Nostalgia Critic Old vs New: Spider-Man

The Nostalgia Critic decides who is the better web-singler: The Spider-Man or The Amazing Spider-Man? Also, don't forget to post your opinions on who your favourite webhead is below!

Review Opinion

By spodermen - May 20, 2014 08:05 PM EST

Filed Under: Spider-Man

Source: youtube.com

My first post here so please...be gentle.

Nostalgia Critic compares which Spider-Man is better. Sure the video is half an hour long but it's because he goes into detail. Personally I believe Nostalgia Critic is spot on and I do have to take his side. But I'd still like to know what you all think and why.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypSzNZhInTk

So, who do you think is better? Old or new Spidey?

About The Author:

spodermen
Member Since 5/2/2014

“[Don’t] Use Me Or My Work To Take Sides”: Miles Morales Co-Creator Clarifies Comments About Media Royalties

Related:

“[Don’t] Use Me Or My Work To Take Sides”: Miles Morales Co-Creator Clarifies Comments About Media Royalties

STRANGER THINGS Star Calls Miles Morales’ Spider-Man A “Dream Role”

Recommended For You:

STRANGER THINGS Star Calls Miles Morales’ Spider-Man A “Dream Role”

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Show Comments

10 Comments

Related Headlines

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

RUMOR: SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Will See Peter Parker And The Punisher Battle The [SPOILER] Version Of Hulk

JoshWilding

15 hours ago

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

THE FANTASTIC FOUR Composer Michael Giacchino Will Return To Score SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY

JoshWilding

1 day ago

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Rumored To Make This Huge Change To Mark Ruffalo's Savage Hulk - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

1 day ago

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Trailer - Speculation Mounts As Sony Shares "All We Want For Christmas" Post

MarkCassidy

1 day ago

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Rumored To Feature Daredevil Villain [SPOILER] - But What About Matt Murdock?

JoshWilding

1 day ago

THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN: Josh Hutcherson Reflects On Heartbreaking Experience Of Losing Peter Parker Role

The Amazing Spider-Man

THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN: Josh Hutcherson Reflects On "Heartbreaking" Experience Of Losing Peter Parker Role

JoshWilding

4 days ago

RUMOR: Multiple AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Trailers Now Described As “Boring”

THE BATMAN 2: Scarlett Johansson's Role Revealed As Matt Reeves Looks To Cast Harvey And Christopher Dent

DEADPOOL’s Ryan Reynolds Addresses Quentin Tarantino Controversy With Ad Starring SCOOBY-DOO’s Matthew Lillard

AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY's Four Trailers Rumored To Feature [SPOILER]; Will Begin With Anti-Piracy PSA

MAN OF TOMORROW: This GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY Star Is Reportedly The Frontrunner For Brainiac

Latest Headlines

RUMOR: Charlie Cox's Daredevil Will Finally Return To The Big Screen In AVENGERS: SECRET WARS

Avengers: Doomsday

RUMOR: Charlie Cox's Daredevil Will Finally Return To The Big Screen In AVENGERS: SECRET WARS

JoshWilding

11 mins ago

THE PRINCESS BRIDE Director Rob Reiner And His Wife, Michele, Found Dead In Apparent Homicide

Other

THE PRINCESS BRIDE Director Rob Reiner And His Wife, Michele, Found Dead In Apparent Homicide

JoshWilding

39 mins ago

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Finale Ending Explained: Another Pennywise Twist As Stage Is Set For Season 2 - SPOILERS

Horror

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Finale Ending Explained: Another Pennywise Twist As Stage Is Set For Season 2 - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

3 hours ago

DEADPOOL’s Ryan Reynolds Addresses Quentin Tarantino Controversy With Ad Starring SCOOBY-DOO’s Matthew Lillard

Deadpool & Wolverine

DEADPOOL’s Ryan Reynolds Addresses Quentin Tarantino Controversy With Ad Starring SCOOBY-DOO’s Matthew Lillard

DanielKlissmman

13 hours ago

STREET FIGHTER Teaser Trailer Hides An Unannounced World Warrior Right Under Your Nose

Street Fighter

STREET FIGHTER Teaser Trailer Hides An Unannounced World Warrior Right Under Your Nose

MarkJulian

13 hours ago

The Last PLUS ULTRA! Deku, All Might And More Bid Farewell As MY HERO ACADEMIA Anime Concludes

Anime & Manga

The Last PLUS ULTRA! Deku, All Might And More Bid Farewell As MY HERO ACADEMIA Anime Concludes

MarkJulian

14 hours ago

Hot Headlines

70 comments

THE BATMAN 2: Scarlett Johansson's Role Revealed As Matt Reeves Looks To Cast Harvey And Christopher Dent

JoshWilding

22 hours ago EST

59 comments

MAN OF TOMORROW: This GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY Star Is Reportedly The Frontrunner For Brainiac

MarkJulian

17 hours ago EST

53 comments

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Says NONE Of The Rumored Names Are Correct For Brainiac, Including Dave Bautista

JoshWilding

14 hours ago EST

45 comments

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Rumored To Make This Huge Change To Mark Ruffalo's Savage Hulk - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

38 comments

RUMOR: Multiple AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Trailers Now Described As “Boring”

DanielKlissmman

19 hours ago EST

PLURIBUS Overtakes SEVERANCE To Become Apple TV's Most-Watched Television Show

PLURIBUS Overtakes SEVERANCE To Become Apple TV's Most-Watched Television Show

MarkJulian

1 day ago

STREET FIGHTER Trailer And Posters Spotlight Iconic Characters Such As Ryu, Blanka, Chun-Li & M. Bison

STREET FIGHTER Trailer And Posters Spotlight Iconic Characters Such As Ryu, Blanka, Chun-Li & M. Bison

MarkCassidy

1 day ago

STAR WARS: STARFIGHTER Actor Matt Smith Reveals Daft New Look For Movie's Mysterious Villain

STAR WARS: STARFIGHTER Actor Matt Smith Reveals "Daft" New Look For Movie's Mysterious Villain

JoshWilding

1 day ago

FALLOUT’s Inaccurate AI Recap For Season 1 Leads To Amazon Taking It Down From Prime Video

FALLOUT’s Inaccurate AI Recap For Season 1 Leads To Amazon Taking It Down From Prime Video

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago

THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU Trailer Description Leaks Online Ahead Of Expected Release Next Week

THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU Trailer Description Leaks Online Ahead Of Expected Release Next Week

JoshWilding

2 days ago

STAR WARS: GALACTIC RACER Brings The Need For Speed To The Outer Rim

STAR WARS: GALACTIC RACER Brings The Need For Speed To The Outer Rim

MattThomas

2 days ago

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

New WORLD TRIGGER TV Anime Confirmed To Be A Traditional Reboot

New WORLD TRIGGER TV Anime Confirmed To Be A Traditional Reboot

MarkJulian

15 hours ago

Major MY HERO ACADEMIA Announcement Coming At Jump Festa 2026 Next Week

Major MY HERO ACADEMIA Announcement Coming At Jump Festa 2026 Next Week

MattThomas

16 hours ago

New Trailer For SENTENCED TO BE A HERO Released Ahead Of January Premiere

New Trailer For SENTENCED TO BE A HERO Released Ahead Of January Premiere

MarkJulian

16 hours ago

What's Next For MY HERO ACADEMIA Now That The Anime Is Over?

What's Next For MY HERO ACADEMIA Now That The Anime Is Over?

MattThomas

17 hours ago

The My HERO ACADEMIA Anime Is Over: Deku, All Might And More Say Goodbye

The My HERO ACADEMIA Anime Is Over: Deku, All Might And More Say Goodbye

MarkJulian

17 hours ago

Gainax Founder Addresses Studio's Closure, Lack Of Respect, And The Profound Sadness Of It All

Gainax Founder Addresses Studio's Closure, Lack Of Respect, And The "Profound Sadness" Of It All

GabeReisinger

1 day ago

More Anime & Manga ►

STAR WARS: FATE OF THE OLD REPUBLIC Director Addresses 2030 Release Rumors

STAR WARS: FATE OF THE OLD REPUBLIC Director Addresses 2030 Release Rumors

MattThomas

6 hours ago

The STREET FIGHTER Teaser Trailer Is Hiding Another World Warrior In Plain Sight

The STREET FIGHTER Teaser Trailer Is Hiding Another World Warrior In Plain Sight

MarkJulian

14 hours ago

WB Games Is Something Of An Afterthought In Netflix's Acquisition Strategy, Says Co-CEO Peters

WB Games Is Something Of An Afterthought In Netflix's Acquisition Strategy, Says Co-CEO Peters

MarkJulian

1 day ago

STAR WARS: FATE OF THE OLD REPUBLIC May Not Release Until 2030, According To Journalist Estimates

STAR WARS: FATE OF THE OLD REPUBLIC May Not Release Until 2030, According To Journalist Estimates

MattThomas

1 day ago

Is STAR WARS: FATE OF THE OLD REPUBLIC A Sequel To KOTOR?

Is STAR WARS: FATE OF THE OLD REPUBLIC A Sequel To KOTOR?

MattThomas

2 days ago

Deadpool Slices His Way Into MARVEL RIVALS This January With Season 6

Deadpool Slices His Way Into MARVEL RIVALS This January With Season 6

MattThomas

2 days ago

More Video Games ►

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Season Finale Spoilers: Major Cameos, Another Big Pennywise Twist, And Season 2 Tease

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Season Finale Spoilers: Major Cameos, Another Big Pennywise Twist, And Season 2 Tease

JoshWilding

6 hours ago

CRYSTAL LAKE Showrunner Compares FRIDAY THE 13TH Prequel Series To A Psychological Thriller

CRYSTAL LAKE Showrunner Compares FRIDAY THE 13TH Prequel Series To A "Psychological Thriller"

JoshWilding

3 days ago

28 YEARS LATER: THE BONE TEMPLE Sequel Officially Confirmed With Cillian Murphy Returning

28 YEARS LATER: THE BONE TEMPLE Sequel Officially Confirmed With Cillian Murphy Returning

RohanPatel

4 days ago

28 YEARS LATER: THE BONE TEMPLE Reactions Hail Sequel As One Of The Best Horror Movies Of The Last Decade

28 YEARS LATER: THE BONE TEMPLE Reactions Hail Sequel As "One Of The Best Horror Movies Of The Last Decade"

MarkCassidy

5 days ago

28 YEARS LATER: THE BONE TEMPLE Featurette Reveals New Story Details And Footage From Nia DaCosta's Sequel

28 YEARS LATER: THE BONE TEMPLE Featurette Reveals New Story Details And Footage From Nia DaCosta's Sequel

JoshWilding

5 days ago

SCREAM Star Skeet Ulrich Confirms That Sam Would Have Become Ghostface Prior To Melissa Barrera's Firing

SCREAM Star Skeet Ulrich Confirms That Sam Would Have Become Ghostface Prior To Melissa Barrera's Firing

MarkCassidy

6 days ago

More Horror ►

ZOOTOPIA 2 Co-Director Jared Bush Celebrates Billion Dollar Milestone With Fan Q&A

ZOOTOPIA 2 Co-Director Jared Bush Celebrates Billion Dollar Milestone With Fan Q&A

MarkJulian

1 day ago

Radio Flyer Studios' MAX & MAPLE: THE CAN-DO KIDS Wants To Fill The Narrative Kids Content Void

Radio Flyer Studios' MAX & MAPLE: THE CAN-DO KIDS Wants To Fill The Narrative Kids Content Void

GabeReisinger

1 day ago

ZOOTOPIA 2 Officially Passes $1 Billion At The Global Box Office After Just 17 Days In Theaters

ZOOTOPIA 2 Officially Passes $1 Billion At The Global Box Office After Just 17 Days In Theaters

MarkCassidy

2 days ago

Mickey Mouse Will Be Allowed In AI Videos As Disney And OpenAI Strike Huge Licensing Agreement

Mickey Mouse Will Be Allowed In AI Videos As Disney And OpenAI Strike Huge Licensing Agreement

GabeReisinger

3 days ago

AVATAR: THE LAST AIRBENDER Season 2 Trailer Puts The Spotlight On Toph's Highly Anticipated Debut

JoshWilding

4 days ago

MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE: It Sounds Like The First Trailer Could Arrive Sooner Than Expected

MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE: It Sounds Like The First Trailer Could Arrive Sooner Than Expected

JoshWilding

6 days ago

More Cartoons & Animated ►

Despair, Cannibals, And Martial Arts: LONE SAMURAI Is Now Available On Digital

Despair, Cannibals, And Martial Arts: LONE SAMURAI Is Now Available On Digital

MarkJulian

1 day ago

Tom Cruise Reportedly “Grew Unhappy” With Paramount CEO David Ellison Over MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE

Tom Cruise Reportedly “Grew Unhappy” With Paramount CEO David Ellison Over MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE

DanielKlissmman

Dec 05, 2025 01:12 PM

First SPARTACUS: HOUSE OF ASHUR Reviews Illuminate High Quality Action And Storytelling

First SPARTACUS: HOUSE OF ASHUR Reviews Illuminate High Quality Action And Storytelling

MarkJulian

Dec 04, 2025 07:12 AM

RUSH HOUR 4 Is Reportedly Considered A Bad Idea By Many In Hollywood

RUSH HOUR 4 Is Reportedly Considered A Bad Idea By Many In Hollywood

DanielKlissmman

Dec 03, 2025 06:12 PM

SHELTER: Jason Statham Is An Elite, Former Assassin On The Run

SHELTER: Jason Statham Is An Elite, Former Assassin On The Run

MarkJulian

Dec 03, 2025 08:12 AM

JAMES BOND: Callum Turner Rumored To Be Denis Villeneuve's Top Choice To Play New 007

JAMES BOND: Callum Turner Rumored To Be Denis Villeneuve's "Top Choice" To Play New 007

MarkCassidy

Dec 02, 2025 10:12 AM

More Action Movies & TV ►

John Cena Retires: How SATURDAY NIGHT'S MAIN EVENT Match Ended Explained As Triple H Addresses Fan Backlash

John Cena Retires: How SATURDAY NIGHT'S MAIN EVENT Match Ended Explained As Triple H Addresses Fan Backlash

JoshWilding

22 hours ago

John Cena's Final Match WWE Saturday Night's Main Event Results: John Cena vs. Gunther, NXT Showcases & More

John Cena's Final Match WWE Saturday Night's Main Event Results: John Cena vs. Gunther, NXT Showcases & More

AnthonyMango

1 day ago

Brock Lesnar Likely To Retire From WWE In 2026 - And Two More Top Superstars May End Up Joining Him

Brock Lesnar Likely To Retire From WWE In 2026 - And Two More Top Superstars May End Up Joining Him

JoshWilding

1 day ago

WWE SmackDown Results: December 12, 2025 - Terror Twins vs Aleister Black & Zelina & More

WWE SmackDown Results: December 12, 2025 - Terror Twins vs Aleister Black & Zelina & More

AnthonyMango

2 days ago

WWE SATURDAY NIGHT'S MAIN EVENT Confirmed Match Card And How To Watch John Cena's Retirement Match

WWE SATURDAY NIGHT'S MAIN EVENT Confirmed Match Card And How To Watch John Cena's Retirement Match

JoshWilding

2 days ago

STREET FIGHTER Trailer And Posters Reveal First Look At Cody Rhodes And Roman Reigns As Guile And Akuma

STREET FIGHTER Trailer And Posters Reveal First Look At Cody Rhodes And Roman Reigns As Guile And Akuma

JoshWilding

2 days ago

More Pro Wrestling ►

RUMOR: Multiple AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Trailers Now Described As “Boring”

THE BATMAN 2: Scarlett Johansson's Role Revealed As Matt Reeves Looks To Cast Harvey And Christopher Dent

DEADPOOL’s Ryan Reynolds Addresses Quentin Tarantino Controversy With Ad Starring SCOOBY-DOO’s Matthew Lillard

AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY's Four Trailers Rumored To Feature [SPOILER]; Will Begin With Anti-Piracy PSA

MAN OF TOMORROW: This GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY Star Is Reportedly The Frontrunner For Brainiac

70 comments

THE BATMAN 2: Scarlett Johansson's Role Revealed As Matt Reeves Looks To Cast Harvey And Christopher Dent

JoshWilding

22 hours ago EST

59 comments

MAN OF TOMORROW: This GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY Star Is Reportedly The Frontrunner For Brainiac

MarkJulian

17 hours ago EST

53 comments

MAN OF TOMORROW: James Gunn Says NONE Of The Rumored Names Are Correct For Brainiac, Including Dave Bautista

JoshWilding

14 hours ago EST

45 comments

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Rumored To Make This Huge Change To Mark Ruffalo's Savage Hulk - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

1 day ago EST

38 comments

RUMOR: Multiple AVENGERS: DOOMSDAY Trailers Now Described As “Boring”

DanielKlissmman

19 hours ago EST

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Home | Index | Site Map | About | Terms Of Service | Community Guidelines | Privacy | Copyright | Trademark Contact | Advertise

© 2025 ComicBookMovie.com®. All Rights Reserved.

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site, ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions. Content herein has been submitted by users who have agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. ComicBookMovie.com and Best Little Sites LLC are not liable for inaccuracies, errors, or omissions.

Learn more about our copyright and trademark policies

Contact Us for removal of copyrighted images, trademarks, or other issues.

View Recorder