USER POLL: Top 10 Favorite Superhero Movies of all Time

USER POLL: Top 10 Favorite Superhero Movies of all Time

Question: What are your top ten superhero movies of all time? Note: Before you answer, consider watch ability... Can you look at this film indefinitely and enjoy it in the same manner time and time again?

How strongly do you feel about the film? Would you be upset if it were re-booted?

Feature Opinion
By dageekundaground - Oct 31, 2010 01:10 PM EST
Filed Under: Other




10. Hellboy (2004)

The opening sequence in this movie is almost worth the price of admission alone. Hellboy is a classic example of smart producing. Guillermo Del Toro was an avowed fan of Mignola before snagging the director’s chair for this adaptation. [Note: The opening sequence of Hellboy convinced me that Del Toro would be the perfect director for a Captain America Film.] Ron Perlman is canon as the gruff, blue collar demigod / demon & would be hero.






09. Blade II (2002)

Del Toro again firing on all cylinders as he took the BLADE franchise in a different direction, infusing it with a keen comic book feel. So far this movie has one of the best END FIGHTS in comic book movie history as Wesley Snipes and Luke Goss tear up the place in spectacular fashion. With BLADE II, Del Toro proves that he understands crisp story telling, vivid imagery and proper framing of action sequences. A lot of future directors in this genre could do worse when searching for a template to use as reference for future projects.





08. The Crow (1994)

This movie is just a treat to watch as it makes perfect use of a small contained simple plot to tell a dark gothic tinged tale of vengeance. The movie feels almost magical in some respects with its German expressionistic blended with urban decay production design. Brandon Lee makes this movie what it is …. A CLASSIC.




07. Batman Returns (1992)

Tim Burton’s sequel to his franchise opening and record making (40 Million opening weekend) Batman Series. Here I got more of a sense of the director as Tim was allowed to indulge his vision more fully and the sequel benefits greatly because of this. You can feel Burton just under the skin of a lot of the onscreen characters (i.e.; The Penguin, Catwoman & Max Schrek). The gothic set dressings, double entendres and graphic violence are dialed WAY up to Hard R levels. On the plus side also, Michelle Piefer definitively captures the role of Catwoman much in the same way Jake Nicholson had with Joker in the previous film. Every time I watch this film, I wish Burton had been fully allowed to indulge his vision with the first Batman film.




06. Blade (1998)

I really like this film for a lot of reasons, but chief among them would be that it really feels like it takes place in the MARVEL UNIVERSE. Stephen Norrington succeeds at creating a self contained universe and the reason this film succeeds is because of that creative vision and attention to detail. Funny, but I have to mention the first X-Men movie (2000) because if you play these two back to back, it definitely feels like Blade could exist in their world. These movies have somewhat of a similar esthetic of heightened reality.




05. The Watchmen (2009)

Zack Snyder was under an intense amount of scrutiny and pressure to deliver a DECENT ADAPTATION of Alan Moore’s industry defining graphic novel “The Watchmen”. You know what? He SUCCEEDS on all levels delivering a film that has endless watch ability. I honestly never get tired of looking at this film as it has all the things “REAL” fanboys piss and moan about there not being enough of in other comic book movies.





There are brightly colored costumes that aren’t purposely made to look silly, astonishing visuals, and enough decently shot action to please any comic book movie aficionado. This movie is like a superhero version of Pulp Fiction or
Gone with the Wind.

[Because of this film, I am heartened that Snyder can deliver at least a decent Superman film.]




04. Superman II (1980)

One word … “Zod!!”

Terrence Stamp is featured in this sequel as the BIG BAD, and he makes the most of the opportunity while behaving totally somnambulistic for most of the proceedings. Along with Sarah Douglas and Jack O’Halloran, Stamp menaces the world as no other. When not busy rubbing out small town USA or defacing Mount Rushmore, these extraterrestrial criminals are casually taking control of the earth. Where is Superman during all of this? He’s taking a sick day so that he can loose his virtue to Lois Lane (Margot Kidder).

My favorite scene involves the de-powered Superman, now completely Clark Kent watching a newscast after receiving his first REAL ass beating from a thug like trucker. During the special bulletin, the president (E.G. Marshall) breaks character while reading the planet’s written surrender and pleads for Superman’s help. The following p.o.v shot reveals Zod who becomes enraged and also implores Superman to try and stop him before the screen gives way to an emergency test code.)

And last but not least, my next favorite scene involves a humbled and contrite Superman apologizing to the president for basically screwing up.

Note: Sometimes looking back on this sequel, I feel like it screwed up the rest of the franchise. I mean, what kind of credible threat could you logically follow Zod with at that time?




03. Batman Begins (2005)

Finally, a movie about “Batman” … David S. Goyer and Christopher Nolan combined to make what feels like a truly personal and epic piece of filmmaking. This movie finally places the Dark Knight center stage in the proceedings. I hadn’t seen anything as good as this since the first Superman movie by Richard Donner.

This movie comes tricked out with A-list actors like Morgan Freeman, Michael Caine and Liam Neeson, a Blade Runner-esque Gotham City and finally (there’s that word again) a Batman (Christian Bale)that actually looks like he can take somebody’s head off.

Its BIGGEST asset and conceit is that it is world’s different from the earlier franchise begun by Tim Burton and destroyed by Joel Schumacher.

I felt that the movie was so good that I actually wished that there would be no sequel.





02. The Dark Knight (2008)

“I felt that the movie was so good that I actually wished that there would be no sequel.”

Boy was I wrong!!

Nolan showed me that he definitely had more in the tank when it came to the caped crusader. This movie is shot for shot-PERFECTION!! I actually have no complaints or quips regarding any facet of this production.

Now that being said ….

I wish there were no sequel to this film.

(Note: We all know the third movie curse of most superhero franchises i.e.; Spiderman 3.)




01. SUPERMAN the movie (1978)

The One that stated it all (For me at least.). Let’s face it, Superman has always been around in one form or another, but Richard Donner’s 1978 opus is the POP CULTURE personified. This movie is epic and a great piece of Americana.

Donner realized early on during the preproduction of this film that a number of elements central to the comic could possibly appear cheesy and campy. So he made “verisimilitude” a driving force while shooting this Iconic origin story.

Consider this … Superman the movie is completely entertaining and engrossing even before the title character appears and that’s well at the halfway point in the movie.


This grounds the rest of the movie which plays like a 1930’s pulp serial without the inclusion of the Superman’s origin and time in Smallville.

CHRISTOPHER REEVES IS SUPERMAN!!


There you have it … my TOP 10 FAVORITE SUPERHERO MOVIES OF ALL TIME!!

Question:

What are your top ten superhero movies of all time?

Note: Before you answer, consider watch ability …. Can you look at this film indefinitely and enjoy it in the same manner time and time again?

How strongly do you feel about the film? Would you be upset if it were re-booted?

Place your lists in the comments section of this article.


…. Shadowgeek10 returns to the shadows once more ….
About The Author:
dageekundaground
Member Since 8/13/2010
Magic the Gathering Just Leaked Four Epic Marvel Super Heroes Cards
Related:

Magic the Gathering Just Leaked Four Epic Marvel Super Heroes Cards

Warner Bros. Discovery Shareholders Approve Paramount Merger - But Reject David Zaslav's Massive Payday
Recommended For You:

Warner Bros. Discovery Shareholders Approve Paramount Merger - But Reject David Zaslav's Massive Payday

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

LEEE777
LEEE777 - 10/31/2010, 2:35 PM
Pretty much good going, good stuff no FOX movies lol! ; D

I'd say WATCHMEN is more than 5 tho, its right behind SUPERMAN I in my book!



What no BATMAN '89 or SPIDER-MAN 1 & 2?


THE CROW is deff in there, awesome movie!
jaysin420
jaysin420 - 10/31/2010, 2:55 PM
Great list, I totally agree with your top 4. I haven't seen the Blade movies though so I'd switch them with Spiderman 2 and Xmen 2.
Ethic
Ethic - 10/31/2010, 3:13 PM
Nice list,
I'd throw in Burton's 1st Batman, Hellboy 2 annnnnnd Dark Knight again lol

Dark Knight is top of my list but i still think theres a better Batmann film to be made in future.

The Dark Knight isn't as dark as it's made out to be at all, and i think the whole idea of strict realism isn't the best way to create Bats world.

Genius films in there own way but i'm still waiting for the real Batman.


..Yea i like Batman
redson
redson - 10/31/2010, 3:14 PM
10. SPIDERMAN 2 (VERSION 2.0)
9. SPIDERMAN
8. INCREDIBLE HULK (2008)
7. BATMAN RETURNS
6. SUPERMAN RETURNS
5. BATMAN (1989)
4. TDK
3. BATMAN BEGINS
2.SUPERMAN 2 (DONNER'S VERSION)
1. SUPERMAN (DIRECTOR'S CUT)
Angelus
Angelus - 10/31/2010, 4:58 PM
Superman reigns supreme, of course.

BMP!
dageekundaground
dageekundaground - 10/31/2010, 6:21 PM
@ Kyos

STFU !!! Get the HELL off my page.
Kyos
Kyos - 10/31/2010, 7:15 PM
@dageekunderground

Okay, listen man, next time I'll try to be my normal positive and constructive me again, but this is one of the few things that really tick me off. Because Watchmen is very dear to me, and although I really wanted to love the movie I just can't. Which makes me sad. Someday I might write an editorial about what my fanboy problems with the movie are, who knows. Most people on this site seem to like it, and I'm happy for them, I really am.

But there are so many - and I mean SO [frick]ING MANY - people who call the movie "THE" Watchmen. Which is, all other things aside (there are reasons it’s called Watchmen), just not the title of the movie. Nor is it, as you say in this article, the title of Alan Moore’s industry defining graphic novel. I can understand how this mistake can happen (a lot), it's one of the misunderstandings that comes from the movie calling an actual group of crime fighters The Watchmen. Still, when writing about it in an article claiming it's your top 5 comic book movie, even talking about the importance and influence of the source material, it should be possible to get it right. Even the movie poster without the “the” is there. And the trailer.

So, if the tone of my first, now deleted post offended you in some way, I hereby withdrew the critical sentence "Article dismissed" and apologize. Your article is fine, I like it, and I would never have bothered attacking you the way I did had it not contained a mistake that just personally pisses me off, because I seem to be correcting the very same mistake in lots of discussions here that involve Watchmen. Maybe others fans would be annoyed too if a great percentage of people would speak about “Crow”, “The Superman - The Movie”, “The Batman Begins” and “Dark Knight”.

That’s about what I have to say, I hope we can make peace now and you will not delete this comment (cause it took a little longer to type than the last one ^^)!
BrotherQStark
BrotherQStark - 10/31/2010, 8:53 PM
Forgetting Iron Man?
dageekundaground
dageekundaground - 11/1/2010, 2:29 AM
@ MrAnonymous

You can include him on your list ... This is MY list and Iron Man doesn't fit into my top 10.

BTW: Iron Man feels like a car commercial to me ... and you can read my review of both movies on my page.
Orphix
Orphix - 11/1/2010, 7:56 AM
Some good choices on the whole BUT I wouldn't include Watchmen on the list - mainly because it was trying so hard to stick to the source material it forgot to be a film.

Apart from the Bob Dylan 'Times they are a changing' track was pretty much dissapointed with the whole thing.

Good shout with the Superman chioces tho :o)
Destroyer14
Destroyer14 - 11/1/2010, 10:55 AM
Spider-Man 3 is my number one.
Denn1s
Denn1s - 11/1/2010, 3:30 PM
spiderman 2 anyone? x2? iron man? tih?
antonio
antonio - 11/1/2010, 7:00 PM
1-tdk
2-watchmen
3-iron man 2
4-batman begins
5-spiderman 2
6-iron man
7-x2
8-sin city
9-v for vendetta
10-superman 2
RaMan
RaMan - 11/28/2010, 7:57 PM
Everybody has it all wrong!! Here is the top 10 super hero movies of all time in proper order:
1-tdk
2-spiderman
3-iron man
4-the incredible hulk 2008
5-spiderman 2
6-batman begins
7-fantastic four
8-superman returns
9-superman
10-xmen 2
View Recorder