BIRDS OF PREY Star Margot Robbie Says She's Been "Pushing" To Bring Poison Ivy To The Big Screen

BIRDS OF PREY Star Margot Robbie Says She's Been "Pushing" To Bring Poison Ivy To The Big Screen

Fans are desperate to see Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy together on the big screen, but it's not the plan for Birds of Prey. Thankfully, it sounds like Margot Robbie is trying to change that moving forward.

By JoshWilding - Jan 28, 2020 08:01 AM EST
Filed Under: Birds of Prey
Source: CBR
Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy's relationship in the comic books is a fascinating one and, in recent years, they've been linked romantically as well. That's something fans would love to see play out in a live-action setting, while Ivy returning to the big screen is definitely long overdue at this point. 

Unfortunately, it doesn't appear as if there are any plans for that to happen in Birds of Preyand with Gotham City Sirens no longer happening, the character's future is somewhat unclear. 

Now, though, it seems like things could change down the line because Margot Robbie has confirmed that it's something she wants to make a reality. "I've been pushing a Poison Ivy reunion for a long time...Because obviously Ivy and Harley have such an incredible relationship, so I would love to explore that."

Based on what we've heard in the past, it sounds like Robbie definitely has some clout at Warner Bros., so if she wants a Harley Quinn movie - or Birds of Prey sequel - which adds Ivy to the mix, there's a very good chance it will happen. When that could be is hard to say, though, especially as the actress is now back serving as a member of Task Force X in James Gunn's The Suicide Squad

Would you guys be interested in seeing a Harley/Ivy team up in the not too distant future? 

Hit the "View List" button to check out a breakdown and
some hi-res screenshots from the new Birds of Prey trailer!

Iwxeongj o


Margot Robbie is back as Harley Quinn after debuting in Suicide Squad, and it's clear that she'll be rocking more than just a skimpy outfit during this adventure. 
 
Di0ryf9q o


Harley attacking a police station may seem like a villainous move on her part but she's using non-lethal ammo so it definitely looks like she's going to be portrayed as an anti-hero moving forward.
 
Shmzlbp6 o


That makes sense based on the way Harley has been portrayed in the comics in recent years and it will be interesting seeing what impact, if any, it has on James Gunn's The Suicide Squad.
 
Szqwdo0s o


A post-credits scene with Birds of Prey setting the stage for Task Force X to return to the DCEU is surely a given, especially as the movie has been shooting for quite some time now. 
 
7abhdhdj o


We still don't know how Harley and the rest of the original cast will factor into that adventure but it likely means that this movie ends with the fan-favourite character behind bars.
 
Dfhd5w6o o


As for what Harley might be up to here, it's hard to say but perhaps she's attempting to steal evidence which can be used against the man trying to kill her? (more on him later)
 
I9vfcka4 o


What we do know is that Harley and The Joker are no longer an item and Margot Robbie recently confirmed that Jared Leto won't be returning as the Clown Prince of Crime in Birds of Prey.
 
2ytzlaur o


That is indeed Ace Chemicals she's driving a truck into and it's hard not to wonder whether Mr. J is inside as Warner Bros. could choose to kill off the villain here to explain where he's vanished to.
 
Hp1p4r9k o


After all, Leto hasn't shied away from voicing his displeasure with how his Joker was used in Suicide Squad and insiders have since claimed that he was left fuming over Joker being made.
 
 
Rffdetef o


Regardless of his future as that iconic Batman villain, Harley is clearly ready to cut all ties and that includes blowing up the place she left behind her Dr. Harleen Quinzel persona.  
 
4qjnahmj o


It's been said that Birds of Prey isn't really a sequel to Suicide Squad but with these references to The Joker, it's not exactly like this is a reboot...chances are that movie's ending won't be addressed, though. 
 
0msivy8z o


Visually, Birds of Prey looks like a very colourful movie and a far cry from the darker, often quite grimey tones which dominated the first wave of movies in the DCEU.
 
Vyskcimb o


Harley certainly seems happy with her newfound freedom and time will tell whether her breakup with Mr. J (which was filmed with a stand-in) will make it into the final cut of the film. 
 
Rmniktiw o


Yet another costume for Harley, Warner Bros. is jumping on the merchandising opportunities here (which they declined to do for Joker) despite Birds of Prey being R-Rated.
 
015f3edk o


Poor Harley isn't doing well following her breakup and it appears as if we're going to follow her as she rebounds from this, albeit with some Deadpool-style fourth wall breaks in the process.
 
Nnppvw8r o


What's the deal with that beaver in the background? Well, in the comics, Harley has a taxidermied beaver - called Bernie - who serves as a kind of sidekick of sorts during her adventures.
 
A4tnxdqy o


This is our first glimpse at Mary Elizabeth Winstead's Huntress in the trailer and it definitely appears as if we can expect her to be the team's biggest badass (even moreso than Black Canary). 
 
Vd3arljf o


What brings Harley and the young Cassandra Cain together? Well, it sounds like Roman Sionis is after both of them and Quinn takes the character better known as Batgirl in the comics under her wing.
 
4tftrydm o


That is Victor Zsasz, a classic Batman villain who carves a marking into his body for every person he kills. Unless his arms and torso are covered, he may not have many kills at this stage in his career.
 
8rmg1def o


There it is! We weren't expecting to see Roman don a comic book accurate version of his mask in the movie based on past rumours but he really wouldn't have been Black Mask without it.
 
Zuqcoaob o


There doesn't seem to be any love lost between Harley and The Joker, hence why she's using a drawing of him for target practice. Warner Bros. actually toned down their abusive relationship in Suicide Squad.
 
Cgf31y7a o


Ewan McGregor appears to be having a lot of fun here as this classic villain but the trailer doesn't reveal much about him beyond the fact he seems to have a rather eccentric fashion sense. 
 
D7hpifwx o


Harley reveals that Black Mask wants to kill her but is it because she and The Joker wronged him in the past (he's clearly a gangster) or might he want to make her his own?
 
Keq2p2fv o


Many fans expected Harley Quinn to receive a complete makeover after Suicide Squad but the tattoon remain (at least there's nothing as awkward as The Joker's "Damaged" tat). 
 
G6lanhae o


Something we likely won't see is Harley's comic book costume but we did get a glimpse of that in Suicide Squad so there's not really any need for it to make its return here.
 
Hulzwd9a o


Could this be another example of Harley breaking the fourth wall? It wouldn't be the worst idea Warner Bros. has had to create their own version of Deadpool for the DC Extended Universe. 
 
Zu9ksnzj o


Is that a big pile of drugs next to Harley? It would make sense for Black Mask to have a massive drugs empire and that R-Rating allows Cathy Yan to explore things that a PG-13 release can't.
 
Jjtslxvj o


Yet another costume for the title character, Warner Bros. has certainly given Harley Quinn cosplayers plenty of different options ahead of this year's San Diego Comic-Con!
 
Dih9hx0z o


Another advantage that comes with an R-Rating is the fact that things will get a whole lot more violent and we see an example of that here as Harley brutally takes down these three goons. 
 
Swfdd9eq o


Harley and Cassandra seem to be having a lot of fun together but isn't it a little risky for someone as notorious as Harley Quinn to just be wandering around Gotham City? 
 
C61qj20f o


This definitely looks like a fantasy sequence of some sort and, believe it or not, it's been claimed that Ewan McGregor could have worn a mask not all that different to what we see above. 
 
0nrai0hy o


The Birds of Prey assemble here and they look like a formidable group! Leading the charge is Rosie Perez as Renee Montoya, a character better known in the comics as The Question. 
 
D6bzx91y o


Could this be what leads to Cassandra Cain being targeted by Black Mask and his crew? She appears to be just a normal kid but picking Victor Zsasz's pocket might be the dumbest thing she's ever done. 
 
B0uwxsne o


Rumour has it that in an earlier version of Birds of Prey, that diamond actually had Black Mask's d*ck pics stored on it. Now, though, it's thought that it just contains incriminating evidence against him. 
 
Dyphabmg o


He's certainly a pretty flamboyant character and it was once claimed that he's gay. Whether that's true and something that has made it into this version of the film is hard to say. 
 
Ictouq8w o


Margot Robbie recently said that she didn't understand why Harley would ever fall for The Joker, so the chances of their romance ever being touched on again in the DCEU seem extremly slim. 
 
Qvf7gyoj o


We've seen a lot of Black Canary on the small screen in recent years thanks to Arrow but it's going to be awesome seeing what Jurnee Smollett-Bell ends up bringing to the role.
 
Gdg3fp2q o


A recent TV spot for Birds of Prey showed Huntress wearing a comic accurate version of her mask so she's one character we can expect to see suited up at some point in the film. 
 
1qoqtlcw o


This version of the character won't be the daughter of Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle (well, not as far as we know anyway) as Winstead is going to be playing Helena Bertinelli. 
 
Fyiekp0l o


Harley mentions that the fact Huntress killed Black Mask's "BFF" is what led to the villain targeting her and that likely came as a result of her crusade against criminals. 
 
Lsi8s6jx o


It seems like Huntress will be a reluctant member of this group but she's someone the rest of the team definitely admires. Making its return here is Harley's iconic mallet too. 
 
Jmfildaa o


Harley Quinn is closely associated with the Roller Derby in the comics and it actually looks like that's something we'll see a lot of throughout Birds of Prey
 
3whpdybp o


Black Canary is shown wielding a gun here but does she really need one when she can unleash that sonic scream of hers? Well, it certainly won't hurt in the fight the team have ahead of them!
 
Fvmnmdvd o


It looks like at least some of the film will take place in this funfair and chances are that this is somewhere Harley has a fair bit of history with after her time with The Joker. 
 
Syjtmy4b o


We see here that Renee Montoya has been keeping track of Black Mask's operations and that's clearly Cassandra Cain on the phone she's taken into evidence (likely from someone who has been tasked with killing her after stealing from him). 
 
Ibyubdjm o


Is the Gotham City Police Detective clearing out her desk? Quite possibly and it doesn't seem she gets much in the way of respect from her male colleagues as she attempts to build a case against Black Mask. 
 
Rvlmi8xm o


Speaking of that villain, what an aweome piece of imagery this is! 
 
64wnmqec o


There may or may not be a good reason for the villain's henchmen wearing masks but it certainly helps them stand out from the crowd (even if they do look a little silly). 
 
Szrwujpu o


Back to that funfair setting, how much do you want to bet that this is actually Amusement Mile? The Joker frequently used that as a hideout so Harley making her last stand here makes sense. 
 
Gmcc5mtd o


Something we don't see in the trailer, of course, is Batman! In fact, there's not really any sort of reference to the Caped Crusader at all here and that leaves us with a lot of questions. 
 
Qg9hnqd4 o


It's not as if a war between Harley Quinn and Black Mask would escape his attention so he's either missing, dead, or working elsewhere in the world on behalf of the Justice League. 
 
Zbqvtcy9 o


With Ben Affleck not set to reprise the role of the Caped Crusader, however, it would be silly for Warner Bros. to leave the door open to Batman making his presence felt down the line...unless the plan is for Robert Pattinson to replace him! 
 
16jk0t4a o


Batman going missing has happened before and as there's no Bat Family to back him up in this universe (not that we know of anyway), perhaps Gotham City has descended into madness in his absence? 
 
3r9o8utf o


J.K. Simmons also isn't slated to appear as Commissioner Jim Gordon so he's either not getting a mention here or his absence will also be explained away by the movie somehow. 
 
H3b8yx8a o


That mask looks like it's been pilled straight out of the comic books and unlike in the source material, he doesn't look like a slightly different version of Marvel's Red Skull!
 
Imkpcidx o


There's no sign of Batgirl in Birds of Prey, a character fans consider an essential part of the team. However, it's definitely feasible that Cassandra could take on that moniker by the end of the film instead of Barabara Gordon.
 
Vgg6tm0p o


Not everyone will be happy with that, of course, and it's hard to say why Cassandra would take on that mantle unless she wants to try and fill the void that's been left by Batman. 
 
Gimvc3zm o


If you're impressed by the action in this trailer, then you can thank John Wick director Chad Stahelski as he was tasked to take the helm of second unit reshoots by Cathy Yan and Warner Bros. 
 
Xc1iydbi o


We don't know if an earlier cut was lacking in that department but it certainly won't be now and what we see here definitely looks like an improvement over what was in the teaser trailer. 
 
Odsrhvcx o


Yes, Harley Quinn appears to be gunning down some cops here but she's once again doing so with non-lethal means so she must have turned over a new leaf to at least an extent. 
 
Hwnrbpjh o


With Gotham City Sirens on hold, it's going to be up to a possible Birds of Prey sequel to introduce Poison Ivy as Harley's love interest but we don't know if the plan is for this to be a franchise yet.
 
U6p6wvcz o


If we do get a sequel, there's nothing to say Harley will be involved as she's making the leap to The Suicide Squad next and will likely get a solo outing shortly after. 
 
Fxq8lbh8 o


This version of Black Canary is a singer who is working for Black Mask but probably not because she wants to. Harley does mention earlier in the trailer that she's "betrayed" him somehow. 
 
Drtnxvfm o


Renee Montoya could definitely become a version of The Question in the DCEU but it's hard to say how that could happen given how little we know about her role in Birds of Prey
 
Bhuvnbc9 o


Ella Jay Basco may end up delivering a breakout performance as Cassandra Cain but one big change that's been made from the comics is that she's not a mute in this movie. 
 
Lzhtt24u o


Huntress, meanwhile, does seem to have a lot in common with her comic book counterpart. Did you know that McGregor and Winstead are in a relationship in real-life?
 
Tjju10mf o


Harley's love of dancing hasn't gone anywhere but things aren't quite as raunchy as they were in Suicide Squad because this movie looks set to move away from the male gaze.
 
Kmq2dhgn o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
R2yywowb o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
Ztewqk1f o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
Khueqypl o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
J9go5nu1 o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
Ras0fz6e o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
0h0kkfkc o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
S7r8cgea o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
2fprnx0b o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
Vfh6jpc2 o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
Tkdhunuz o


Yes, it does look a little like the Demon Bear is concealed within a cloud here so we now just have to hope that this isn't another classic bad guy the studio is hiding within, well, mist! 
 
1ffm035m o


We've seen three different versions of Black Canary on the small screen over the past few years and their powers are portrayed pretty similarly to what we see from this take on the hero. 
 
O0fufsuj o


There's no clear indication that this Black Canary has any links to Green Arrow - or that Oliver Queen even exists in the DCEU - but an Easter Egg pointing to that would definitely be appreciated. 
 
Wtkxbcfs o


She doesn't need backup from Green Arrow, though, because her powers are undeniably impressive as she managed to take down an entire crew of Black Mask's men with a single blast. 
 
Q81ywx8z o


Black Canary will be the only member of the team with powers but Harley certainly doesn't appear to be struggling without them as she shows off her impressive fighting abilities. 
 
Jsuyecon o


Of course, when they let you down, just set a dude's beard on fire! We're not entirely sure it would go up in flames that fast, though, unless it's seriously dry! 
 
F3gxv7cz o


Black Mask has seemingly caught Harley at this point as that's her in the chair in front of him. His men aren't taking any risks as they all have their guns pointed at The Joker's former flame. 
 
Dknx3g0k o


Thanks to the aforementioned R-Rating, Warner Bros. will be able to up the ante in terms of violence and while this trailer is light on blood, we can likely expect plenty of it in the film itself. 
 
9rtn7dbf o


That seems appropriate in Gotham City but will this supposed team of heroes actually be killers? It certainly doesn't look like Black Canary is holding back during this sequence. 
 
I0uyizw9 o


Is it possible that these two are more than friends? Sure, Black Mask only has his arm around his employee but it would certainly add an interesting new wrinkle to both villains. 
 
Hyuztlgd o


We know that Cassandra Cain steals diamonds from Black Mask and Harley seems to be rocking a lot of them here. What if the movie ends with her making off with the villain's haul? 
 
Wdz1mp1s o


Even if that is the case, we know Harley somehow winds up back in Amanda Waller's custody because, as we mentioned earlier in this post, she'll return in The Suicide Squad in 2021. 
 
Fm5wuxea o


Harley Quinn had two hyenas in Batman: The Animated Series - Bud and Lou - but there's only one here and, well, even that is something fans of the show are bound to appreciate! 
 
1m0i78y6 o


Rather than being called "Bud" or "Lou," though, Harley has instead named him "Bruce" after Bruce Wayne (who she definitely doesn't appear to know is also Batman). 
 
Zcuv45im o


What do you guys think of these screenshots from Birds of Prey? Did you notice anything in the trailer that we missed? As always, share your thoughts in the comments section below. 
 
HUNTRESS Korean-Language DCU Movie Rumored To Have Enlisted THE VILLAINESS Director Jung Byung-Gil
Related:

HUNTRESS Korean-Language DCU Movie Rumored To Have Enlisted THE VILLAINESS Director Jung Byung-Gil

DC Studios Reportedly Planning A HUNTRESS Project And It Will Be A Korean-Language Movie
Recommended For You:

DC Studios Reportedly Planning A HUNTRESS Project And It Will Be A Korean-Language Movie

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2 3
Yelmurc
Yelmurc - 1/28/2020, 8:40 AM
If only Josh would being proof reading to his articles.
MyCoolYoung
MyCoolYoung - 1/28/2020, 8:48 AM
@Yelmurc - oh the irony
BattleBeard
BattleBeard - 1/28/2020, 8:48 AM
@Yelmurc - Took the words out of my mouth.
AnthonyVonGeek
AnthonyVonGeek - 1/28/2020, 8:48 AM
“ BIRDS OF PREY Star Margot Robbie Says She's Been "Pushing" To Being Poison Ivy To The Big Screen”
geekarchitect
geekarchitect - 1/28/2020, 8:48 AM
I think there's a grammatical error on the headline.
SpideyPuffsMJ
SpideyPuffsMJ - 1/28/2020, 8:48 AM
Robbie is a smart business person. And I love her in pretty much every role except for Harley. But it seems desperate/strange of WB/DC to give her near-complete creative control of not only her character but upcoming films. Like is Margot Robbie the Kevin Feige of DC now? It seems like she has a pretty strong input on where things go from here concerning her corner of this scattered group of puzzle pieces that is the DCEU nowadays.
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 8:52 AM
@SpideyPuffsMJ

“ Like is Margot Robbie the Kevin Feige of DC now?”

That’s Walter Hamada. I do think WB has given Robbie a lot of control over HQ and her projects. Pretty sure her production company was behind Birds of Prey.

As long as the movie ends up being good I don’t have an issue with it. They’re clearly doing more standalone franchises and stories now without focusing on building a universe like Marvel.

Which I also don’t have a problem with 👍🏻 They failed pretty miserably when they tried it. And honestly this gives us more variety.
SpideyPuffsMJ
SpideyPuffsMJ - 1/28/2020, 8:56 AM
@regularmovieguy - I'm all for the variety. I just worry they're throwing shit at the wall to see what sticks. Expect them to pressure Phoenix/Phillips hard for an unnecessary Joker sequel. If Birds of Prey hits, same thing. Batman, etc. It's funny because they're really going back in time to the trilogy model that was pretty much how things worked before the MCU. Before they botched copying that model so hard.
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 9:01 AM
@SpideyPuffsMJ

I can almost guarantee we’re getting a sequel to BOP. If this does 200 mil+ domestic you can bank on it.

I don’t want a Joker sequel but I would be there opening night if they made one.

Nothing wrong with trilogies either 🤟🏻 Stories should have a beginning and ending.
tmp3
tmp3 - 1/28/2020, 9:03 AM
@regularmovieguy - speaking of walter hamada what the fuuuuck happened to that Speilberg Blackhawk movie he greenlit lmao. Shit just disappeared
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 9:12 AM
@tmp3

Haven’t heard about that one!
tmp3
tmp3 - 1/28/2020, 9:14 AM
@regularmovieguy - Like 9 out of 10 DC film projects never happen lol. That Deathstroke movie could have been baller, especially with Gareth Evans behind the camera
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 9:17 AM
@tmp3

TBF I don’t think they ever officially announced that but yeah that was one of movies I was most hyped for.

Was always a long shot imo. But it sounded [frick]ing awesome.
MyCoolYoung
MyCoolYoung - 1/28/2020, 8:51 AM
I can dig. 'Harley Quinn's second emancipation after being in birds of a prey and suicide squad, oh and here's poison ivy' really does have a ring to it
MuadDib
MuadDib - 1/28/2020, 8:52 AM
Harley is over hyped and we’ve seen Ivy before.. not that it wouldn’t be cool to see her again.. I want Clay Face.. a comic book accurate Bane... or maybe a Talon... idk..

Margot is hot.. and she’s an ok actress.. but this Harley push is too much..

She didn’t even exist until BTAS...
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 8:57 AM
@MuadDib

Margot’s one of the best young actresses working right now. I, Tonya. Wolf of Wall Street. She was pretty great in Bombshell too and that was a mediocre movie at best.

I’m going to wait and see how BOP turns out before I call for her head too. This only her second movie 😂
tmp3
tmp3 - 1/28/2020, 9:09 AM
@regularmovieguy - She’s gonna be in the next David O Russell film with Christian Bale, and then she’s got the Gerwig/Baumbach Barbie film coming up too. Kind of crazy how prolific she became in such a short period of time
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 9:12 AM
@tmp3

I keep hearing about this David O’Russell movie but I haven’t really seen it in the trades.

Going to be a rom-com, right? And yeah, feel like WOWS pushed her into the stratosphere and I, Tonya cemented her.
tmp3
tmp3 - 1/28/2020, 9:13 AM
@regularmovieguy - It was confirmed by Collider back in Jan, starring Bale w/ Jamie Foxx, Angelina Jolie and Robbie in talks. JLaw was meant to be Robbie’s role at one point but schedules couldn’t align.
Reeds2Much
Reeds2Much - 1/28/2020, 9:26 AM
@MuadDib - She didn’t even exist until BTAS

"Comic accuracy" was neither an issue or even a thing until about 2012 and now everyone is all about it.
regularmovieguy
regularmovieguy - 1/28/2020, 9:32 AM
@Reeds2Much

I thought comic accuracy has been a thing since the Burton Batman or even the X-Men movies in the 2000s.

It’s dumb but I feel like it’s been around for a while.
Reeds2Much
Reeds2Much - 1/28/2020, 9:43 AM
@regularmovieguy - Comic accuracy was never a thing with the studios, and the complaints were only minor and always disappeared after the movies came out.

It's really a new phenomenon that people lose their minds and cry about how it's a movie ruining issue. Birds of Prey and Spider-Man are perfect examples of it.
MuadDib
MuadDib - 1/28/2020, 10:09 AM
@Reeds2Much - Negative. The entire reason this genre exists and is as popular as it is, is bc kids way back use to day dream about one day seeing their favorite superheroes come to life on the big screen. Sups and Bats were some of the first to make the leap. Thus they enjoyed success.

Marvel has been very good about walking a line that allowed them to tap into a vast catalogue of established characters all with rush histories, while making minor alterations when necessary. Obviously you can always find the expectation to anything.

That said, I was referring to Bane.. which aside from the funny looking version that coincidentally appeared along side Ivy .. has never been shown as he looks in the comics.. that’s what I mean by comic accurate..

Clay Face... not a grounded take ... a comic book accurate Clay Face.. it’s not hard

Disney live action remakes that stick to the source material get better audience reviews and make more money. I wonder why? Their Cinderella remake didn’t even come close to say.. Jungle Book or Beauty and the Beast. Bc they stuck very close to the originals

Last point.. as a kid.. when you fantasized about seeing things in comics and in books and things from your imagination.. come to life on the big screen in real life.. did you think.. boy it would be so cool to see “X” on screen or I hope one day they make a movie about “X” .. but I hope they change stuff about his origins or main storylines from that super popular book?

If you change certain aspects you can easily change the chemistry and change what made something stand out as special.. when something is a success.. and is liked or loved by the masses.. changing them isn’t always the smartest move.. hows the old saying go? Dont fix it if it ain’t broken..

We could go back and forth forever.. I respect your opinion

But I think your wrong
Reeds2Much
Reeds2Much - 1/28/2020, 11:23 AM
@MuadDib - MuadDib - Marvel has been very good

Yeah, I'mma stop you there. There's little "minor" in the differences between the MCU and it's source. Like I told the other person that tried that, Steve wasn't fighting Hydra during World War 2 and Bucky wasn't his best friend from Brooklyn, Tony hid his identity for in-world years and Rhodey was a Marine and also not a long-time friend, and pretty much all of Thor.

Donner's movies aren't accurate (Pretty much all of Luthor), Burton was certainly off (socially awkward Bruce Wayne wut?), and yes I'm aware that the comics retconned Spidy to have organic webs to match the movies, and has been removed again so Raimi is certainly no better. That's not even beginning on how inaccurate all their villains were.

And speaking of Batman, how about retconning? Spider-Man's relationship with Mary Jane was a retcon of her "always knowing" from being his neighbor not to mention the whole organic webshooter mess, Superman was a dude that was strong and could jump real good but because jumping was harder to draw they decided he should fly instead ... and then laser eyes were cool and so on and so forth in a ridiculous cycle of powercreep that would make Goku blush, and then Batman got retconned so hard in the 80s by Alan Moore and Frank Miller that he's basically a completely different character from Bill Finger's original; So much so that people complain about Adam West's show which was closer to accuracy to Bill Finger's book than Burton and Nolan were to Moore and Miller. While some people might have complained about the lack of them, no one is really holding the costumes in the X-movies or how prominent Wolverine was against them. And let's be real for a second: Logan was about as comic accurate as my wedding video. And do I even have to mention Joker?

They weren't accurate, and everyone was fine with it. They were entertaining. The kind of rage that Birds of Prey and Spider-Man (now) get for diverging from their sources are pretty new. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." "If it wasn't accurate before, why start now?"
MuadDib
MuadDib - 1/28/2020, 11:34 AM
@Reeds2Much - Like I said and autocorrect changed, there are exceptions for everything.

I’m not wrong in having high standards that the movies in question regardless of character or universe resemble the character that I fell in love with as a child.

So again, to each their own. In my world and in my circle or friends and those who’s opinions actually matter to me. I’m right.

Good day sir.

I said good day!
Tasmaniac
Tasmaniac - 1/28/2020, 12:33 PM
@MuadDib - Bloody well said. Clayface is the one I’ve been wanting for years. And you’re bang on about Bane too.
E4Nigma
E4Nigma - 1/28/2020, 8:56 AM
I'd love to see Poison Ivy played by Ana de Armas. 😍

1 2 3
View Recorder