POLL: What Is Your Take On George Lucas Tinkering With Star Wars?

POLL: What Is Your Take On George Lucas Tinkering With Star Wars?

This one has exploded over the last few days, with actors, producers etc weighing in on the subject. But how do you feel about Lucas' decision to "update" his Star Wars saga for it's Blu-ray release?

Feature Opinion
By MarkCassidy - Sep 08, 2011 01:09 PM EST
Filed Under: Star Wars


Star Wars will be released on Blu-ray for the first time next week in the US, (it's already out in the UK and Ireland) but along with the release comes more of George Lucas' infamous tweaking and tinkering as he updates and adds scenes and special effects to certain parts of his movies. This won't be the first time of course. For previous DVD releases Lucas has done the same, the most fan blasted moment so far being the "Greedo shoots first" moment from the first Star Wars. Something done to tone down Han Solo's ruthlessness in an effort to make the movie more kid friendly. Many of the other tweaks were fine -added special effects, clearing up the picture etc - were generally accepted even though they were still viewed as a bit unnecessary.



Now we have a similar situation with the Blu-ray releases. Only instead of Greedo shooting first we have an added "NOOOOOOOO" to the Darth Vader redemption scene towards the end of Return Of The Jedi. This, and to a lesser extent the fact that Obi Wan Kenobi now sounds like a cage dancer from The Blue Oyster in the scene in which he scares off the Sand People, have fans up in arms. But there are a few other things, the Ewoks getting some snazzy new CG eyelids for example, that have gone down a bit better.

So there are a few ways you can look at this. Are you against all changes or just the ones that LESSEN the quality of the originals? Or do you embrace any and all changes Lucas wants to make to his own movies? Do you not care one way or the other? Vote below.



The video features the "NOOOO" scene, but you can access the rest of the altered scenes from it too




By: TwitterButtons.com

By TwitterButtons.com



STAR WARS: Henry Cavill Rumored To Have Had Talks About Potential Role In Simon Kinberg Trilogy
Related:

STAR WARS: Henry Cavill Rumored To Have Had Talks About Potential Role In Simon Kinberg Trilogy

STAR WARS Movie - Most Likely Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy's NEW JEDI ORDER - Pulled From 2026 Release Calendar
Recommended For You:

STAR WARS Movie - Most Likely Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy's NEW JEDI ORDER - Pulled From 2026 Release Calendar

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
ColonelKilgore
ColonelKilgore - 9/8/2011, 2:02 PM
@Gaston-Sent the way of ol' yeller
CapFan79
CapFan79 - 9/8/2011, 2:11 PM
I'm actually okay with the changes. What I hate is that changes that don't impact the viewing experience are made and yet the glaring ones like crappy lightsabers etc are not fixed.
PaulRom
PaulRom - 9/8/2011, 2:13 PM
Some of them I like (such as CGI Yoda and blinking Ewoks), but the NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO scene wasn't necessary. It was perfect the way it was, no need to ruin it.
JayTopStix
JayTopStix - 9/8/2011, 2:25 PM
I love the MOvies, even the prequels there I said it.

What bothers me is not that he changes them as much, as him making a profit and myself spending money for his movies for the 30th time. 5-7 years from now we will have Ultra HD 3D remasterization, it never ends. I am sick and tired of paying for something so many times.

They should memberships and every time there is an update you get the new version for free.
Spock
Spock - 9/8/2011, 2:27 PM
Iam personally ready for a Star Wars TV series already. Que Star Trek, Star Trek The Next Generation, Star Trek Voyager, Star Trek Deep Space Nine, Star Trek Enterprise, Star Trek Phase 1, BSG, Star Gate, Atlantis: Need I say more!!!!!!
Curmudgeon
Curmudgeon - 9/8/2011, 2:33 PM
I don't hate Star Wars, but I had to vote "who cares?"

If you don't like the changes, the unedited versions were included with the 2007 DVD's.

And if you really think a guy needs to die or that you've been "raped" because he made some changes to a movie, you're taking that shit wayyy too seriously.
Ceejay
Ceejay - 9/8/2011, 2:35 PM
Adywan's Star Wars and TESB revisted versions of these put Lucas to shame, he made over 200 proper fixes to bad editing, shaky props and garbage matte removals that Lucas couldn't even be bothered with and he also colour corrected the entire movie, fixed all the lightsaber FX and added the planet Yavin in the background of the final battle where it should be as well as a proper dogfight between all the X and Y wings vs T.I.E fighters.



All this and he did it by himself while building his own house with his own money in his own free time. Lucas has billions and he just don't care enough to get it right because he knows idiots will always buy them!

headlopper
headlopper - 9/8/2011, 2:44 PM
Lucas is a creative guy, and surrounded by 100's of creative people he pays $1,000,000's of dollars in payroll to, so why won't they give us Star Wars 7?
1)The Dark side of the force is gone from the universe, but now that the Empire has fractured,it has no central leadership, so this give the regional governor's an opportunity to power grab territory using what's left of the Imperial fleet.
2) Luke's the only Jedi and is now burdened with the responsibility to revive the Jedi order-find worthy recruits.
3)Han and Leia get married. Han has to still deal with his past and Leia now has to consider her 'destiny' regarding the force.
4)The Rebellion has the difficult task of soliciting the scattered systems throughout the galaxy to re-form the Galactic Senate.
5)Boba Fett has illegitimate children who want revenge on Skywalker-maybe one discovers his armor and weaponry,asks mom,"what's this?'", and swears to avenge the death of his father he never knew.
6) Piracy and organized crime spread due to the power void left by the Empires defeat, adding to Luke's problem- maybe Lado and Chewy can handle this scenario. Etc.,Etc.
So you see, the Star Wars universe is RIPE for new adventures, new stories, new worlds, new drama, new wars, new characters for a new generation.
NO EXCUSES LUCAS!!! GIVE US A NEW STAR WARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 9/8/2011, 2:47 PM
I think the "his movies he can do what he likes" attitude is kinda ridiculous to be honest. So you wouldn't mind if Vader gave The Emperor a wet willy and slapped him on the arse before throwing him then? Small alterations and updating special effects is ok because it doesn't alter the actual dramatic fabric of the story. Having Vader shout a big cheesy, cliched "NOOOOO" in that scene which was made all the more powerful by the fact that he was SILENT in the first place is just another example of Lucas's ineptitude as a director and a story teller. It;s moronic. And it doesn't matter that I can still go back and watch the originals, I was going to buy em on Blu-ray and now I'm not. It's not a matter of not HAVING to watch them, I WANTED to. It;s good film making vs bad film making and that's all there is to it.
HelaGood
HelaGood - 9/8/2011, 2:55 PM
ENOUGH ALREADY!!!!!!!
George Lucas, keep your damn hands off of our movies!!!

Ceejay
Ceejay - 9/8/2011, 2:57 PM
sackboy1991
sackboy1991 - 9/8/2011, 2:59 PM
theres no need for all these edits and changes. what made the original so great, was what they did, with what they had a the time. the creativity they had, with what the technology of its time would allow them to do. the original copies of the films, imo are the superior cuts. i dont mind the mild updates, but changing classic scenes, such as the "nooo" there is no need for it. also his ideas and scripts, etc, but to be honest the director has the say on the scene. how it plays. he werent happy with how they are, then lucas, should have said something when the films were BEING MADE, not 20 years in the future. the way he keeps on making "minor changes" then in the end, will anything of these films be in the final product!!!!!! lucas just needs to stop hanging on to the past, and come up with something new. and write a better indianna jones film. ok rant over!
headlopper
headlopper - 9/8/2011, 2:59 PM
This question drives me crazy. Yeah ,it's George's baby but I don't care. Star Wars belongs to ALL of us now! We don't need tweeking, we need Star Wars #7 "Rise of the new Republic". What's this guy trying to do? Why don't we just take down the Mona Lisa or a Rembrandt and alter it to death! I'm talking about Star Wars 4 & 5 . They're perfect the way they were at first,I don't care about any others. As far as I'm concerned, Return of the Jedi needs to be re-booted. The emperor said to Luke that a legion of his best troops were on the moon. How can little teddy bears with stone age weapons defeat Storm Troopers with At-At's and laser weapons. It's preposterous!
Spock
Spock - 9/8/2011, 2:59 PM
CAN WE GET SOMETHING NEW THAT WE HAVEN'T SEEN ON THE BIG OR SMALL SCREEN. Lets get passed Vader & Luc all ready!!!!!!!!!
GUNSMITH
GUNSMITH - 9/8/2011, 2:59 PM
THE GUY MADE STAR WARS, LET HIM CHANGE IT UP. IF YOUR A STAR WARS PURIST, THEN WATCH THE OLD ONES..IF YOU WANT NEW STUFF WATCH THE NEW STUFF..ALL IN ALL- STAR WAS IN GENERAL IN ALL ITS FORMS IS OUT THERE, ITS AVAILABLE, CHOOSE WHAT YOU LIKE AND STICK WITH IT.
TheOverlord
TheOverlord - 9/8/2011, 3:00 PM
@Ceejay Wow - Adywan's edit is fascinating.

Lucas is a hack.
At the end of the day, I don't care what he does to the films, as ong as I get to see the originals.

Oh, and let Episode VII be made - by someone else!
DJJX
DJJX - 9/8/2011, 3:01 PM
I've actually seen it (not just small part but the whole sequence) and I actually don't mind it. It's not as distracting or as horrible as taking it only for that one small part.

I honestly don't like messing with original work but this minor change will not stop me from buying the BluRays of these classic movies.
Spock
Spock - 9/8/2011, 3:09 PM
CAN WE GET SOMETHING NEW THAT WE HAVEN'T SEEN ON THE BIG OR SMALL SCREEN. Lets get passed Vader & Luc all ready!!!!!!!!!
marvel72
marvel72 - 9/8/2011, 3:10 PM
i wish he'd just leave the original trilogy alone he can do what he likes to the prequels.

here's a challenge for lucas

the prequels are shite compared to the original trilogy,lets see lucas make that crap better.
headlopper
headlopper - 9/8/2011, 3:12 PM
^^^HAHAHAHA! Right on brother!
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 9/8/2011, 3:13 PM
The thing I find funniest is that the most changes made were to the originals. haha, this clown re-watched those abominations of prequels and went "Nah, they are fine as they are, just CGI Yoda". I'm telling you, delusional.
95
95 - 9/8/2011, 3:16 PM
DO WHATEVER YOU WANT GEORGE, YOU JUST WON'T GET MY MONEY, ANYMORE!!!

Spock
Spock - 9/8/2011, 3:22 PM
CAN WE GET SOMETHING NEW THAT WE HAVEN'T SEEN ON THE BIG OR SMALL SCREEN. Lets get passed Vader & Luc all ready!
headlopper
headlopper - 9/8/2011, 3:29 PM
@rormachine- Whoooo!!! You're swinging for the fences now! Very well said sir, I salute you! Looks like we gotta consensus here!
Lucas, make Star Wars # 7. No wait-ta-minute, DONT make Star Wars #7 , but let:
1.Jackson
2.Del Toro
3.Blomkamp
4.Nolan
5. Hell, I'll even take Snyder.
Somebody with passion and artistic vision.
RockNRollCC
RockNRollCC - 9/8/2011, 3:33 PM
God, this is such a hard poll...

Some changes im fine with (CGI yoda in Ep1) but some of the other things are so stupid (ewok CGI eyelids, Darth's new NOOOOOS, the krayt dragon call).

Lucas, leave the movies alone. They're fine the way they are. I dont care if they're your creations (as others ^^^ are giving that excuse), if you're changing something that is so unnecessary, WHATS THE POINT?
comicb00kguy
comicb00kguy - 9/8/2011, 3:43 PM
I have nothing against tweaking the effects, much like what was done with the original Star Trek series, but I don't like the idea of changing the story in any way. Changing who shoots first or adding an unneeded NOOOOOOOO!!! is unnecessary and cheapens the movie.

headlopper
headlopper - 9/8/2011, 3:45 PM
@marvelweiner- Earlier this year I found the originals on DVD at Target. Don't know what country you live in, so it's like a middle class dept. store. The purchase also had the 90's re-touch versions included.
I killed my VHS versions from watching them a billion times.
comicb00kguy
comicb00kguy - 9/8/2011, 3:47 PM
MarvelWeiner: You want to find the originals? Find the 2006 DVD releases (they're on Amazon), which include both the newer version and the original version as seen in theaters. Search for 'star wars original'. If you can't afford them, hit the thrift stores and find pre-1998 VHS copies of the movies. Those will all be original. I know, you're stuck with sucky full-screen, but it's a low-cost alternative if you want to see the originals. You can also find those on Amazon.

GuyF1105
GuyF1105 - 9/8/2011, 3:48 PM
If he would make another DECENT Star Wars Movie....I would forgive him for his tinkering...
1 2
View Recorder