How Far Did Justice League: Mortal Get?

How Far Did Justice League: Mortal Get?

How close did we come to seeing George Miller's Justice League on the screen?

Editorial Opinion
By slimybug - Feb 12, 2010 08:02 PM EST
Filed Under: Justice League

It's a funny thing talking about Justice League: Mortal, the abandoned project that almost led to a premature cinematic outing for the JLA. The reason it's so funny is that I can't really remember hearing much hype about it, even here. True, we all hated the idea and wanted it to fail, but still, I don't recall a large number of articles being published whenever someone was cast, or even any hype trying to be generated.

I mean, whether people generally liked the idea or not, we had a new Superman and Batman cast! We even had Wonder Woman! And I guess it was totally legit! We actually had a live action cast for these heroes. And yet, I don't remember these as big announcements here. Maybe I'm not remembering it the right way, but the cast of the film didn't seem to get much attention. It just seemed to be a fact, something that was referenced when talking about other things regarding the film, which I think is how I found out about a good portion of the cast even being in it!

You would think something that big would be big news, published in the mainstream newspaper or mentioned on the news, but I can't remember hearing anything about it. Is it just me? Am I remembering these events wrong, or do others find it strange the lack of hype such things created?

Was it just that the project itself seemed like such a joke, that we wanted so bad for it not to happen, that we intentionally paid it no heed? I certainly remember I wasn't expecting it to see the light of day, and when there was an announcement, I seem to remember other commenters sharing the same sentiment. Usually, when the cast comes together, that's when filming is set in stone, but I remember, even as the cast came together, I, and others, still didn't really expect it to happen. I also recall that even though they had the actors, filming itself kept getting delayed and delayed until the film was finally cancelled.

But when we look at the reality of the situation, how close did we really come to seeing this version of the league on the screen? Here's what we know. The script was written by the husband-and-wife team of Kieran (brother of Dermot) and Michelle Mulroney, and was to be helmed by "Mad Max" director George Miller. They were fully willing to cast a new Superman and Batman, despite of Superman Returns, and the fact that Chris Nolan's Batman series was still going on simultaneously. The cast for the film went as follows:

D.J. Cotrona as Clark Kent / Superman


Is it just me, or is he Latino?

Armie Hammer as Bruce Wayne / Batman

Armie Hammer? That's really his name? That's just asking for all the baking soda jokes you can ever dream of!

Megan Gale as Diana of Themyscira / Wonder Woman


Common as John Stewart / Green Lantern


Hugh Keays-Byrne as J'Onn J'Onzz / Martian Manhunter


And here's where I get confused. Apparently, there was news of both Adam Brody and Anton Yelchin being cast. I have read on the net that one or the other was cast as Wally West / The Flash.




So which is it? Were they both cast, at separate times, after one dropped out? Were they actually both in the movie, or one had a different role? Why can't I find the answers to these questions by looking up a simple article on the web? See what I mean? I wouldn't expect this of a comic book movie. Usually, if a major superhero is cast, it's a big announcement, and there isn't generally confusion like this.

At any rate, also cast in the film was one villain...

Teresa Palmer as Talia al Ghul


There's one more thing. Apparently, and I never even heard about this when the film was actually happening, there was talk of Jay Baruchel possibly playing the villain in the film? Really? This guy?


Must have been one hell of a geeky villain.

At any rate, the movie was set to film in Australia, but, as I said, was eventually cancelled, apparently due to the protestations of the fans at the idea. DC then directed it's efforts to making solo movies that would link up, a la Marvel. And they still haven't gotten around to actually doing that yet.

Whatever the outcome, apparently the film got pretty far along. According to statements from Armie Hammer, he had actually been fitted for his costume. Now THAT intrigues me! They already had the costumes designed? I want to see those!I want to know if they went the Nolan route on Batman, or put him in spandex. I want to see all the costumes that were supposedly going to hit the screen.

Actually, I want to see all sorts of stuff from this film! The costumes, the concept art, maybe even storyboards! Since the film's not gonna happen now, I'd be really glad if Warner Bros. released this stuff! And of course, what would be really interesting would be to see the script.

However, is it possible that Warner Bros. is still planning on using this same script for when and if they make the actual Justice League movie? It would have to be tweaked, obviously, since, for instance, Green Lantern's now going to be Hal Jordan. But could this still be the Justice League script we see on screen? Not only that, but, since they're making the solo movies now, could these actors, like Miss Gale, be the ones being considered for said roles? You tell me.

If you read all that, you're a saint. Thanks a million! Now let me know what you think!

Slimy!
James Gunn Weighs In On JUSTICE LEAGUE Movie Rumors And Reveals Comic That's A Big Influence On DCU
Related:

James Gunn Weighs In On JUSTICE LEAGUE Movie Rumors And Reveals Comic That's A "Big Influence" On DCU

JUSTICE LEAGUE Star Amy Adams Praises Henry Cavill And Talks James Gunn's SUPERMAN Recasting
Recommended For You:

JUSTICE LEAGUE Star Amy Adams Praises Henry Cavill And Talks James Gunn's SUPERMAN Recasting

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

bleedthefreak
bleedthefreak - 2/12/2010, 9:16 PM
they really wanted windows from fanboys as the bad guy? thats [frick]ing to funny
SHHH
SHHH - 2/12/2010, 9:52 PM
I think this would of killed the franchise before they got started..
luffycapri
luffycapri - 2/12/2010, 10:06 PM
to bad they didnt make the movie lol
lethargic
lethargic - 2/13/2010, 12:07 AM
To fill in some holes....

1. Anton Yelchin was in the running early but never cast. Brody was the only one officially cast as Flash/Wally West.
2. Jay Baruchel was playing Maxwell Lord.
3. The movie wasn't canned because fans didn't like it. It was cancelled due to a combination of not wanting to anger Nolan (risking Batman 3) and tax issues in Australia.

Nolan wasn't against the movie at first, he didn't like it but he wasn't against it. But when he saw the script he found out that it had been written as a psuedo sequel to his movies (Talia was seeking revenge for Batman letting her father die at the end of Begins). Up until then everybody thought it was obvious that this was two different Batmans and the movies wouldn't step on each other's toes. Nolan got really mad when he found out differently.

Still they went forward with the movie until Australia refused to give the movie it's film production rebate. The budget was already over 200 million and that was factoring in shooting it in Australia and getting that rebate. Once they lost that they tried to find other places to do it but nobody could save them the money that Australia could. Without saving that money the movie just got way too expensive to make when you add in what a risk it was PLUS that it was pissing off the one guy who had just given them the 2nd biggest movie of all time.
THEHAWK
THEHAWK - 2/13/2010, 9:13 AM
I actually forgot about this. Thank for reminding me Slimy you bastard. I wanted this to stay forgotten.
AngryMan13
AngryMan13 - 2/13/2010, 11:09 AM
The Writers Guild of America strike of '07 coupled with the tax rebate issue eventually killed the momentum of this project.

Re-writes were called for and couldn't be delivered and the fear of a potential Screen Actors Guild strike over the summer of '08 was the nail in its coffin.
LuckyKyd
LuckyKyd - 2/14/2010, 9:55 AM
Why would they want a Latino to play Superman? Thankfully that never happened, because the whole idea was just crap.
Though I too would like to see some art and costume concepts.
flames809
flames809 - 2/14/2010, 1:54 PM
i like the superman pick they got and the wonderwomen and even the first pic for flash but thats it. i was waiting for this movie but know we could see a newer justice league movie.
VitMagic
VitMagic - 2/15/2010, 1:14 AM
this movie didnt have a chance. and im not talking about the tax thing, nolan, or whatever else complicated it. it was gonna suck no matter what. nothing against the clark kent pick, but no thanks on the last ese' of krypton! just thinking about that cast really pisses me off, and i know its not even happening. megan gale might have been good, im not sure cause i dont know who she is, but the rest no thank you! and please dont use whatever garbage script was written. now that im done ranting, i too wouldnt mind seeing some costumes atleast. couldnt be half as bad as all the other news for this movie.....could it?
Diamond1995
Diamond1995 - 2/15/2010, 8:41 AM
They really musn't have spent any money or time casting. i bet they just cast the first person to enter the casting room. The JLA:Mortal film would have been one of those mindless action films. Sure it has a bunch of dazzling special effects and action sequences but the acting would be shit, the plot would be horrible, the script a mess, and basicly everything other than the action would suck. Though I would have wanted to see this movie be made. Why? Just so we can see DC destroy each of its main characters (Batman, superman, Wonder woman, flash) and then once again remind us that Marvel is way better at making films. Frankly other than the new Batman series, Dc really hasn't made any recent good film (2000-2008). Marvel, no matter what, is DC's superior in film making. Cause at least we dont have to wait three-five years for the next DC film, while we get a new Marvel film almost every year!
Diamond1995
Diamond1995 - 2/15/2010, 8:46 AM
And I have a feeling if the Thor (or Avengers) movie does better than the Dark Knight, DC will either
a) quickly rush out a new film (just like they did with the Justice League mortal) and just pray to god that it will make more money.
b) release 'plans' to make a new film but then put it on the backburner for the next couple years. Frankly only 1% of Dc characters are given films, the rest are put into talk and then either abandoned or pushed back even more.
flames809
flames809 - 2/15/2010, 1:22 PM
diamond- i disagree with you if the avengers makes more money than the dark knight dc will beat if with there justice league movie that they going to make. and thor would not beat the dark knight on the first or second opening week
wwfanatic
wwfanatic - 2/16/2010, 5:55 AM
I was excited mainly for the fact that we could see a live action Wonder Woman. Megan Gale would have been a great choice. She is so smoking gorgeous. If Wonder Woman EVER makes it to the big screen, I think casting an unknown will be the best option. I had no idea who Megan Gale was until word of this movie came out. The only exception that would fit in my mind other than casting an unknown would be Angelina Jolie (around the same time as the Tomb Raider movies)
AshleyWilliams
AshleyWilliams - 2/16/2010, 8:04 AM
Man,that would NOT go over well with people.
MatchesMalone
MatchesMalone - 2/18/2010, 12:16 PM
Crisis averted. The costumes couldn't have been nearly as bad as the ones they used for the JL tv pilot. I'll wait another 20 years for a JLA movie if it means they get everything right.
serateigiburim
serateigiburim - 2/21/2010, 6:39 AM
The author is off the mark. Many of us wanted to see the movie. It's just that the casting was the pits. George Miller wanted to reinvent JLA. The only one that made even slight sense was Megan Gale and that's a reach.
serateigiburim
serateigiburim - 3/24/2010, 3:23 AM
Something else that the author of this article missed: Aquaman was also miscast with Santiago Calabria.

Don't let George Miller come anywhere near DC ever again!
JLAAvengers
JLAAvengers - 7/14/2010, 12:07 AM
They can't make a JLA movie cuse we don't hav a flash movie wonder woman movie aquaman movie and a epic superman movie and as for bats were all good
View Recorder