announcement about Andrew was made so I had to update it. She does look more mature for her age though but I doubt it too. Just a suggestion. Thanks again! :)

@TANKGIRL
LOL, I doubt she would even bother since she probably doesn't check the internet about herself. ;)

@djvasco
You're right about that. With the setting possibly changing from high school to college it would make sense to follow the new age range. I think Taylor could pull it off though if Marc ever thought about it. She looks more mature for her age (some user comments say that they thought she looked like she was twenty).



Mary Elizabeth would make a fantastic MJ. A past script review said that MJ is going to appear in the film but that could change as with other scripts. Thanks again! :)
bleedthefreak
bleedthefreak - 7/2/2010, 5:04 PM
she is hot and talented and holy shit great work man truly awesome editorial
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 6:31 PM
@bleedthefreak16
Thanks for the support and I'm glad you liked it! :)
What did you think about the age difference though? I had written this about 2 weeks before it was announced that Andrew was cast. You think she might still work with Andrew and all?
bleedthefreak
bleedthefreak - 7/2/2010, 6:58 PM
@AverageCitizen99 yeah the age difference is a little...um illegal(and creepy) but hell i still think she would make one hell of a Gwen Stacey or Liz Allen
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 7:38 PM
@wolverinesfury
It's okay. You have the right to your own opinion and I welcome it. You made good points of your own though. I created this editorial two weeks before it was announced that Andrew got the role, so I was making this with the idea of either Josh or some other teenage actor. In Paranoid Park, she was a weak point and she didn't fit well with the film because a lot of the other actors weren't experienced. All of the actors involved in the film had no acting experience and I could tell from how they delivered their lines. I felt Taylor was one of the few that was trying and that is what made her come out as different than everybody else. I still enjoyed the film and I said in the editorial that she was okay in it; not great, but okay. And I know the age difference, I had to update the editorial because of him. I would be okay with another actress around Andrew's age, like you said, but my opinion is that Taylor looks more mature for her age. Andrew will be playing a Peter Parker that is barely going to college and so the age of the character in the film should be 17 or 18, that is the age at which Andrew is playing Peter. Taylor is going to be 17 when the month ends.



Amanda would make a good Gwen Stacy though, like you said. I'm glad you gave me your honest opinion and thanks for the feedback! :)
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/2/2010, 8:25 PM
@wolverinesfury
I forgot, this editorial was originally supposed to showcase both my reasons to why and my reason as to why not. I might work on it a little but if you're interested keep on eye out for it. Thanks again. :)
lc
lc - 7/3/2010, 5:44 PM
well done i like it :)
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/3/2010, 8:00 PM
@lc
Thanks for taking a look, I'm planning on a follow-up involving the negative side of her casting if you're interested. Glad you liked it ma'am. :)
Jordacar
Jordacar - 7/4/2010, 12:28 AM
It would be so groundbreaking for them to actually cast a blonde to play a blonde for a change. (See: Mary Jane, Invisible Woman, Pepper potts, Storm, Carol Ferris, etc.)
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/4/2010, 8:32 AM
@Jordacar
Now that you mention it, it would be for them. Hopefully they start to hire people with the same hair color. Is that so hard for them? ;)
UnfriendlySpidey
UnfriendlySpidey - 7/4/2010, 10:37 PM
hey Average! check out my fancast!! i put this article as a link in it to back up why i think momsen should be gwen! check it out and let me know what you think dude!

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/news/default.aspx?a=19749
AverageCitizen99
AverageCitizen99 - 7/4/2010, 10:54 PM
@UnfriendlySpidey
Oh My God! It's awesome that you mentioned me in your article, it especially flatters me that you stuck by my opinions. This really means a lot to me. Thank you so much.
View Recorder