5. Peter Parker
While an argument could be made that Sam Raimi never quite got Spider-Man right (where were the wisecracks?), his Peter Parker was definitely spot on thanks to the likeable Tobey Maguire. For Andrew Garfield, his wall-crawler was a lot closer to the comic books, but his Peter...well, he was an unlikeable tool. Whether it was treating his uncle like crap, stalking his girlfriend, or being an all round hipster douche, this Peter was wrong on so many levels.
Spending time with him was a chore, and one of the biggest problems here was the fact that Marc Webb made his Spider-Man so "cool." Unlike the comic book version of the character, Peter wasn't a nerd or a social outcast; he was an expert skateboarder dating the hottest girl in school. In an attempt to update the wall-crawler, what makes him special was lost.
3. Harry Osborn
The first two Spider-Man movies did a pretty great job with Harry Osborn. Sure, things went horribly wrong in the third instalment when he went nuts and started flying around on a snowboard, but James Franco did a great job even with that lame material. The Amazing Spider-Man 2's Dane DeHaan on the other hand did not fare so well.
Despite impressing in Chronicle, his performance here was horrible from start to finish. Harry's rushed story arc saw him become a Green Goblin with frizzy white hair, some weird scars, and a set of false teeth which made DeHaan sound like he was reeling off his lines with a mouthful of food. Having Harry become the Goblin before his father Norman was another pathetic attempt by this franchise to stand out from what came before, but it completely missed the point of what motivates this villain as a result.