MAN OF STEEL REVIEW

MAN OF STEEL REVIEW

A fan who doesn´t care what the critics say

Review Opinion
By ultimatefan1974 - Jul 06, 2013 02:07 PM EST
Filed Under: Superman
Source: ComicBookMovie.com

MAN OF STEEL REVIEW

i´m not usually the "screw critics" kinda movie fan, I learned a lot about storytelling from reading reviews. But it doesn´t mean I have to agree with them. Maybe they´re jaded from so many superhero origin movies, which I understand, and I was even afraid of that aspect of MOS.

But the movie did overall a great job at avoiding the two things I was the most afraid of: feeling like a remake of the first two Supes movies and being too close to that infamous JJ Abrams script where Krypton didn´t explode and there was some prophecy BS. The movie presents everything again with a fresh take and, like Nolan´s Dark Knight trilogy, it borrows from all the best versions: as I was seeing, I was constantly thinking, "oh, that´s inspired by the Animated Series pilot, that´s a Mark Waid thing, that´s Jeph Loeb", etc.

Comparisons to Michael Bay are just stupid. This actually feels a lot like seeing those great no-nonsense sci-fi films from the late 1970s, early 1980s, like an Alien or a Close Encounters, but for the gamer generation (more on that later). Make no mistake, more than a superhero movie this is a sci-film, kinda like a modern take on things like The Day Earth Stood Still, and sci-fi is very much what Siegel and Schuster had in mind when they created Superman, there was no "superhero genre" before the character came out. Even the FX overall have a very gritty, naturalistic look.

The cast is all around great. Cavill is the right blend of masculine and powerful yet kind and vulnerable for a more humanized take on the character. This is not a darker or depressed Superman, but a conflicted one between two worlds, the dead one of Krypton that didn´t accept difference, and an Earth that hasn´t been too kind on him for it either. Amy Adams has a natural likability that makes Lois less bitchy and Michael Shannon is as commanding and intimidating as Zod must be, although this version has more understandable reasons and goals than the one from the 1980 movie.

Now, for the controversial ending: yes, we all know Supes is not supposed to kill, but in that situation he was like the police sniper: policemen are trained to avoid killing, but when the suspect is pointing a gun to an innocent hostage´s head and you have one shot to take him down, you take him down. And it´s not like he shrugged it off, it tore him apart to do it, but Zod forced his hand. One can argue Zod had a death wish, his whole purpose for existing was gone, he had nothing, he meant to push Supes to killing him while performing one last act of contempt for humankind.

Is it a flawless movie? No, maybe trying to overcompensate for all the complaints about lack of action in SR, it goes a little overkill in that area, although the action scenes themselves are quite impressive, the pacing is a little too breakneck sometimes, could allow the character bits to breathe a little more at times, as the romance between Supes and Lois feels a bit rushed. Could also have used a little more humor here and there.

But overall, I think the reboot is off to a great start and I can´t wait to see their versions of Luthor (some Brainiac, please), etc.

8 OUT OF 10

SUPERMAN Director James Gunn Reveals An Interesting New Detail About Anthony Carrigan's Metamorpho
Related:

SUPERMAN Director James Gunn Reveals An Interesting New Detail About Anthony Carrigan's Metamorpho

SUPERMAN Star Nicholas Hoult Teases Lex Luthor Role As Rumors Swirl About First Trailer Debut
Recommended For You:

SUPERMAN Star Nicholas Hoult Teases Lex Luthor Role As Rumors Swirl About First Trailer Debut

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

jojofmd
jojofmd - 7/6/2013, 8:46 PM
Great review!! I loved it. I was a huge Smallville fan, (yes it had it's detraction's but was a fresh modern take on the Clark and Lex dynamic). What I thought was the biggest weakness was Johnathon Kent. Honestly was not the biggest fan of how is character was portrayed. His advice to Clark at times was good, but John Schneider was a stronger, more convincing Pa Kent. Yes, he had 5 seasons to do so but I felt that while he is supposed to be one of the more influential relationships that Clark has, his character was squandered a bit. However, I didn't have huge concerns about the ending. It made sense on many different levels and you could feel his anguish at his decision. One he will probably overthink and regret to some degree. I also saw that this relationship with Lois was more grounded. it was built on trust. On a leap of faith and isn't that what relationships, the long lasting kind, supposed to be built on. So yes it was different, but it didn't seem as far-fetched as many reviewers had lead me to believe.
acheronmagnuz
acheronmagnuz - 7/7/2013, 7:29 AM
Nice review.. It's hard to trust critics nowadays..
bronzetiger01
bronzetiger01 - 7/7/2013, 9:46 AM
very well written, simple but it gets your points through
lucio7lopez
lucio7lopez - 7/8/2013, 2:11 AM
Very good review. I give 10/10 to the movie, freaking epic!
heath7s
heath7s - 7/8/2013, 3:20 AM
I give your review 10/10! I couldn't agree with you more. you're spot on about it being a scifi film like those from 70s/80s except MOS has the advantage of modern day SFX. Also, I feel the same way about Superman killing Zod- Zod did force his hand and it wasn't an easy decision but Zod himself says earlier (something like) "this ends only one way. either you die or I do". great work!
ultimatefan1974
ultimatefan1974 - 7/8/2013, 7:35 AM
Thanks guys. Can´t wait for the sequel!
jp688
jp688 - 7/12/2013, 4:19 PM
Two words: THANK YOU!
View Recorder