Send us YOUR Star Trek Review!

Hey this is sort of a "bad comment" but I just thought that i'd ask anyone who has a steam acount to look me up. I'm called Fatt-Smelliott and I have a nerd clan and we get together occassionally for games and chats. So if you'd like to join that would be great.

Sorry for the advertisement... anyway this looks awesome as i've read lots of good reviews unlike our X-men friend!!!!

Also in Star Trek if Eric Bana could go back in time why didn't he save his home planet?

Just uploaded my review.

This movie was awesome. I give it a perfect 10; 2 thumbs up.

I honestly didn't have anything bad to say about it; It POSSIBLY could have been longer, and I wanted to see a little more character development, because all of the actors/characters were DAMN GOOD.

...oh yeah, and for all of you Anton haters out there; he played Chekov perfectly. ...and his Rusky dialect was great also. I speak Russian; it is my second language, and I also know alot of Russians. Besides, Anton's parents are Russian. So, I'm pretty sure he has a pretty good grasp of the Russian tongue/dialect...just saying.

Anyway, it was great...go see it if you haven't already.

The movie was great, I think what they did with the story was great 10/10 in my book

I wrote a review in another thread but its well worth writting again. This movie was written perfectly, the first ever seprequal. Loved the movie, a solid 10 out of 10 easy. I have never seen a better casted movie remake. I cannot think of one single bad thing about this movie. Nemoys part in the movie was wonderful and its full of small things that will make the most dedicated trek fanatic pee their pants. To be truthful shatner is secondary to the new James T Kirk. I have seen the movie in the theatre 2 times now, and with prices the way they are thats saying something for me. I am very suprised that it has not taken in more at this point. The action was perfect, the acting was brilliant and the visual aspects of this movie was stunning. If you have not seen the movie its a must see.

grif-- i agree. Khan was classic!

I dont want to write a huge review so i'll do it here. JUst saw it today. I love the idea of the new timeline. Urban killed it man. SO like Bones without being a charicature-like impersonation. Kirk, awesome. ALthough, he's not as boyish as everyone made him out to be. His face is a little haggered and scarred. I like he new spock. He's less reserved and has that bottled up calm like a bomb attitude. I also like that the Spocks meet each other. Old spock gets to stay home to help replenish his race. Heh heh! For the good of the people.

Uhura is hot in that little shorty kinda way and alot more useful these days. Scotty, Chekov, great.

I only had tiny problems like spock chasing away the huge monster with a torch. I guess being on a frozen snow planet, fire is pretty rare. That was my only gripe though, way better than wolverine.

Just saw the movie with my family and we all enjoyed it. 8/10.

It was a fun romp, but not as good as I had anticipated. The deviations from TOS didn't ruin it for me the way it would for a Trekkie (Trekker? The debate continues I guess...), but I found that they were harmful in some ways. I think the way Nimoy's Spock struggled with emotion versus Quinto's was much more subtle. This provided a little more mystique that was lacking (IMO) in this interpretation. Kirk got his butt whooped too much. In fact, I don't think there was a fistacuff fight that he won in this. And Bana was the biggest disappointment. Too cliched. I know he's better than what he gave. The deliveries were great by everyone else! I would even say flawless, save Bana. I could tolerate this new direction, but I think some of the elements that they altered were what gave the original it's charm.

Oh well, I know I'm in the minority here judging by the other posts. So I'm gonna get grief for my critique. But I think my points are valid and I will stand by them unless I can be proven that they are not.

the blood was green in the movie i saw, so they did at least get that right.

Eric Bana's character accidentally went back in time... but my review would be.. The goal of Wolverine Origins, was succeeded in Star Trek. They tried to work extremely hard for a quality and very fun film for people without knowledge of the prior stories. One was done well the other was not. Star Trek was done very well with few flaws, as Wolverine was done poorly but still ended up being a fun film. JJ Abrams is indeed the next generations most talented director and may soon contend with the greats with what he is showing us is inside him.

Ok, so I just saw the movie with my son. I am a diehard "Trekkie". Started watching original series at age 10 and never stopped. This movie was absolutely entertaining and on the mark. The alternate universe theme makes sense (it has happened before several times). It was a nice and smooth way to keep the interest of the old fans. Young Kirk is perfect as someone finding his way, struggling to find his niche. It makes sense that young Kirk should be immature in his star fleet days. Young Spock has to struggle more with his human side, his struggle should become more subtle as he grows older. The story was well written and I loved that included the little things that made the TOS so popular! Remember, this alternate universe is not written in stone. Who knows, in the next movie older Spock may share the technology to go back in time to save Vulcan and Romulus and then Kirk can grow up knowing his father therefore become the more self assured captain we have all come to know and love! One thing is for sure, my 12 year old son loved it and looks like he too will be as big a fan of Star Trek as his proud mother! Definitely a must see. Don't cut it into pieces just enjoy! At the theater today people were clapping and cheering through the whole movie and in the end they all stood and clapped--now thats a review!!! Can't wait for the next one!!!

Antonio Banderas for KHAN!

lol jk :)

Hmmmm. Then again...? ;)

Why must everything today be about redoing old stories? Khan was greatness. Remaking it would be an insult to the memory of Ricardo Montalban. If and when a sequel is made, how about some original villains (as in new) rather than rehashing old ones?

I am not a Trek fan myself i only ever watched the classic episodes when i had days off from school. but this movie has changed everything for me i loved this flick. Definitely a 10/10. The action was fantastic, the cgi was perfecto, and the acting was great. Just got to say Kirk is way hotter than Shatner! And Bones was so damn hilarious (I loved the "Damn It Jim!")
Seriously, i never thought that Spock and Uhura would get together.
This movie has changed it all for me, can't wait to see more, JJ is a freakin' genius!