What Makes A Good Villain?

What Makes A Good Villain?

Nihilism, Pacifism, Death, Love.... What makes a villain interesting? Is it our fascination with good and evil, and right or wrong? Is it relating to a fictional character on a human level and understanding their mindset and actions? Check out my thoughts after the jump....

Editorial Opinion
By EricBorder - Sep 05, 2015 08:09 AM EST
Filed Under: Comics

I started watching “Narcos” this weekend on Netflix and it’s a really good show.  The portrayal of Pablo Escobar got me thinking about villains, and about something Adam Driver said during Comic Con this year,
 
Driver said,

“We didn’t have a lot of conversations about ‘bad’ or ‘evil’ when we were shooting. It was more, what do you think is the difference between being bad, and being right? Someone who thinks they’re right is something different, that’s almost more evil, a group of people who’ve decided that they’re morally justified in behaving a certain way.”  (Click Here for more)

 
Let’s dissect this a little and take a look at some of our favorite villains
 
The Joker
 
My favorite villain and comic book character may seem like a Joke at first but when you look a little deeper and get to know the character, he is far from just some guy who smiles and looks like he could own a circus.
 
One of The Joker’s strongest ideations is that one bad day can cause anyone to completely break and go insane.  This is one of the coolest mindsets for a villain because the motivation behind his actions relies on proving that “life can break your heart, life can break your soul, and life can turn you completely and utterly insane”.  This is a perfect contrast to Batman’s ideation, “life can break your soul, but it should never break your spirit”.
 


 
Within The Joker you have the makings of a perfect villain.  If you’re sane, he wants to make you insane.  If you’re insane, he wants to keep you as a pet and use you as a pawn.  If you’re scared, he wants you to realize how big of a Joke life really is, he wants you to see the funny side of life, he wants to break your heart.
 

 
If you’re Batman he just wants to have some fun.  That fun can involve beating his sidekicks to death with a tire iron, paralyzing the daughter of his ally, cutting off the right hand of Batman’s right hand man, or taking enough muscle relaxant pills and using pigmentation to conceal his identity in plain site of The Batman.  Completely outsmarting The Bat in the process.

Thanos
 

 
Thanos is another character that has the makings of a great villain.
 
Pacifism
 
Nihilism
 
Love
 
Death
 
To the uninitiated and uninformed Thanos may look like a purple Hellboy in armor, but to the initiated and informed Thanos is a nihilist that is obsessed with the concept of Death and is willing to commit genocide on his own people.
 
He was born with grey skin and a massive body due to deviant syndrome.  Thanos was an ill-tempered child that became obsessed with the concept of Death in his early years.  He was able to augment his Eternal strengths through meditation, as he grew in power, his thirst for conquest and domination increased.  He stole a starship, traveled to other star systems and recruited an entire army, and nuked is home world Titan killing thousands including his mother, Sui-San.
 
Thanos eventually met the embodiment of Death itself and fell in love.  To make himself worthy of Death’s love, Thanos seized control of extremely powerful items like the Cosmic Cube, the Infinity Stones, and ultimately the Infinity Gauntlet attempting to destroy and conquer to gain the affection of Death.
 
Once again, one of the most interesting aspects to Thanos and why he is such a good villain is because he believes that he is right
 
Thanos’ mother, Sui-San tried to kill Thanos at first sight.  The doctor’s actually had to sedate his mother as ordered by the Eternal Mentor.  Thanos went on to be the smartest child in his school and a pacifist that was isolated because of his looks due to deviant syndrome.
 
In the story Thanos Rising, Thanos is falsely accused and believed by the people of Titan to have murdered his friends.  With his friends now dead, Thanos was isolated and alone once again.  In retrospect, Thanos believes that he could have saved his friends if he dropped his overly passive nature.  This led Thanos  on the path to becoming the Mad Titan.
 
Thanos is a very relatable character.  In a way, he has gotten the short end of the stick since birth but instead of wallowing in self-pitty, he decides to make something of himself.  Every time Thanos fails or his plans are destroyed, he either returns to that ill-tempered child or he is taught a lesson by Adam Warlock returning him to his overly passive nature.
 

 
One thing is for sure, Thanos believes that he is right and he has the power and intelligence to attract others to his cause and destroy those that interfere.
 
Nihilism is an important belief for both the Joker and Thanos and it plays an important part in their stories and motivations.  How do you truly defeat someone that believes life has no objective meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value?
 
A recent comic book movie example of how the villain is simply evil for the sake of being, evil, is Malekith The Accursed from Thor: The Dark World.  The movie in itself was not a bad movie but Malekith suffered from being an underdeveloped villain with poorly explained ideals and motivations that was portrayed to perfection by actor, Christopher Eccleston.  The movie also chose to leave out the history behind Malekith, why his face was scarred in the comics, and why he believes that War is inevitable and that there will always be war.
 
A good fictional villain is more than just a news story, he’s more than just a monster, and he’s more than just a bad individual.  A good fictional villain has as much soul and as much spirit as the hero, and one of the most entertaining things to watch on screen is to see either the villain take the heroes spirit away or to see the hero slowly crush the villains hopes and dreams.
 
Either way, somebody is going to get their heart broken.

About The Author:
EricBorder
Member Since 3/21/2015
“ALAMU: Diary of a Street Lagosian” Is The Bold New Motion Comic Redefining African Urban Drama
Related:

“ALAMU: Diary of a Street Lagosian” Is The Bold New Motion Comic Redefining African Urban Drama

AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #19 Preview Sees Peter Parker Forced To Make One Of His Toughest Decisions Yet
Recommended For You:

AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #19 Preview Sees Peter Parker Forced To Make One Of His Toughest Decisions Yet

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

View Recorder