"I Don't Agree With It": ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY Director On His Movie Being Hailed As Lucasfilm's Best

"I Don't Agree With It": ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY Director On His Movie Being Hailed As Lucasfilm's Best

Doing the rounds to promote Jurassic World Rebirth, filmmaker Gareth Edwards has reflected on Rogue One's legacy and the fact it's widely hailed as the best Star Wars movie from Lucasfilm's Disney era.

By JoshWilding - Jun 26, 2025 09:06 PM EST
Filed Under: Star Wars
Source: SFFGazette.com

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story was hailed as one of the franchise's best movies and biggest surprises when it opened in 2016. Its success pointed to Lucasfilm's plans for a slate of "A Star Wars Story" spin-offs being a win for the studio; instead, Solo underperformed two years later, and the concept was scrapped. 

Still, the love for the movie has only increased since the release of the prequel series Andor on Disney+. Despite that, director Gareth Edwards isn't looking to use the show's momentum—which he had no involvement with—to mount a comeback on the Galaxy Far, Far Away.

"I'm very happy to move on and do my thing," Edwards told Business Insider (via SFFGazette.com) while promoting Jurassic World: Rebirth. "[Star Wars is] the thing that was in my life before I knew what a film was. It's like your mom, it's like something that's a part of you. I'm always fascinated by what they're doing. I never stop loving that trilogy."

When it was put to him that many fans view Rogue One as the best Star Wars movie from the Disney era, Edwards responded, "I don't agree with it, but I appreciate it. I'm very grateful that people say nice things."

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story was a critical and commercial hit, though it's since been reported that eventual Andor showrunner Tony Gilroy was brought in to take charge of extensive reshoots, largely designed to reshape the final act. 

Edwards remained involved (he filmed that epic Darth Vader sequence, for example), but we know the 2016 movie underwent some major changes, hence why several scenes from the trailers - like Orson Krennic piloting a TIE Fighter to take down Jyn Erso - were absent. 

The filmmaker doesn't appear to have any hard feelings, anyway. That's evident from how he looks back at Rogue One's legacy all these years later. "What you have to keep in your pocket as you go through making other films, is that it's not about how people feel the day it gets released, it's how people feel about it 10, 20 years from now."

"When you make a movie, you're living at least a year from now, you're trying to imagine what it's like, all these decisions you're making, what they are going to be like a year from now when this movie is released, what's the audience going to think?" 

"And as the movie comes out, you go, 'I'm going to pretend I'm living 10 years from now, and it doesn't matter what people say in the moment,'" Edwards continued. "It's the kid who comes up to you 20 years from now and goes, 'Oh my God, I loved that movie!' I think that's the reward."

Do you think Rogue One: A Star Wars Story is the best Disney-era Star Wars movie? Let us know your thoughts on that in the comments section below.

[It Was] All Very Conceptual: THE LAST JEDI Director Rian Johnson Opens Up On Scrapped STAR WARS Trilogy
Related:

"[It Was] All Very Conceptual": THE LAST JEDI Director Rian Johnson Opens Up On Scrapped STAR WARS Trilogy

STAR WARS: Mark Hamill Reveals The Tragic Luke Skywalker Backstory He Created For The Last Jedi
Recommended For You:

STAR WARS: Mark Hamill Reveals The Tragic Luke Skywalker Backstory He Created For The Last Jedi

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

CplHicks
CplHicks - 6/26/2025, 9:28 PM
It's easily the best of the Disney era. Only regret is it would have been cool if it came out after Andor finished.
bkmeijer1
bkmeijer1 - 6/27/2025, 2:41 AM
@CplHicks - but Andor wouldn't exist without Rogue One. And I like it this way. Watched the movie back when it came out and thinking Andor was an interesting character, but now I watch the movie with a completely new understanding
NonPlayerC
NonPlayerC - 6/27/2025, 2:53 AM
@CplHicks -User Comment Image
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 6/27/2025, 4:19 AM
@bkmeijer1 - Some of the beginning doesn't flow with Andor.

The scene where Andor learns about the Empire's secret weapon for example. Now you have to squint your eyes and pretend that Andor is acting like he's just learning about it but he knew about it all along.

Then when he tells the resistance on Yavin and they're all surprised you have to squint your eyes till they bleed.
bkmeijer1
bkmeijer1 - 6/27/2025, 4:21 AM
@ObserverIO - I saw it as confirming intelligence.

They didn't believe Kleya because it was just a single mention, but with Andor's second bit of intel they knew the threat was real and started acting fast.
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 6/27/2025, 4:26 AM
@bkmeijer1 - Yeah that's really the only way of making it work I think. But that's obviously not the intent of those moments in Rogue One, so it still feels off. Like it's canon, but it just doesn't flow very well.
bkmeijer1
bkmeijer1 - 6/27/2025, 5:20 AM
@ObserverIO - I get that. It's one of the things I look at differently now.
dracula
dracula - 6/26/2025, 9:29 PM
Its not star wars best

But it is disney star wars best
DarthOmega
DarthOmega - 6/26/2025, 10:18 PM
@dracula - 101%
asherman93
asherman93 - 6/26/2025, 9:41 PM
I think its a decent film, but I'd argue TFA and TLJ were better.

(I have not seen Andor, but I have heard nothing but positive things about the show, and I'm sure I'll love it.)
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 6/26/2025, 9:53 PM
@asherman93 - I agree

Star Wars Disney era film ranking (favorite to least).

1.The Last Jedi
2.The Force Awakens
3.Rogue One
4.Solo
5.The Rise of Skywalker
tylerzero
tylerzero - 6/26/2025, 10:08 PM
@asherman93 -

“I'd argue TFA and TLJ were better.”

User Comment Image
Deklipz
Deklipz - 6/27/2025, 12:33 PM
@asherman93 - TLJ was phenomenal. My dad walked out of that thoroughly impressed by the emotional impact it made on him as he had always just seen Star Wars as ‘blasters and spaceships’ essentially. It was well written, wonderfully acted, and brought more to the deep lore than most of the other mainline content ever has.

As an aside, the best Star Wars movie ever could come out under Disney and people would cry about it because it’s not ‘what they wanted’ which was the entire issue with the sequels. Yeah 9 was overblown bullshit in the 3rd act, but outside of that the trilogy is solid.
Pathogen
Pathogen - 6/27/2025, 5:23 PM
@asherman93 - lmao wow. That is a choice, I guess
asherman93
asherman93 - 6/28/2025, 11:00 PM
@TheVisionary25 - Y'know, speaking as a TROS defender... that seems like a fair ranking.
Forthas
Forthas - 6/26/2025, 9:45 PM
Ironically, Gareth Edward's name has been tossed about as a successor to Villeneuve in the Dune franchise. I think Tony Gilroy would be a better fit and would love it if he had a Kathleen Kennedy type role in evolving the Dune franchise especially if they turn to stories outside of the books.
tmp3
tmp3 - 6/26/2025, 11:16 PM
@Forthas - Edwards on Dune would be genuinely awful. Generational step down from Denis
Forthas
Forthas - 6/27/2025, 12:58 AM
@tmp3 - So who would you recommend?
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 6/26/2025, 9:55 PM
Honestly , I also don’t agree it’s the best one from Disney personally but I do think it was enjoyable.

I haven’t rewatched it since Andor ended so perhaps I might feel more positively about it but as is , the movies characters are mostly thinly written I feel & just fine with the performances elevating them to varying degrees (the standouts being K2SO and Chirrut Imwe imo) aswell as help keep the story engaging imo…

The visuals , score and other technical elements are well done also.

Overall , it’s a decent film but certainly not my favorite of this current era.

User Comment Image
Gmoney84
Gmoney84 - 6/26/2025, 10:08 PM
Empire is still the best overall. Rogue One is hands down the best Disney film and my personal number 2.
Pathogen
Pathogen - 6/27/2025, 5:24 PM
@Gmoney84 - Twinsies!
Mercwitham0uth
Mercwitham0uth - 6/26/2025, 10:13 PM
It's the only good Star Wars film from Disney.
tmp3
tmp3 - 6/26/2025, 11:15 PM
Lets be honest - Tony Gilroy saved this movie. Edwards is good at capturing scale, but he’s so dramatically inert in terms of anything else. The dialogue scenes in Godzilla and JW Rebirth are so awful that it almost feels like they were directed by an alien who’s never had a real human conversation in their life.
SheepishOne
SheepishOne - 6/26/2025, 11:47 PM
I don’t care what anyone says, TFA on its own is a good Star Wars movie, especially as the first installment of a trilogy. It becomes progressively, retroactively worse with TLJ and TROS.

Looking at the whole trilogy though, TLJ is the most interesting (and I HATED it when I saw it). It at least asks interesting questions, even if it disregards them altogether and is ultimately the least consequential Star Wars movie of them all.

TROS is the single worst Star Wars film ever made, and by a fair amount. It’s the movie that killed all hope for the franchise for me.
ChrisRed
ChrisRed - 6/27/2025, 12:11 AM
It is the best SW movie yo be released by Disney (although I also liked Solo).

Hopefully, the Mando movie will be as good as the Mando show.

Sadly, bad planning and bad writing ruined the sequel trilogy leading a lot of fans (me included) to pretend it doesn't exist.
THEDARKKNIGHT1939
THEDARKKNIGHT1939 - 6/27/2025, 12:57 AM
It's decent. I really only like it for the Vader scene.
boiling
boiling - 6/27/2025, 1:07 AM
Yea what an accomplishment when the bar is THAT low lol.
RO is totally overhyped. Killing off all the cast is the laziest writing ever. Sure it’s harder to tell where some of the characters could’ve ended up in the Original Films but that is what a good writer gets paid for. Tarkin and Leia cgi were atrocious, way beyond uncanny valley. Not giving the blind Monk a lightsaber crystal for his staff was also a complete failure. Come on he watched over them crystals all the time he could’ve snatched at least one for his staff, how cool would that have been. Only good thing was the explanation for the ventilation shaft, but that only uplifted ANH even more.
Pathogen
Pathogen - 6/27/2025, 5:25 PM
@boiling - I liked that it had real stakes for the people on the ground. Made much more sense than everyone surviving all the time
boiling
boiling - 7/8/2025, 6:27 AM
@Pathogen - absolutely, but at least some could’ve survived. Take K2 f.e., they could’ve easily gotten away with a memory wipe there..
TK420
TK420 - 6/27/2025, 1:10 AM
No one said that.
JustAWaffle
JustAWaffle - 6/27/2025, 3:37 AM
“It's like your mom“

User Comment Image
ObserverIO
ObserverIO - 6/27/2025, 4:16 AM
Of course it's the best of the Disney era. But that's really not saying anything.

It is kinda overrated too.
Discod83
Discod83 - 6/27/2025, 4:33 AM
Am I the only person who thinks Rogue One is trash?

Everyone treats it like this gritty masterpiece that somehow "saved Star Wars", but come on. It is a soulless, confused mess that does not even line up with the film it is meant to feed into.

Let us start with the characters. We know they are all going to die. That is not the issue. The issue is that the film does absolutely nothing to make you care about any of them. Jyn Erso is a bland rebel archetype. Cassian says one vaguely interesting thing early on and then fades into background noise. K-2SO is just there for sarcastic one-liners. None of them feel fleshed out or remotely human. It is like someone filled a roster with tropes and forgot to give them personalities.

And what on earth is the tone supposed to be? One minute it is gritty war drama, then it is mystical Force nonsense, then it throws in awkward humour. It does not know what kind of story it wants to tell. The tone is completely inconsistent and never fits with the spirit or setting of A New Hope.

Speaking of which, can we talk about Darth Vader? The pun. That pun. "Be careful not to choke on your aspirations." Honestly, what were they thinking? Vader is meant to be cold, controlled, and terrifying. Not delivering cringeworthy one-liners like a Marvel villain.

And that final scene. I get it. Nerds love a lightsaber. But that was pure fan service. It is just a flashy action sequence that completely breaks the continuity. In Rogue One, he is a Force-wielding nightmare shredding rebels like a horror villain. Two minutes later in A New Hope, he is strolling through corridors, calmly interrogating people. The mythos in the original was all about implied power. Rogue One turns it into a YouTube kill montage.

And then there is Forest Whitaker as Saw Gerrera. Yes, I know he is a character from the expanded lore, from Clone Wars and Rebels and all that. But here, he just feels thrown in for the sake of familiarity. Another name fans will recognise, but with no real purpose in the story. He limps around delivering cryptic lines, then decides to stay behind and die for absolutely no reason. He could have left with them. He chose not to, for reasons that are never explained or explored. It is pointless drama with no weight.

I genuinely feel like I am losing my mind. Everyone keeps telling me how amazing this film is. But for me, it sums up exactly what is wrong with modern Star Wars. Great visuals, no emotional core, and a desperate attempt to plug holes no one asked to be filled.

PartyKiller
PartyKiller - 6/27/2025, 5:29 AM
Being Disney's "Best" Star Wars is not a huge accomplishment. Rogue One was not anywhere near to being a great, classic movie. One of the proofs of that is that it's most talked about scene was the fan service add on where Vader shows up and does some Jason Vorhees shit when he hacks up a few guys. Some fans had massive orgasms over it but it was just a hollow display. There was nothing behind the scene that gave it feeling. Vader wasn't hacking up old enemies or maybe some evil guys who wronged him before they joined the rebels.

It was a meaningless display. And it was just like the rest of the movie: Someone playing with George Lucas' toys while creating nothing new.

Even with the flaws of Star Wars Episodes 1, 2, 6, they are much greater movies than Rogue One. There are parts of each of those movies that were so important to the story and with such feeling that fans must rewatch them. There were new ideas brought to Star Wars. And good or bad, it all mattered to the overall story.

Rogue One was an effort to directly leech off A New Hope to be relevant but it is irrelevant in every way.

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder