Arrows "realistic" approach = No "Super" Heroes

Arrows "realistic" approach = No "Super" Heroes

Is this idea a good thing for the show in the long run?

Editorial Opinion
By Blame - Mar 11, 2013 09:03 PM EST
Filed Under: Arrow



Although it's been almost one season now that Arrow has been on television the fan following has been going strong. Oliver Queen was never thought of as a top level character created by DC comics, but in recent years rose to that occasion. It was mostly due to the enormous popularity status of the 10 season long hit series Smallville which made the character a series regular by the time season 8 rolled around. That shows story lines (plus the performance by Justin Hartley) is what made Oliver Queen an instant favorite among long time fans of the show. So much of a favorite that people actually wanted Oliver to get his own spin off series even before Smallville ran its course. They also wanted Justin to stay on as the title character since his popularity grew also. At first the shows creators stayed far away from even bringing any acknowledgement to a possible series starring the "Emerald Archer", but the network itself saw the potential of bringing such a show to fruition.


Don't expect to ever see something like this on Arrow.


Fastforward 5 seasons later and the end of an era finally came to a close as the boy who would eventually become a "Superman" finally took flight into the history books. Solidifying its place among the longest lasting shows in television history. Afterwards people were left wondering when or even if a new superhero series was on the horizon to take Smallville's place. Those questions quickly got answered, because no less than a year and a half later the fans of that show got their wish granted (sort of). Usher in the new man in green tights with the CW's brand new series simply titled "Arrow". Stephen Amell is the new guy taking up the mantle as Star Citys current protector, but from a different perspective. It seems that although it hasn't been on the air long enough a distinct similarity can be made between this show and Christopher Nolan's superhero trilogy. Arrow definitely differs in overall tone in comparison to its fellow super show brethren Smallville.


Can boxing glove arrows exist in the "real" world?


The stories plus the way Oliver goes about delivering his brand of "justice" just shows how opposite this show, and its star character is from what was presented on Smallville. That brings me to my article headline which clearly points out the very obvious absence this show will have to get over no matter how much fans want to see it. In a world like the one Nolan presented in his stories it was obvious that Bruce Wayne would never get a visit from his "super friends" in any movie team up. This will also be the case when it comes to any potential appearance from super beings joining Oliver in his crusade to fight crime. One of Smallville's strongest assets which helped it to stay on for such a long time was having DC universe characters at their disposal to use from time to time. Yes they were restricted from using certain people, but at least they were able to put together some type of version of the league that wasn't horrible. Arrow won't be able to do that unless they intend on making a group of non super powered heroes, but how many people would really get hyped about that idea?
ARROW Star Stephen Amell Claims They Tried To Make A GREEN ARROW Movie But Warner Bros. Killed It
Related:

ARROW Star Stephen Amell Claims They "Tried" To Make A GREEN ARROW Movie But Warner Bros. "Killed" It

ARROW Star Stephen Amell On Why He Didn't F***ing Appreciate James Gunn's Jab At Green Arrow In PEACEMAKER
Recommended For You:

ARROW Star Stephen Amell On Why He "Didn't F***ing Appreciate" James Gunn's Jab At Green Arrow In PEACEMAKER

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Tainted87
Tainted87 - 3/11/2013, 10:30 PM
A boxing glove arrow could definitely exist - it just has a compressed air pellet that inflates the material like a balloon. Would it be EFFECTIVE? Hell to the no! It wouldn't travel very far, and really, how much damage would it actually do? It'd be like throwing a pool noodle at someone.

I love the action on the show - it is without a doubt, the best part. The "realism", however, is something entirely different and lacking. If you're watching a tv show expecting to see something that could be performed out on the street, then you're wasting your time.

To me, there doesn't need to be a lot, or even a little bit of "super" on the show. It's about Green Arrow.
JonasWepeel
JonasWepeel - 3/12/2013, 1:34 AM
@Tainted87

Lol on the offensive capabilities of a thrown pool noodle. For some reason that image cracked me up.
JonasWepeel
JonasWepeel - 3/12/2013, 1:36 AM
@Tainted87

Promise I'm no trolling, but I just pictured the 300 scene with all the arrows except it was pool noodles.
GuardianDevil
GuardianDevil - 3/12/2013, 2:33 AM
^^hahaha I just pictured that, it looks hilarious.
MrDonut
MrDonut - 3/12/2013, 8:59 AM
Boxing glove arrows? No I imagine as Arrow becomes the Green Arrow we know and love and a little less violent he starts using arrows with weights at the end to knock guys out
jaysin420
jaysin420 - 3/12/2013, 1:11 PM
I hate it, I think there's enough realism on tv and in movies right now.

I know Green Arrow doesn't have superpowers but it's really boring when the villain's don't either.

He might as well just be a cop whose nickname is Arrow.
LEEE777
LEEE777 - 3/12/2013, 1:45 PM
Why ppl think ARROW is like Nolan's Batman.... hell anyone knows we've had gritty DC comics for decades!

I was a Nolan fan till Rises... all he did was make Batman real like he's been done a 100 times in the comic book...

Still love BEGINS and TDK tho :P

As for ARROW, sure no SUPER Villains... maybe in season 3 we'll see some, we don't really need super powers, been done in SMALLVILLE... and look how that turned out, plus Green Arrows there too lol.

Anyways ARROW deff the best series on TV at the mo, all's fogriven CW!

Nice read.
tonytony
tonytony - 3/12/2013, 8:43 PM
@leee777 real talk.
Yeaton10
Yeaton10 - 3/22/2013, 5:56 PM
It is certainly true that the Green Arrow in Smallville was what convinced a lot of us that the character would make a great TV show. You are also correct when you discuss "realism" in the show that they created, the word belongs in quotation marks. Having said that I think the show delivers a reasonable version of the character we love from comic books and Smallville, and reasonable cartoons, and the story quality is actually better than Smallville (which had better story quality than 90% of television garbage).

The reason that introducing super powers into the show might be a good idea is that the overall action might improve. Right now Ollie's super accurate archery,unrealistic super martial arts skills and Smoak's super hacking skills make Ollie's team almost unbeatable which dents the action. Better action would force the heroes to deal with their vulnerability and make for better drama.

In the comic books, Ollie battles real super villains and wins. Why can't arrow do the same thing.
View Recorder