Another CBM user's review of Watchmen

Another CBM user's review of Watchmen

While pleased overall with the film, there was only ONE major complaint I have with this film...

Review Opinion
By SGA - Mar 07, 2009 10:03 PM EST
Filed Under: Watchmen

This was a spectacular movie.

I knew it was going to be great, but I had no idea how great it was truly going to be.

I can understand a lot of people's agitation of the "random placement of music." Some of it did seem a little out of place, but I think it was meant to help remind the audience what time period this takes place in, instead of them knowing and then losing their concentration by the sheer awesomeness of the movie and reverting it back to our time.

There was only ONE song that I thought was out of place and I don't know the name of it. It was the song that was playing when Dan and Rorschach were flying to Ozymandias's Antartic lair.

The only two things I had a problem with at the start were Rorschach's height and Dr. Manhattan's voice. I got over these issues very quickly. Jackie Earl Haley was wonderful as Rorschach. His "Batman-like" voice wasn't as bad as I thought it might have been, and sounded very monotonistic when he talked for prolongued periods of time.

As for Doc M's voice. I thought it was a little too high pitched from the previews I saw, but it matched his character. The way Billy Crudip portrayed Manhattan matched the voice perfectly.

The movie overall was very pleasing visually and musically. When hearing Tyler Bates' score, I was mesmerized.

I have only ONE complaint out of the whole movie that really kind of took the excitement away. And that complaint is the actor who portrayed Richard Nixon.

With as much as they did for the special effects, you think they could have gotten better prosthetics. It looked absolutely HORRIBLE! Not to mention he was just a bad actor with a bad impersonation. I'm just glad he wasn't in the movie so much. All the other actors made up for his lack of performance.

And I don't know why everyone was getting upset of the portrayal of Ozymandias. I thought it was wonderful. While not as bulky as in the comic. He was majestic and very bad-ass in combat. He truly was the essence of Adrien Veidt.

I'd definitely give this movie anywhere between 8.5 and 9 out of 10.

WATCHMEN CHAPTER I Clip Recreates Two Big Scenes From Alan Moore And Dave Gibbons' Iconic Graphic Novel
Related:

WATCHMEN CHAPTER I Clip Recreates Two Big Scenes From Alan Moore And Dave Gibbons' Iconic Graphic Novel

WATCHMEN CHAPTER I Red-Band Trailer Released Along With Full Cast List And Blu-ray Cover Art
Recommended For You:

WATCHMEN CHAPTER I Red-Band Trailer Released Along With Full Cast List And Blu-ray Cover Art

DISCLAIMER: ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE]

ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

SGA
SGA - 3/8/2009, 12:48 AM
also, a lot of people are complaining that the song "Hallelujah" was playing during the Owl Ship sex scene....any self respecting Watchmen fan would know that "Hallelujah" was the song playing on the radio right before Dan and Laurie had sex.
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 3/8/2009, 8:01 AM
Man i loved All along The Watchtower playing as the boys flew to Karnak..it totally fit what was happening at the time. And like most i didnt like Hallelujah playing while Dan and Laurie got in on..even if it was in the comic it just didnt fit and made the scene cringy and laughable
Boekelaar
Boekelaar - 3/9/2009, 7:12 AM
all along the watchtower was not out of place plus the whole "two riders were approaching" bit was wicked which any graphic novel reading watchmen fan will know is appropriate in a watchmen incarnation of any medium.
blacksword7
blacksword7 - 3/9/2009, 3:55 PM
umm sorry SGA, but "You're my thrill" by billy holiday was the song that was playing during that scene in the comic book. i'm not sure but i think "Hallelujah" was playing on during a veidt nostagia commercial or something in the book. anyways, i was dissappointed that "You're my thrill" was played somewhere earlier on in the film and was replaced during the owlship sex scene. and i was hoping it would be playing during the fire rescue as well, like david hayter's original script suggests.
FalconX2
FalconX2 - 3/10/2009, 2:05 AM
"The way Billy Crudip portrayed Manhattan matched the voice perfectly."

Billy Crudup's voice was amazing. Yes it was his normal voice, but I have never heard such a "normal" voice sound so transcendent. It was astounding. I thought it matched perfectly.

A lot of people complained about the Hallelujah playing (or joked about it), I thought it was romantic.
View Recorder