Anil Rickly's Review - ALL STAR-SUPERMAN

Anil Rickly's Review - ALL STAR-SUPERMAN

...The Man of Steel faces foes familiar...and threats anew...Can he look into the eyes of mortality...and can he look into the eyes of his Love...?...Can he say goodbye...

Review Opinion
By earzmundo - Feb 13, 2011 12:02 AM EST
Filed Under: Animated Features

ALL-STAR SUPERMAN



Grant Morrison spun a high-concept tale that ran from November 2005 and ended a 12-issue run in October 2008, coupled with the immaculate art of Frank Quitely. It drew rave acclaim and was generally well-received with the 2006 Eisner win for 'Best New Series' as well as the 2007, 2009 'Best Continuing Series' Eisners. Harvey Awards in 2008 for 'Best Single Issue' and 'Best Artist' rounded off a pristine slate of accolades for this run, and while it has not been my favorite tale of the Man of Steel, throw in some Eagle Awards in 2006, 2007 and it's clear that Grant matches his own high feats with another measured dose of revamping, rehashing and retooling...as he strips Superman down to his bare essentials, his most humanity-gripping aspects, and seizes the chance to relay a story out-of-continuity...to blow the minds of readers of DC. While it did not sit as my most accepted Superman tale, it definitely engaged readers to step their intellect up a level as he threw spokes in the wrenches of high concept moldings of the man-turned-Superman, and etched fatigues into those who expected an arbitrary tale that wouldn't test the limits of avid Superman fans...Take note well...Love him or hate him...from Final Crisis to his past DC tales...and his enigmatic runs of modern Batman tellings...every single thing Grant does, we need to pay close attention to...everything he does...may not turn to gold...but it's calculated...and there's always an end-point...Grant weaves a quintessential web that encourages all readers to think outside the box...and he does what he sets out to all the time...shake the entropy of all those whose eyes gleam onto his pages...

Now, the question bodes...Could this conceptualized tale of a deconstruction of Superman from ground zero be translated and reconstituted to the usually impressive DC ANIMATED MOVIES? Or would we end up grasping at flailing straws and insipid overtures?


Dwayne McDuffie takes on writing duties as he did on Justice League: Crisis on 2 Earths, Justice League: The Series, Ben-10, Static Shock, Teen Titans etc. He also is versed in DC COMICS such as 'JLA, Firestorm', and even has a decent arsenal of Marvel titles to his name such as 'Fantastic Four, Deathlok and Beyond!' to name a few...and he's quite revered with his array of comic-scribes complimenting his animation forays.
Sam Liu directs this film, with the likes of Bruce Timm and Andrea Romano, always overseeing with an altruistic sense of reassurance. When they're onboard, little goes wrong...safe to say! The backroom staff was well structured and it remained to see how this tale would match the books...and would the critical reception be promising with that on-screen?


The Film -
The story starts with Superman saving the day atypical to what we know of our boyscout- with Dr. Leo Quintum and his space mission team falling prey to the squalors of Lex Luthor. Superman is brilliantly voiced by James Denton as he gives a logic, rational...yet charmingly human feel to the character...mature and wise...cool, calm, confident and collected under pressure; but Anthony LaPaglia steals the show with his conniving machinations and scheming sense of purpose in the movie. He's as sneer and snide as Denton is charismatic and charming. They add a lovely rival-feeling to them, a yin-yang sort of texture that is most welcome.

It's a lurid plot by Luthor that sees Superman saving Quintum's crew at a full-price...Superman has been exposed to radiation that not only empowers him, but is killing him. It's a tale of decay and wither, and comes with our protagonist now facing the one thing he never worried much for, Mortality. This story is how he deals with inevitable death...and also, how he factors his loved ones into the web...with Lois Lane taking spotlight.



Christina Hendricks voices Lane nicely and there's a well-plotted romance factor that is perfectly brought over from the comics - What would you do if you had to tell your One True Love you were dying? How would you spend your remaining days with that person?
It's Herculean tasks that conjure a fun trip and the lovely tale of endearment between the two lovers meshes in with cynicism, lucidity and eventually ends up where fans would want and expect things to go...despite, the looming eerie gloom that is engraved throughout the film with Superman's fate running threadbare. It's literally his last will and testament!



Not only does Clark run afoul of some fiends vying for Lois' affections but affiliations such as Jimmy Olsen, Ma Kent and Perry White are all timely placed and voiced to a tee as the supporting cast never waivers. There are some surprising voice talents that gracefully deliver the goods in this movie. The exchange with Clark Kent interviewing a death-row Lex Luthor is the highlight of this film, and the irony seeps in fully, as we see Luthor at his smartest, yet his lowest intellectual point. Lex's view of the world and humanity is matched when he asks Clark what would the reporter do if he had Superman's powers -
Save the world is the response that steals the scene as Clark displays his innocent dominance as the world's Saviour.




Familiar villains rear ugly heads here and there as Clark's trials and tribulations grow with his impending death; and shout outs to Jonathan Kent, Kandor, Krypton, the Phantom Zone and other lore that DC fans hold dear come in abundance as the movie actually takes the poignant portions from the comics, and abbreviates the excess material well with the proper aspects of the books left out as they may be simply too much and too irrelevant for the overall scope of the tale. It's a nice editing job on the vivid breakdown of this book...and one which I was pleasantly surprised to see the writer and team...commit to...spot-on! It was a well-gauged condensation of Morrison's book!



The crescendo hit with Lex's machinations on death row, building to fruition as we learn that isolation is never a good thing with Lex. Superman's Fortress of Solitude and its denizens all factor in greatly as we see the serenade of a Grant Morrison created-villain in 'Solaris', whose pivotal role hinges on another tease of a DC character in the 'Sun-Eater'. Lex's schemes and these other not-so-peripheral characters segue nicely into each other as the tapestry of Superman's final moments are woven with loyalty, honestly, selflessness and perseverance to protect the Home and the people he love. Lex takes his game to a new level to combat and triumph his rival, as Superman wanes to withstand the threats to Earth, and at the same time, contend with the aftermath that Lois faces.



We get epiphanies, self-realization and...clarity...amongst those who we never would expect.



We end with a semblance of sacrifice amidst constant hope and the furore of redemption, which will surprise those who have not read the comics. It comes left-field to them, and this shows just how different this story is from the usual Superman ones we read and view on cartoons. This does not end the way we expect it to...and with Grant writing...that is not a shocker!

It's no surprise that McDuffie doesn't censor that much to the end. We get a sense of introversion in folks that are usually assertive and non-changing, and by the time this film ends, it's the redemptive aspect that blows the lid off as redemption comes in the form of something and someone that isn't usually associated with it. Hope lingers on in the end-scenes with Jimmy and Lois as McDuffie tweaks the final scene a bit, as I hoped for a bit more literal expansion on that last shot...one that echoed the final scenes of the comic a bit more mechanically so to speak...that's something I garner only readers of the book will grasp when the film's final scene sprays across our eyes...machinery of the Sun much?



‎...Your Bright Eyes are an Illuminating Inferno that turn off the dark of the world...It's the Fire of 1000 Burning Suns is a quote that reeked pleasantly in my mind at the end as we saw exactly why Superman stands for Truth, Justice...and moreso, why he remains akin to a Saviour and Messiah that the faithless, wayward & hopeless sometime look to...
Look to the skies...and that phrase has never had more meaning than it did at the conclusion of this film...
Thumbs up as DC delivers a good story...with an optimum stability and level of pseudo-perfected achievement...that I expect them to never falter with
It's a good job with a story that I honestly never thought they'd translate well to the screen...
Glad to be proven wrong...



"Batman: Year One">...anyone????
Will This Be The New BARBIE? Warner Bros. Announces First-Ever HELLO KITTY Hollywood Movie For 2028
Related:

Will This Be The New BARBIE? Warner Bros. Announces First-Ever HELLO KITTY Hollywood Movie For 2028

ABSOLUTE BATMAN #14 Cover Reveals A New Look At Controversial Redesign For Harley Quinn
Recommended For You:

ABSOLUTE BATMAN #14 Cover Reveals A New Look At Controversial Redesign For Harley Quinn

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

LEEE777
LEEE777 - 2/13/2011, 4:55 AM
Big thumbs EPIC review dude!!! :)



HELLZ YES for BATMAN YEAR ONE!

n1ghtw1ng2832
n1ghtw1ng2832 - 2/13/2011, 6:11 AM
Just saw it yesterday as well. Not a big Grant Morrison fan but I have to say this was pretty damn good. Definitely a must buy people.
USAgent
USAgent - 2/13/2011, 6:13 AM
I agree, it was absolutely amazing to watch. Best DC animated movie to date if I do say so myself, so good that I bought the tpb's.
Ancar
Ancar - 2/13/2011, 6:30 AM
I just saw it last night and I have to confess that impressed me a lot. McDuffie dropped a lot of comic series chapters - the Bizarro planet, Jonathan Kent's death, The Jimmy Olsen episode, the girl suicide scene - but it worked at the end.

And DCF, the animation is available to download on the web. Go search for it.
AiyalKilU
AiyalKilU - 2/13/2011, 6:53 AM
that anime style is played out and needs to go

especially after seeing the possibilities with graphics showcased in the 'Arkham City' and 'DC Universe' trailers?

Year One doesn't deserve this second rate crap animation
jazzman
jazzman - 2/13/2011, 7:13 AM
@AiyalKilU

what u talking about this style is not played out its solid.
Dakjaniels
Dakjaniels - 2/13/2011, 7:34 AM
Great review, I watched it last night. Really enjoyed it, under the red hood is still my favorite animated DC movie, but this is a very close second. I'm also glad they made superman appear less "rumpled" than in the comic if you know what I mean. Never liked that about the art in the book. Highly recommended.
Betty
Betty - 2/13/2011, 8:06 AM
wish the art was as interesting as Quietly's. Not the same, but interesting.
marvel72
marvel72 - 2/13/2011, 8:07 AM
just finished watching it,definetly the best superman animated movie,not sure if its the best dc animated movie though.

its out of this & batman under the red hood for the best movie.

all star superman has some very epic moments,i think i'm definetly gonna pick up the graphic novel.
Exiles
Exiles - 2/13/2011, 8:25 AM
what I thought it was being released on 22nd but great review anyways loved the story
phoe1
phoe1 - 2/13/2011, 9:16 AM
i really have to say i thought this shit was an ABOMINATION. i have not read the comic nor do i now have ANY DESIRE whatsoever to see what the source material is like. this animation flick was so goddamn awful i literally laughed out loud several moments because i really couldnt grasp what was going on.
there were so SOOO many huge logical errors, shoddy animation, horrific dialogue and more i just couldnt stand a minute of it really but forced myself through it.

i dont want to spoil to much incase some ppl havent read/seen it yet but superman does [frick]in insane shit like change from clark kent to superman way too often in little time, when it reall makes no sense. jimmy olsen is a [frick]in transexual, crossdresser. lois acts super effin dumb and the scene where clark reveals his super identity is incredibly anti-climatic.
luthor is put in a "prison" where he can just go about his evil business without avail (and [frick]IN DIG A RIVER underneath the whole building?????)

its a horrible film. the worst animation flick i ve ever seen by marvel or dc.
MaddMonkk
MaddMonkk - 2/13/2011, 9:56 AM
I am happy to have anything with heroes in it. I really loved Superman/Batman:Apocalypse and Public Enemies and the Crisis on 2 worlds, but this one just didn't do it for me. I liked the book alot, don't know why I didn't like this as much as I thought I would. It's not terrible, it's just not great. That's my opinion.
satanors
satanors - 2/13/2011, 9:57 AM
Loved this movie. Best Superman animated so far. DC animated gets better and better than some of the marvel crap they have been putting up. and i'm a marvel.
CaptainAmerica1
CaptainAmerica1 - 2/13/2011, 10:08 AM
A- Nill....heeee heeee heeee
ReillyParker
ReillyParker - 2/13/2011, 10:10 AM
Great review man, I can't wait to check this movie out myself, but man they need to make better Superman movies without him dying/having to die... I'm pretty sure it can be done.

@satanors: Yeah Marvel's Animated Features need to step up their game.
SHHH
SHHH - 2/13/2011, 10:17 AM
I liked it... Great Review! Marvel needs a Spiderman or Captain AMerica Animated Feature.. or Batman Year One!!

funny gifs
Ceejay
Ceejay - 2/13/2011, 1:06 PM
It's still cheesy Superman making ridiculous excuses to do "superstuff" while dressed as the overly dopey version of Clark Kent, and most of the design work is retarded like the robots with capes.. Why CAPES??? It will appease half the fans of the comic series but in all honesty the best thing about it is the music. Common sense goes out of the window in tales like this with ridiculously huge world threats and every single character in the DC universe missing for some unexplained reason EXCEPT Superman. This tale breaks down to another long and drawn out Death of Superman minus all his superhero best-friends who should care and should be there trying to help him and us, if the narrative had any scope. Instead its a contrived Martyr-tale and suits only tunnel-vision Superman fans only in its narrow-visioned attempt to be clever.

And I'm tired of every Kyrptonian that appears in a Superman tale being some tyrant with a god complex unless they're related to Kal El! With all their power and intelligence they should be more like Star Fleet and less like Klingongs in their moral standings. All they are ever used for is to show how good, clean and wholesome Superman is becasue he grew up as a yankee farmboy! And the title describes what exactly? It has didly-squat to do with the story and everything to do with the DC campaign that ran at the time forging celebrity named writers and artists in collaboration to get that extra buck out of the drooling fanboy! ..Meh!
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 2/13/2011, 1:35 PM
Right, I gotta get this now!
Blackvoid
Blackvoid - 2/13/2011, 1:46 PM
just watched it, didnt care for it.
SavageWolf12
SavageWolf12 - 2/13/2011, 2:10 PM
Very well written review. I have been waiting for this to come out so I can see it. There seem to be alot of mixed feelings about this but you'll always have that. I'll not let myself be dissuaded by those that hate because it's different. Can't find anyplace to download it from so I guess now I wait 'til the 22nd.
Ceejay
Ceejay - 2/13/2011, 2:14 PM
Best DC Animated movies..

1: JLA: Crisis on Two Earths
2: Batman: Mask of Phantasm
3: Batman Beyond: Return of The Joker
4: Batman: Under Red Hood
5: Wonder Woman
6: Green Lantern
7: All Star Superman
8: Batman Superman Apocalypse
9: Superman Doomsday
10: Batman Superman Public Enemies
EditNinja
EditNinja - 2/13/2011, 2:27 PM
Like your review.
Normally animated movies make me sleepy, but this was a great story I'd be happy to see Snyder use for Man Of Steel. (He can just delete all that Samson, Atlas stuff)
ThomYorke
ThomYorke - 2/13/2011, 2:33 PM
year one then red son please
Yasn7
Yasn7 - 2/13/2011, 2:39 PM
Awesome! Bring on Red Son!!
BuckTonka88
BuckTonka88 - 2/13/2011, 3:24 PM
http://www.icefilms.info/ip.php?v=125296&

i know i posted this on that smallville article but this is the link to All-Star Superman for anyone who hasn't had the chance to go and buy it
drykillogic22
drykillogic22 - 2/13/2011, 8:13 PM
Didn't care for it much but final scene was sweet..Hated Atlas and Samson. The Kryptonian astronauts were lame as well..
m0th3r
m0th3r - 2/13/2011, 9:08 PM
@Ceejay I dunno..Red Hood and ROTJ were both better the Two Earths i thought.....But i totally agree PE was pretty lousy. I also really liked the effort put into WW and GL. It almost feels like WB/DC uses these for "feelers" and reception for storyline. Would make sense. Also, does anyone know if they are going to attach another short film with this DVD? I LOVED the Green Arrow short...
MaddMonkk
MaddMonkk - 2/13/2011, 9:44 PM
UNDER THE RED HOOD stayed pretty close to the books and is my favorite animated film that DC has done so far. ALL STAR SUPERMAN is okay but I would have liked the Zibarro chapter and the Jimmy chapter instead of Lois, Atlas, and Samson. RED SON maybe the only story adapted to animated film that has a chance of becoming my fave over UTRH. That would be niiiiice.
eyezonr
eyezonr - 2/13/2011, 10:43 PM
possibly the greatest superman animation i have ever seen. this is a must have for the blue ray collection
Paulley
Paulley - 2/14/2011, 2:47 AM
it was horrible.. really jumpy and forced.. i mean i have never read its source material.. but i dont want either now.. it just all seemed forced, very silly and mostly rushed... but thats what you get when you condense a whole series into 90 minutes i guess.

Like Lex's niece.. here use these robots to cause havoc.. next scene walks a few steps and blows up a car before stopping and talking to Jimmy and Lois... uhh pointless much.

also yea the giant cave under the prison cell WTF!
MARV3L
MARV3L - 2/14/2011, 5:24 AM
was abit w*nk really, felt more like a chick flick at times... enjoyed the animation tho!
redson
redson - 2/14/2011, 6:05 AM
Really good film. It's even better if a person has read 
the book first. The story and character choices were 
different then what is normally spun, but I found it 
enjoyable.

Some have issues with certain parts that seem unrealistic or  that didn't make sense. But it's a fictional movie,
based on a comic, about a guy from another planet who flies around in a cape saving people. What are we expecting?
ScorpioEagle1
ScorpioEagle1 - 2/14/2011, 6:31 AM
Terrible.. I think the whole think stunk to high heaven of kickback.. I mean the idea was sound but as PAULLEY said it wall felt forced and wrong. I know there wasn't much time to fit it all in but they had to of story boarded the damn thing and felt who wrong it was. I mean damn.. it isn't that hard to do.. you will never please everyone but you can please most people by giving them the basic tennets of a good movie.. why does Lex Luther have to be in the thick of most of these movies? We know Clark/Superman loves Lois.. next! move on from it all.. geeeeshhh.. this is why the reboot will suck they don't get it.. the suits just don't get it.. make something epic stop trying to adapt stories we already know and screwing them up!!
Rorschach12311
Rorschach12311 - 2/14/2011, 7:18 AM
i liked the movie
not even in the same ball park though as the comic
hatrick3
hatrick3 - 2/15/2011, 5:12 AM
Huge fan of DC animation. Unfortunately, this missed for me. Dino men living at the Earths core, super serum and the Krytonian astronauts. A little to silly. And how many "Death of.." stories do we really need?
View Recorder