MrDonut Presents: 'Green Lantern'

MrDonut Presents: 'Green Lantern'

A fan cast for the Emerald Warrior(s)

By MrDonut - Apr 25, 2013 12:04 AM EST
Filed Under: Fan Fic

Those of you who checked my previous fan casts will know for my casts I’ve taken on a bit more a generic view with casting, those of you who don’t, just to make it clear; rather than cast one specific film entry in a franchise I decided to cast of characters I’d expect to be around in the ‘5 year’ window of the New 52/existence of the Justice League, and who will hopefully crop up in DC’s future films.

Anyway, as we all know Ryan Reynold’s turd-fest Green Lantern pretty much obliterated any chances of the Emerald Warrior(s) from ever getting a movie that does him justice and any other characters outside of Batman and Superman, but hopefully if a Justice League film is successful then we will eventually get individual films for the respective team members. For some people DC needs to adopt Marvel’s approach in building up to The Justice League, but I think they could go in their strong absent this especially if Man of Steel is a success.

So, like a lot of people I’m a big fan of Geoff John’s run on Green Lantern and hope his work still influences whatever incarnation of the character and his universe that is next portrayed on the big screen, (despite his involvement in the first film) but don’t just want to see ‘Lantern v Lantern’ brawls and hope they approach the series with a slightly more grounded take, focusing on the Corps’ position as space cops more; a cross between Training Day, Dredd and Star Wars seems like the best way to go.

Essentially, for the next Green Lantern film they need to reduce the scale; keep the big space epic in the background but focus on Hal fresh out of training, working with Sinestro investigating Abin Sur’s murder whilst throwing in elements from the comic Secret Origin and the animated film First Flight. This would set up an eventual Blackest Night based film, and allow for a lot of characters and additional lanterns to be introduced in the films in between very naturally. Fiscally, this would be also be a safer bet and creatively, it’d help shine a much need spotlight on two of the most interesting and important characters within the mythos, servicing both fans and newbies alike.

___________________________


Mike Vogel as Hal Jordan/Green Lantern


There’s fair bit of debate amongst fans as to who should be the next live action Green Lantern, especially with so many characters to choose from. Well, I personally believe in giving the original character their dues before moving on to others (unless the original is extremely shit). So, with that in mind, I think Vogel is the best man for the job. He can do drama and comedy and can even play the loveable asshole role well too; that basically covers all grounds.

Anyway, unlike the New 52, I’d prefer a more drastic change up to the character’s (and other Green Lanterns’) costume; yeah it should be armoured and maintain a uniform-like space cop look, but it needs to also effectively display the ring’s power; Shawn Yap’s redesign would be great place to start – Click Here to See

Scot Speedman as Martin Jordan


Casting this role proved to be a little tough for me, but in the end I thought the best way to approach it was to find an actor who could play an older Hal Jordan and had somewhat of a resemblance to Vogel, and ended up going with Speedman. Whilst Speedman doesn’t really have much resemblance to Vogel, he’s a pretty solid actor and definitely gives off the right vibe for a role like this, his recent work in Last Resort also helped give me an idea what he could bring to the table for the role and quite frankly, I think he’d prove to be both a memorable and worthy addition to my cast.

Powers Boothe as Carl Ferris


Boothe can play a sleazy big shot bastard like a pro, and can also bring some presence to his roles too. Quite frankly, whilst this role is hardly big having such an actor in the role would definitely add some class to the cast, plus I like the idea of having an actor like Boothe as one of Hal’s normal ‘villains’.

Michelle Borth as Carol Ferris/Star Sapphire


A lot of you may be scratching your heads as to who Borth is, well admittedly she’s not very well known but her work in Hawaii Five-0 and Combat Hospital have shown she’s got some talent and that she’s played a slightly similar character well in the past. So, if given a chance I think she could impress, if not do a better job than Blake Lively at least.

Steven Yeun as Tom Kalmaku


Original? No, but let’s be honest; it works very well. Yeun’s showcased his acting skills fantastically on The Walking Dead and has even proven himself to be a bit of a badass, but alongside this, the guy is naturally very funny and has a very ‘Peter Parker’ vibe to him that’d definitely help him elevate the role.

Peter Mensah as Abin Sur


I was a huge fan of the Starz TV series Spartacus so will admit to casting a few actors from there. Anyway, Mensah really is the only choice for me here; he’s a ridiculously underrated badass who unfortunately gets the short end of the stick with most of his roles. Given the fact that he can bring a solid world weary and authoritative presence to the role (as seen in Spartacus) I can definitely see him making the character more memorable and appealing.

Hugh Laurie as Tomar Re


Some may see this as being too small a role for Laurie, and I can definitely understand that given his credentials, but still stand by this choice simply as like Geoffrey Rush before him, Laurie could class the role up and just prove to be a solid addition to the cast.

Ving Rhames as Kilowog


Once again, not an original casting choice but there are very few actors who can fit the shoes of the late, great Michael Clarke Duncan well. Rhames has got the voice, the presence and the swagger needed for the role and is very simply the most logical choice for the character.

Terence Stamp and Vanessa Redgrave as Ganthet and Sayd


Casting these roles was kind of tough, but end of the day the roles require actors who can bring class and gravitas to their characters. Stamp and Redgrave are put simply two of the best actors there are; not only are they heavyweight acting legends but they’re also ridiculously versatile and would definitely improve proceedings if cast.

Viola Davis as Amanda Waller


This roles always been pretty tough to cast for me, but Davis is a very talented actress who I can actually picture as an intelligent badass, so it just seems very fitting to cast her here.

Omari Hardwicke as John Stewart/Green Lantern


I won’t lie, I haven’t seen Hardwicke in much and mainly chose him as he seems to be a popular choice for the role, but after checking out some his stuff in Dark Blue I can see him doing the character justice. He can do drama, comedy and action and looks the part, so as far I’m concerned he’s right for the role.

Ben McKenzie as Guy Gardner/Green Lantern


Some might argue McKenzie comes across a bit too calm for the role, but I think he’d be a good fit especially because of his work on Southland. He can play the tough guy and can keep things fairly light so I’d be willing to see what he could do.

Shiloh Fernandez as Kyle Rayner/Green Lantern


Fernandez is relatively unknown actor, but I’ve seen him in a bunch of things now and think he could do a serviceable job. He can do drama and comedy and has the look down plus has a ‘Peter Parker’ vibe to him which I think could work for the rookie Lantern.

Guy Pearce as Thaal Sinestro


I can see myself getting some flak for casting a ‘Marvel’ actor in a DC role, but [frick] it; I wanted Pearce as Sinestro for a while and hope he does get the job one day. He’s retardedly talented, classy, charismatic, suave, badass and pretty versatile, so I think he’d own the role, especially given the fact he’s one of the most engaging actors around even when working with bullshit material (I’m looking at you Prometheus).

John Hawkes as Hector Hammond


Hawkes is a criminally underrated actor with a solid track record; he can play intense, obsessive and dark characters pretty well and is just overall very versatile. Seeing as how the last live screen incarnation of the character was overly camp I can definitely see Hawkes approaching the character in a darker and more grounded vein if given the chance.

Dominic Purcell as Clifford Zmeck/Major Force


Purcell is definitely an underrated actor, whilst I acknowledge he’s done some big duds it still has to be said, when he tries he puts his heart and soul into his work. From his work in Prison Break and Killer Elite I think he’d be more than capable for the role; he’s got the right look, the acting capabilities and is physically a very imposing individual.

Lester Speight as Mark Richards/The Tattooed Man


I haven’t seen Speight in much and from what I gather he’s an actor who’s perceived similarly to Terry Crews (as the comedic muscly black guy), but his roles in Faster and Transformers 3 made me think he’d be able to pull off a role like this. He’s got the potential and physically, he’s a beast so if given the chance I think he’d be able to pull it off.

Eddie Gathegi as Amon Sur


I’ve seen Gathegi in a bunch of things now and put simply, he seems to be the best choice for the role. His roles Gone Baby Gone, Death Sentence and X-Men: First Class served as my reasoning behind this decision; he’s clearly versatile and engaging, plus he brings a certain swagger to his roles and can play a charismatic thug well, so in a role like this, it seems very appropriate to have him cast.

Jason Mamoa as Lobo


The guy played both Khal Drogo and Conan serviceably well. He might not be the greatest actor around, but to be honest Lobo is best known for being a badass who [frick]s shit up; Mamoa seems like an ideal fit in my eyes.

Ron Perlman as Mongul


Perlman is just a badass and talented actor. He’s been cast numerous times for various similar (if not the same) roles both by fans and in films, but if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Like Lobo, Mongul doesn’t really need all that much depth, but Perlman is one actor who could definitely deliver on that in spades and even bring some authority and presence to the role too.

Manu Bennett as Atrocitus


Shout out goes to Splenda for this one!
Another Spartacus actor, but like I said, I love that show. So, why Bennett? His role as Crixus on the aforementioned hit show mesmerised me; he basically played the ‘same’ character, a beast with a heart lost to his rage- so if given the chance to ‘reprise’ this role, it’s pretty clear he’d excel. But ignoring, Bennett is a very intense actor and also very underrated, the fact that he has a fairly unique accent and voice also factored into my decision as I think he could bring something different to the role and elevate the character into something more.

Jude Law as Bro’Dee Walker/Saint Walker


Law is a pretty damn versatile actor and another one of my favourites; he’s charming, charismatic, suave and talented. In a role like this, it could be said he’s too big an actor, but I wouldn’t have it any other way; he’s got the skills and to me is the only choice for the role.

Jackie Earle Haley as Larfleeze/Agent Orange


Haley is another pretty versatile actor, admittedly he’s played a lot of similar character downs the line but he can bring a nice touch of darkness and can bring a lot of humour and charm to his roles too. His work in Watchmen, Little Children and Human Target in particular convinced me he’d the best man for the job.

Cynthia Addai-Robinson as Iroque/Indigo-1


Not to worry, this is the final Spartacus actor I’ve cast. So, why Addai-Robinson? Well, like with Manu Bennett, her character Naevia showed off her talent; she’s a skilled dramatic actress and great with the emotional stuff and action-wise she also knows how to handle herself and look good whilst doing so. Whilst it might be a little clichéd casting her as a tough warrior chick, I think she could really elevate the role and just do wonders in it.

Ben Foster as William Hand/Black Hand


Foster is a wonderfully dark actor; his roles in Hostage, Alpha Dog, 30 Days of Night and even The Mechanic are a testament to that. He’s clearly versatile and has a knack for playing psychotic and damaged characters well, so whilst this role might require someone a little more subtle I still think he’d nail it not only because of his talent but if we’re getting technical, his role in 30 Days of Night was basically a hillbilly version of the character, so it’s pretty clear he’s definitely got what it takes.

Imelda Staunton as Scar


I won’t lie, I found this role pretty tough to cast but am pretty pleased with the end result. Whilst Staunton hasn’t exactly played similar characters to this before, her roles in the Harry Potter series and Psychoville showed off her talents well and showed me she has what it takes to go full on batshit crazy; those of you who know the character will know this is clearly a necessity here.

Malcolm McDowell as Krona


McDowell is another acting legend I’ve cast here, but it fits very well. His roles in A Clockwork Orange and Heroes were what made chose him, as not only did he showcase his range well in those roles but they seemed like ideal spots to draw from with this character, so like a lot of the actors I’ve cast here, I’d love to see him have a go at the character one day.

Michael Wincott as Nekron


I’ve seen Wincott in a bunch of things over the years, but the main reason why I think he’d be good for the job is both due to his memorable voice and his role as Top Dollar in The Crow. His performance there just speaks for itself.

___________________________


So, that’s my ideal cast for Green Lantern. I hope you enjoyed checking it out, and if you did look out for my Flash cast!

About The Author:
MrDonut
Member Since 12/13/2012
DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created Infinite Crisis Video
Related:

DC & Marvel Team Up In Awesome Fan-Created "Infinite Crisis" Video

Star Wars: John Boyega Has Reportedly Met With Lucasfilm About Returning As Finn
Recommended For You:

Star Wars: John Boyega Has Reportedly Met With Lucasfilm About Returning As Finn

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

TheSoulEater
TheSoulEater - 4/25/2013, 12:35 AM
I would actually say get a different Jon Stewart and Sinestro, someone that can breath REAL life into the character as a opposed to just playing him.

Other then that, everyone else here is idealy casted
redhood2710
redhood2710 - 4/25/2013, 6:07 AM
Cool cast!Good Guy Gardener and Abin Sur picks
MrBlueSky
MrBlueSky - 4/25/2013, 6:31 AM
As a big Green lantern fan, I have to say that this cast is awesome!! I applaud you for your originality. I admit that I bullheadedly support Chris Pine for Hal, but I could warm up to Mike Vogel (besides, anyone is better than Reynolds). And I absolutely love your picks for Sinestro, Guy Gardner, and Larfleeze.

Anyway, I'm going to try to post my Avengers cast next week (I've been delaying it for some time). Anyway, what are you working on next (besides your Flash cast)?
MCott
MCott - 4/25/2013, 8:04 AM
This is awesome. Honestly, I didn't expect your Kyle Rayner choice. Mine was Joseph-Gordon Levitt. But, to each his own.

I also like your Mongul choice. But I will say that after Young Justice, I really wanna see Keith David in the role.
MrDonut
MrDonut - 4/25/2013, 8:27 AM
TheSoulEater
- I kind of agree with you about Stewart; there are better actors out there for the role, but I've since become a bit more of a fan of Hardwicke, he's got a lot of talent and is something of a diamond in the rough
- Pearce is one of my favourite actors and I think he's more than capable of excelling in the role, his entire filmography speaks for itself; I really don't think there is anyone better for it
- Cheers for the praise though man, but had to defend my choices lol ;)

redhood2710
Thanks!

MrBlueSky
- Thank you kind sir :D
- Im not against Pine and would love to see him get the gig, but for the sake of originality I opted to go for someone else, and Vogel is the next best choice I think
- Thanks man; gotta say, Im very proud of my Sinestro and Larfleeze too lol...
- Drop it dude, I remember you saying something about an Avengers' cast for a while now; will defo give it a look ;)
- After the Flash I'll probly do some Marvel casts; have had some ideas rattling away in my head for a while now lol... Just want to get the DC ones done first lol...

MCott
- Thanks for checking the cast mate
- I like Levitt but wanted someone who came off as bit younger for the role; Fernandez not only is the right ethnicity but he brings a nice balance of vulnerability and toughness, so seemed like the best choice to me
- Keith David is epic and definitely someone I had in mind, but I passed on that idea as I have another character in mind for him ;)
MikeZ
MikeZ - 4/25/2013, 2:12 PM
I can't really find a lot wrong with this cast. However, Mike Vogel seems to pretty and youthful for Hal Jordan. Plus he's a little on the short side, isn't he? And I'm not really feeling Ben McKenzie as Guy Gardner.

Other than that, no bad. By the way, check out my brand new cast for Titan Maximum. You may have to watch the TV series first, but other than that, I've included choices for crew and even soundtrack ideas that will tickle you.

Also, check out my older fan cast for Panty and Stocking and Garterbelt. The series it's based on is too good to miss out on.
SAT
SAT - 4/25/2013, 5:48 PM
GREAT cast, I pretty much have no problems. I still like who ever voiced Mongul in YJ, but ur pick is great too! I loove your Hal Jordan pick. I think Hal should be young, kind of hot shot like.
ager
ager - 4/26/2013, 5:16 AM
I can honestly say this is the most outstanding fancast in quite a while. After watching Vogal on the last few episodes of Bates Motel, I can honestly say there is no better Hal out there. And when I compliment other fancasts there are many many times were I like the actor chosen but can see another in that role Iay like better. In this case, from top to bottom, I think u have the best possible choices. McKensie might be the only one where there may be a better option, but I am drawing a blank because Jenson Ackles is good for Guy, but is to similar in stature attitude and appearance to Vogal (as Hal), although comes off as more of a hard ass making him not a good for Hal sooooo again fantastic cast. Thumbs up
DatNerdyKid
DatNerdyKid - 4/26/2013, 6:04 AM
I actually thought of Pearce for Sinestro awhile back, and Iron Man 3 just confirmed his villainous capabilities. Everyone else is quite good.
MrDonut
MrDonut - 4/26/2013, 7:16 AM
JokerFanHAhaHA
That's partially why I choose him for the role, care to comment on the rest of the cast?

RoadDogXXIV
- Vogel's often played a ladies man, a lot of Hal-type characters in the past so that works for the character, as for height, well I don't really consider that too much, plus if they can make a 5 foot 9 Tom Hardy appear to be the same height as Chris Bale I'm sure if Vogel is cast they'd work wonders there too
- Casting Guy was pretty tough, but from his earlier work in The O.C. and Southland I think McKenzie has the potential to surprise us
- Cheers for checking it out though dude, will give your stuff a look in a bit ;)

MrSpock
Thanks mate :D

SAT
- Thanks; that's what I had in mind with Vogel as Hal lol...
- It was Keith David who voice Mongul, but as I mentioned up top, I've got another role for him in mind, so stay tuned for my next cast ;)

FreakingIntelligentRobertGriffin
- Thanks, I guess... Have any thoughts about the rest of the cast?
- I went with Vogel for Hal over McKenzie cos he seems more smooth, but can see where you're coming from... Who knows though? Maybe if they get Green Lantern right next time they'll cover more of his history...

ager
- Thanks man, that's quite the compliment :D
- Vogel is a very unsung actor and fairly versatile, so glad to see others can see what Im talking about lol...
- Ackles is a solid choice for Guy, but like you said, he's a bit too much like Hal and that is partially why I went with McKenzie, but am also a big Southland fan so... Lol...

TheAwesomeAvenger456
- Thanks for checking the cast
- I haven't seen Iron Man 3 yet, but Pearce's work in Prometheus (the viral stuff at least), Lawless, Lockout and The Proposition in particular just made me think he'd own as Sinestro
DatNerdyKid
DatNerdyKid - 4/27/2013, 2:03 AM
@MrDonut
I was doing a GL fancast awhile back (I'll eventually put it on this site) with Pearce as Sinestro. How do you think people would react to a Hal Jordan origin story with Sinestro as the villain-SINESTRO injured Abin Sur (causing his death), Fatality is a red herring, Parallax and the Sinestro Corps are officially formed.
JawBreaker1981
JawBreaker1981 - 4/27/2013, 8:04 AM
Great cast

except for Sinestro and Jon Stewart. I think you should keep Mark Strong. He's as good as Pearce if not better IMHO
MrDonut
MrDonut - 4/27/2013, 9:36 AM
TheAwesomeAvenger456
I personally wouldn't mind that but I like the idea of Sinestro 'falling from grace' it just adds depth to him, but it's something that could work, though it might undermine Hal and Sinestro a little bit given that Sinestro is technically evil from his intro...

JawBreaker1981
- Thanks for checking it
- I like Strong and think he did a fantastic job with what little screen time he had, but this cast is fresh task; no old actors, so Pearce was the first choice that came to mind especially as I wanted him in the role first time round

SuperDude001
- Thanks... Lol... Given that the last take on the character was so cheesy I'd like a bit more grit next time round; I'd want it to tonally be a mix between a crime-drama and sci-fi adventure film with some buddy-cop elements injected in somewhere... Basically, a little darker in tone than the first Iron Man
- I've seen a lot of the same actors cast for the role so wanted someone different; Laurie is greatly underrated and can greatly balance humour and drama so it seemed the right way to go... Glad others appreciate the decision :D
LegendaryOutlaw
LegendaryOutlaw - 4/27/2013, 6:10 PM
This movie is doomed to fail. All I needed was to see your choice for Hal Jordan.
DatNerdyKid
DatNerdyKid - 4/27/2013, 9:05 PM
@MrDonut
I know it was an animated movie, but wasn't Sinestro like that in First Flight too? Or at least, he did a LOT of complaining about the Guardians.
MrDonut
MrDonut - 4/28/2013, 8:56 AM
DeadpoolsCommonSense
Cool story bro

TheAwesomeAvenger456
Yeah, I guess it kinda was... But personally speaking, I like to see a bit more character development with Sinestro, but yeah liek I said it could and has worked... I just hope the next big screen incarnation of the character shows Hal and Sinestro investigating Abin's death like First Flight, that I really loved and it also just shows how Green Lanterns are space cops...
View Recorder