Should An "Avatar the Last Airbender" Movie be tried again?

Should An "Avatar the Last Airbender" Movie be tried again?

Should "Avatar: The Last Airbender" be tried as a Movie again?

Editorial Opinion
By CapedCruVader - Feb 04, 2015 01:02 AM EST
Filed Under: Anime & Manga
Source: avatarreboot/comicbookmovie.com

M Night Shyamalan is someone who disappointed many. Be it for his rise with his earlier work (The Sixth Sense, Signs) and his abrupt fall with his latter (all films aside from Unbreakable), or for his shockingly shoddy, racist and all around uninteresting adaptation of the much loved series- Avatar: The Last Airbender/Legend of Ang. This film was an insult to the heartfelt and awe-inspiring, anime inspired original show, which was the story of a young boy dealing with the responsibilities of being the Avatar. Within the world created there are four nations, each being represented by what elements said nation can bend. I imagine if you're reading this article, then you already know this, but I'm just explaining it to the very confused James Cameron fans who've stumbled down the Rabbit Hole and discovered a far superior "Avatar". As much as I'd love to (and probably will in the near future) I'm not here to criticize M Night Shyamalan's choices (nor those of James Cameron, who headed the spectacularly boring film of a similar title) but rather ask, should we try again? If we are too do so, precautions need to be taken. Such as-

1. A racially diverse cast!


(Yeah... That happened.)
Why is it that Hollywood feels the need to make Asian characters white? I mean, in the show Sokka and Katara were darker skinned than the villains... While in the movie, the fire Nation are played by mostly Indians. Is that overt racism from the Indian director? Or is M Night Shyamalan just an idiot? 

Probably the Latter. Whoever is in charge of casting this hypothetical film needs to do their casting right. That means Japanese actors for the fire nation, not Indian.

2. Pick a director with experience of a Saga.

Yeah, it's an obvious pick, and the Hobbit trilogy didn't live up to it's predecessor, but the thematic structure of the Avatar series is similar to The Lord of The Rings. You have a small character saddled with an immense power and responsibility - Ang/Frodo.
His band of misfit friends - The Fellowship of The Ring/Team Avatar.
The evil lord taking over the world who the main character doesn't meet until the third installment- Sauron/Fire Lord Ozai (I realize Frodo doesn't really meet Sauron but It could be argued that when he is possessed by the ring towards the end, he is encountering Sauron).
And finally, the conflicted character who is unsure where his allegiance lies - Zuko/Smegol.
There are elements of the story which are similar also. The main characters traveling for the entire series, the conflicting nations, the dark lord trying to rule all, the main characters banding together to bring down the dark lord, etc. This could be broken down to the myth of originality and the fact that all Art is derivative, but I do think Peter Jackson could do this due to his experience, which brings me onto my next point.

3. You can split the books into multiple movies!
.
(You get permission to do this!)
If Peter Jackson is to direct these films, then he can do something he is now somewhat famous for.
Yeah, the Hobbit trilogy was unneeded. It was overly long and around two hours of it felt like filler. But, oddly enough, one of the main problems with the Avatar movie was trying to squeeze six and a half hours of information into an hour and a half. The series could work as two parts for each book. Making for a more accurate film series in both emotion and events.

4. Develop your characters! 

Another one of the main problems with the film was the under-development of its characters. It was an adaptation of a show that featured some of the greatest characters in children's television. Make Katara motherly, make Sokka funny and sarcastic, make Aang lovable and childish, make Zuko arrogant and angry and for god's sake, make Iroh the charming tea-lover he should be! And then build upon these characters throughout the films! Much like the television show.


Does Avatar need a film adaptation? No. But that doesn't mean I wouldn't like to see one. It doesn't need one, but it deserves a good one. Thanks for reading - Caped Cru-Vader
 
VOLTRON Live-Action Movie Starring Henry Cavill Adds Sterling K. Brown, Rita Ora And John Kim
Related:

VOLTRON Live-Action Movie Starring Henry Cavill Adds Sterling K. Brown, Rita Ora And John Kim

ONE PUNCH MAN Live-Action Movie From Director Justin Lin Taps RICK AND MORTY Co-Creator Dan Harmon For Rewrite
Recommended For You:

ONE PUNCH MAN Live-Action Movie From Director Justin Lin Taps RICK AND MORTY Co-Creator Dan Harmon For Rewrite

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

DannRamm113
DannRamm113 - 2/4/2015, 4:35 PM
...even if it is directed by shamalan i'd watch another avatar movie (not legend of korra because idk that series)
DoctorJesus
DoctorJesus - 2/5/2015, 6:48 AM
I love this idea. The Avatar: the Last AIrbender series NEEDS A GOOD ADAPTATION. The whole series could be done in 5-6 movies and totally honor (and maybe even expand on) the world created for the cartoon. One of the best sagas of all time.
MileHighRonin
MileHighRonin - 2/5/2015, 3:15 PM
Exactly, treat this franchise like the Harry Potter franchise. I think this franchise if done correctly, can eventually compete with Marvel and WB for superhero supremacy.

My thought I was nuts when I told her I watched it and loved it. She gave it a shot, and now my in laws all watch it.

It can touch so many people on so many levels. I don't know how many times I teared up. Korra was great too.
RobGrizzly
RobGrizzly - 2/7/2015, 12:19 AM
This is a nice article, but I think one of the biggest problems with the Avatar adaptation was how badly it so obviously wanted to be the next Lord of the Rings. M Night even said it in several interviews. He really did try to make it something else instead of first understanding that AVATAR IS ITS OWN THING. Why imitate when you can innovate?

-Get the mythology right! This includes HOW THEY PRONOUNCE THEIR NAMES. Needing a fire source made the Fire Nation super weak, and don't get me started on the Earth prisoners SURROUNDED BY EARTH like they can't break free. Speaking of which...

I would love for Hollywood to try again, but thanks to this stinker, it won't be for a good Loooooong while

-Better bending. It took like 5 minutes of flailing around before anyone produced anything. It looked ridiculous. Keep the forms, but make it swift.

-Slow and steady wins the Pace. The movie shoots through plot points fast enough to give you whiplash. They needed major downtime to let the story breath (and develop character moments)

-Have fun! M Night's take was so serious and dour. Where were Sokka's jokes? Or Aang's gags? Good natured Uncle Iroh? The movie was so lifeless.
submitorperish
submitorperish - 2/24/2015, 4:58 PM
The movie was bad but you can't say he's an idiot for having Indian actors. Most of the inspiration for ATLA is based on Indian Asian Culture and themes, some comes from Oriental Asian but the Indian culture doesn't get enough credit in the show. Especially with there being no Indian characters in the show except for Guru Patik which is a shame considering the borrowed influence.

Avatar, chakras, Agni are all Indian words. The concept of an Avatar with the same spirit being reborn to save the world is an Indian concept.

View Recorder