Nostalgia Critic Old vs New: Spider-Man

The Nostalgia Critic decides who is the better web-singler: The Spider-Man or The Amazing Spider-Man? Also, don't forget to post your opinions on who your favourite webhead is below!

Review Opinion

By spodermen - May 20, 2014 08:05 PM EST

Filed Under: Spider-Man

Source: youtube.com

My first post here so please...be gentle.

Nostalgia Critic compares which Spider-Man is better. Sure the video is half an hour long but it's because he goes into detail. Personally I believe Nostalgia Critic is spot on and I do have to take his side. But I'd still like to know what you all think and why.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypSzNZhInTk

So, who do you think is better? Old or new Spidey?

About The Author:

spodermen
Member Since 5/2/2014

STRANGER THINGS Star Calls Miles Morales’ Spider-Man A “Dream Role”

Related:

STRANGER THINGS Star Calls Miles Morales’ Spider-Man A “Dream Role”

GOD OF WAR: Frontrunners For Baldur And Thor In The Upcoming Prime Video Series Have Been Revealed

Recommended For You:

GOD OF WAR: Frontrunners For Baldur And Thor In The Upcoming Prime Video Series Have Been Revealed

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Show Comments

10 Comments

Related Headlines

OI! OI! SPIDER-PUNK Spin-Off Gets Major Update From Daniel Kaluuya

Into The Spider-Verse

"OI! OI!" SPIDER-PUNK Spin-Off Gets Major Update From Daniel Kaluuya

MarkJulian

9 hours ago

Miles Morales Co-Creator Reveals She Hasn’t Received Any Money For The Character’s Billion-Dollar Franchise

Into The Spider-Verse

Miles Morales Co-Creator Reveals She Hasn’t Received Any Money For The Character’s Billion-Dollar Franchise

DanielKlissmman

10 hours ago

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Crew Member Confirms Production Has Now Wrapped In Since-Deleted Post

MarkCassidy

13 hours ago

MADAME WEB Star Sydney Sweeney Addresses Controversy Surrounding Recent Jeans Advert: I'm Against Hate

Madame Web

MADAME WEB Star Sydney Sweeney Addresses Controversy Surrounding Recent Jeans Advert: "I'm Against Hate"

MarkCassidy

1 day ago

Spider-Man: Brand New Day

SPIDER-MAN: BRAND NEW DAY Rumored To Have Finally Wrapped Filming - But There Might Still Be More On The Way

DanielKlissmman

2 days ago

SPIDER-NOIR Producer On Whether Black & White Or Color Is The Main Version; CCXP Scene Description Revealed

Spider-Noir

SPIDER-NOIR Producer On Whether Black & White Or Color Is The "Main" Version; CCXP Scene Description Revealed

JoshWilding

2 days ago

SUPERGIRL Official Trailer Teaser Reveals The Maiden Of Might Like You've Never Seen Her Before!

James Gunn And Peter Safran Address Warner Bros.’ Sale To Netflix, As Their Contracts Get Extended Until 2027

“It Hurts”: DAREDEVIL: BORN AGAIN Actor Responds To Quentin Tarantino Saying He Doesn’t Like Him

Resurfaced BTS Images From THE AVENGERS Show Much Better Design For Captain America’s Most Controversial Suit

Zack Snyder Says He Treated DC's Characters With "Reverence And Respect" While Sharing New Superman Photo

Latest Headlines

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Episode 7 Recap: Pennywise's Twisted Past Is Revealed As The Death Toll Rises - SPOILERS

Horror

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Episode 7 Recap: Pennywise's Twisted Past Is Revealed As The Death Toll Rises - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

2 hours ago

Resurfaced BTS Images From THE AVENGERS Show Much Better Design For Captain America’s Most Controversial Suit

Avengers

Resurfaced BTS Images From THE AVENGERS Show Much Better Design For Captain America’s Most Controversial Suit

DanielKlissmman

7 hours ago

SUPERMAN Star David Corenswet Reveals The One Note From James Gunn He Refused To Budge On: I Was Like, 'No!'

Superman

SUPERMAN Star David Corenswet Reveals The One Note From James Gunn He Refused To Budge On: "I Was Like, 'No!'"

MarkCassidy

8 hours ago

FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY's 2 Claims The Domestic Box Office Crown But ZOOTOPIA 2 Is The Real Monster

Disney

FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY's 2 Claims The Domestic Box Office Crown But ZOOTOPIA 2 Is The Real Monster

MarkJulian

8 hours ago

SUPERGIRL Official Trailer Teaser Reveals The Maiden Of Might Like You've Never Seen Her Before!

Supergirl

SUPERGIRL Official Trailer Teaser Reveals The Maiden Of Might Like You've Never Seen Her Before!

JoshWilding

8 hours ago

OI! OI! SPIDER-PUNK Spin-Off Gets Major Update From Daniel Kaluuya

Into The Spider-Verse

"OI! OI!" SPIDER-PUNK Spin-Off Gets Major Update From Daniel Kaluuya

MarkJulian

9 hours ago

Hot Headlines

115 comments

SUPERGIRL Official Trailer Teaser Reveals The Maiden Of Might Like You've Never Seen Her Before!

JoshWilding

8 hours ago EST

96 comments

MADAME WEB Star Sydney Sweeney Addresses Controversy Surrounding Recent Jeans Advert: "I'm Against Hate"

MarkCassidy

1 day ago EST

73 comments

Zack Snyder Says He Treated DC's Characters With "Reverence And Respect" While Sharing New Superman Photo

JoshWilding

13 hours ago EST

63 comments

How Exactly SUPERMAN Made Massive $100 Million Profit For Warner Bros. Discovery Has Finally Been Revealed

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago EST

57 comments

James Gunn And Peter Safran Address Warner Bros.’ Sale To Netflix, As Their Contracts Get Extended Until 2027

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago EST

The Disney+ POWER RANGERS Series Is Real! Showrunners Confirm Development Status

The Disney+ POWER RANGERS Series Is Real! Showrunners Confirm Development Status

MarkJulian

10 hours ago

STAR WARS: 10 Undeniable Reasons George Lucas' Prequels Are BETTER Than Disney's Underwhelming Sequel Trilogy

STAR WARS: 10 Undeniable Reasons George Lucas' Prequels Are BETTER Than Disney's Underwhelming Sequel Trilogy

JoshWilding

18 hours ago

Rumor Sparks Hope For STAR WARS JEDI 3 Or KNIGHTS OF THE OLD REPUBLIC REMAKE Game Reveal Next Week

Rumor Sparks Hope For STAR WARS JEDI 3 Or KNIGHTS OF THE OLD REPUBLIC REMAKE Game Reveal Next Week

MattThomas

1 day ago

THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU Leaked Synopsis Reveal Some Surprising New Story Details, Including Grogu's Future

THE MANDALORIAN AND GROGU Leaked Synopsis Reveal Some Surprising New Story Details, Including Grogu's Future

JoshWilding

2 days ago

STRANGER THINGS Season 5, Volume 2 First Official Look Takes Us Back To Hawkins For Final Battle With Vecna

STRANGER THINGS Season 5, Volume 2 First Official Look Takes Us Back To Hawkins For Final Battle With Vecna

MarkCassidy

2 days ago

New MEN IN BLACK Movie From BAD BOYS FOR LIFE Writer In The Works; Will Smith Eyed To Return

New MEN IN BLACK Movie From BAD BOYS FOR LIFE Writer In The Works; Will Smith Eyed To Return

MarkCassidy

3 days ago

More Sci-Fi & Fantasy ►

MY HERO ACADEMIA: VIGILANTES Season 2 Premiere Date Announced With New Trailer And Key Visual

MY HERO ACADEMIA: VIGILANTES Season 2 Premiere Date Announced With New Trailer And Key Visual

MattThomas

14 hours ago

Crunchyroll To End Ad-Supported Streaming At The End of 2025

Crunchyroll To End Ad-Supported Streaming At The End of 2025

MattThomas

15 hours ago

It's Morphin' Time! PERCY JACKSON Showrunners Verify Existence Of Disney's POWER RANGERS Reboot Project

It's Morphin' Time! PERCY JACKSON Showrunners Verify Existence Of Disney's POWER RANGERS Reboot Project

MarkJulian

2 days ago

Amazon Removes NO GAME NO LIFE, VINLAND SAGA & BANANA FISH AI Dubs After Intense Industry Anger

Amazon Removes NO GAME NO LIFE, VINLAND SAGA & BANANA FISH AI Dubs After Intense Industry Anger

GBest

4 days ago

The Author Of SWORD ART ONLINE Has A New Series That Is Becoming An Anime

The Author Of SWORD ART ONLINE Has A New Series That Is Becoming An Anime

GBest

4 days ago

Netflix Teases At New ONE PIECE Remake Update With An Announcement Likely Coming Soon

Netflix Teases At New ONE PIECE Remake Update With An Announcement Likely Coming Soon

GBest

4 days ago

More Anime & Manga ►

Amazon Prime Members Get 14 Free PC Games During December, Starting With LEGO 2K DRIVE

Amazon Prime Members Get 14 Free PC Games During December, Starting With LEGO 2K DRIVE

MattThomas

1 day ago

GOD OF WAR: The Actors Being Eyed To Play Baldur And Thor In Prime Video TV Series Have Been Revealed

GOD OF WAR: The Actors Being Eyed To Play Baldur And Thor In Prime Video TV Series Have Been Revealed

JoshWilding

1 day ago

New STAR WARS Game, Possibly JEDI 3 Or KOTOR Remake, May Get Announced This Month

New STAR WARS Game, Possibly JEDI 3 Or KOTOR Remake, May Get Announced This Month

MattThomas

2 days ago

The NEX PLAYGROUND Is One Of This Holiday Season’s Hottest Gaming Systems

The NEX PLAYGROUND Is One Of This Holiday Season’s Hottest Gaming Systems

MattThomas

2 days ago

NINTENDO SWITCH 2 + MARIO KART Bundle Drops To All-Time Low Price After Amazon Discount

NINTENDO SWITCH 2 + MARIO KART Bundle Drops To All-Time Low Price After Amazon Discount

MattThomas

3 days ago

THE WITCHER Star Freya Allan Talks Liam Hemsworth Backlash And Why She Nearly Left The Netflix Series

THE WITCHER Star Freya Allan Talks Liam Hemsworth Backlash And Why She Nearly Left The Netflix Series

JoshWilding

3 days ago

More Video Games ►

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Episode 7 Reveals More Of Pennywise's Twisted Origin And Sets Up Bloody Finale - SPOILERS

IT: WELCOME TO DERRY Episode 7 Reveals More Of Pennywise's Twisted Origin And Sets Up Bloody Finale - SPOILERS

JoshWilding

4 hours ago

“I Don’t Give A Sh–t”: SCREAM Star Responds To Quentin Tarantino Saying He Doesn’t “Care For” Him

“I Don’t Give A Sh–t”: SCREAM Star Responds To Quentin Tarantino Saying He Doesn’t “Care For” Him

DanielKlissmman

8 hours ago

FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'S 2 Reviews Land Along With Truly Terrifying Rotten Tomatoes Score

FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'S 2 Reviews Land Along With Truly Terrifying Rotten Tomatoes Score

MarkCassidy

3 days ago

ANACONDA Character Posters And New Teaser Introduce Meta Reboot's Potential Snake Fodder

ANACONDA Character Posters And New Teaser Introduce Meta Reboot's Potential Snake Fodder

MarkCassidy

3 days ago

New PARANORMAL ACTIVITY Film On The Way With THE CONJURING Director On Board As Producer

New PARANORMAL ACTIVITY Film On The Way With THE CONJURING Director On Board As Producer

DanielKlissmman

4 days ago

STRANGER THINGS: THE FINALE Lengthy Runtime Confirmed As VOL. 1 Scores Netflix’s Second Biggest Premiere

STRANGER THINGS: THE FINALE Lengthy Runtime Confirmed As VOL. 1 Scores Netflix’s Second Biggest Premiere

MarkCassidy

4 days ago

More Horror ►

ZOOTOPIA 2's Box Office Run Is Still Burning Hot As It Closes In On $1 Billion

ZOOTOPIA 2's Box Office Run Is Still Burning Hot As It Closes In On $1 Billion

MarkJulian

10 hours ago

SPIDER-PUNK Animated Movie Gets Major Update From Daniel Kaluuya

SPIDER-PUNK Animated Movie Gets Major Update From Daniel Kaluuya

MarkJulian

10 hours ago

KPOP DEMON HUNTERS Squishmallows Available For Pre-Order; More Jazwares Plush Arrives In 2026

KPOP DEMON HUNTERS Squishmallows Available For Pre-Order; More Jazwares Plush Arrives In 2026

MattThomas

13 hours ago

FROSTY THE SNOWMAN: Where To Watch The Animated Christmas Classic In 2025

FROSTY THE SNOWMAN: Where To Watch The Animated Christmas Classic In 2025

MattThomas

1 day ago

KPOP DEMON HUNTERS X VANS Sneaker Collection Launches Today: Where To Buy

KPOP DEMON HUNTERS X VANS Sneaker Collection Launches Today: Where To Buy

MattThomas

2 days ago

TANGLED Live-Action Remake Rumored To Be Eyeing Sadie Sink, Mckenna Grace & More To Play Rapunzel

TANGLED Live-Action Remake Rumored To Be Eyeing Sadie Sink, Mckenna Grace & More To Play Rapunzel

MarkCassidy

3 days ago

More Cartoons & Animated ►

Tom Cruise Reportedly “Grew Unhappy” With Paramount CEO David Ellison Over MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE

Tom Cruise Reportedly “Grew Unhappy” With Paramount CEO David Ellison Over MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE

DanielKlissmman

2 days ago

First SPARTACUS: HOUSE OF ASHUR Reviews Illuminate High Quality Action And Storytelling

First SPARTACUS: HOUSE OF ASHUR Reviews Illuminate High Quality Action And Storytelling

MarkJulian

3 days ago

RUSH HOUR 4 Is Reportedly Considered A Bad Idea By Many In Hollywood

RUSH HOUR 4 Is Reportedly Considered A Bad Idea By Many In Hollywood

DanielKlissmman

4 days ago

SHELTER: Jason Statham Is An Elite, Former Assassin On The Run

SHELTER: Jason Statham Is An Elite, Former Assassin On The Run

MarkJulian

4 days ago

JAMES BOND: Callum Turner Rumored To Be Denis Villeneuve's Top Choice To Play New 007

JAMES BOND: Callum Turner Rumored To Be Denis Villeneuve's "Top Choice" To Play New 007

MarkCassidy

5 days ago

FAST & FURIOUS: The Original FURIOUS 7 Ending Before Paul Walker's Death Has Been Revealed

FAST & FURIOUS: The Original FURIOUS 7 Ending Before Paul Walker's Death Has Been Revealed

JoshWilding

Nov 27, 2025 08:11 AM

More Action Movies & TV ►

John Cena Reflects On Taiwan Controversy That Had Him Convinced He'd Be Fired From DC's PEACEMAKER

John Cena Reflects On Taiwan Controversy That Had Him Convinced He'd Be Fired From DC's PEACEMAKER

JoshWilding

18 hours ago

Who Won NXT Deadline's Iron Survivor Challenge Matches? New Year's Evil Matches Set

Who Won NXT Deadline's Iron Survivor Challenge Matches? New Year's Evil Matches Set

AnthonyMango

1 day ago

NEW CHAMPION Crowned At NXT Deadline, Cody Rhodes Match Set For Saturday Night's Main Event

NEW CHAMPION Crowned At NXT Deadline, Cody Rhodes Match Set For Saturday Night's Main Event

AnthonyMango

1 day ago

WWE NXT DEADLINE 2025 PPV Results: Iron Survivor Challenge, Ricky Saints vs Oba Femi & More

WWE NXT DEADLINE 2025 PPV Results: Iron Survivor Challenge, Ricky Saints vs Oba Femi & More

AnthonyMango

1 day ago

John Cena's Final Opponent Revealed As The Last Time Is Now Finals Take Place On SMACKDOWN

John Cena's Final Opponent Revealed As "The Last Time Is Now" Finals Take Place On SMACKDOWN

JoshWilding

1 day ago

TNA FINAL RESOLUTION 2025 Results: Frankie Kazarian vs JDC & More

TNA FINAL RESOLUTION 2025 Results: Frankie Kazarian vs JDC & More

AnthonyMango

2 days ago

More Pro Wrestling ►

SUPERGIRL Official Trailer Teaser Reveals The Maiden Of Might Like You've Never Seen Her Before!

James Gunn And Peter Safran Address Warner Bros.’ Sale To Netflix, As Their Contracts Get Extended Until 2027

“It Hurts”: DAREDEVIL: BORN AGAIN Actor Responds To Quentin Tarantino Saying He Doesn’t Like Him

Resurfaced BTS Images From THE AVENGERS Show Much Better Design For Captain America’s Most Controversial Suit

Zack Snyder Says He Treated DC's Characters With "Reverence And Respect" While Sharing New Superman Photo

115 comments

SUPERGIRL Official Trailer Teaser Reveals The Maiden Of Might Like You've Never Seen Her Before!

JoshWilding

8 hours ago EST

96 comments

MADAME WEB Star Sydney Sweeney Addresses Controversy Surrounding Recent Jeans Advert: "I'm Against Hate"

MarkCassidy

1 day ago EST

73 comments

Zack Snyder Says He Treated DC's Characters With "Reverence And Respect" While Sharing New Superman Photo

JoshWilding

13 hours ago EST

63 comments

How Exactly SUPERMAN Made Massive $100 Million Profit For Warner Bros. Discovery Has Finally Been Revealed

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago EST

57 comments

James Gunn And Peter Safran Address Warner Bros.’ Sale To Netflix, As Their Contracts Get Extended Until 2027

DanielKlissmman

1 day ago EST

Do you have what it takes to write for us?

Want to contribute?

Home | Index | Site Map | About | Terms Of Service | Community Guidelines | Privacy | Copyright | Trademark Contact | Advertise

© 2025 ComicBookMovie.com®. All Rights Reserved.

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site, ComicBookMovie.com is protected from liability under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions. Content herein has been submitted by users who have agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. ComicBookMovie.com and Best Little Sites LLC are not liable for inaccuracies, errors, or omissions.

Learn more about our copyright and trademark policies

Contact Us for removal of copyrighted images, trademarks, or other issues.

View Recorder