CLAYFACE: James Watkins Reportedly Still Top Choice To Direct; Is James McAvoy In Talks To Play Basil Karlo?

CLAYFACE: James Watkins Reportedly Still Top Choice To Direct; Is James McAvoy In Talks To Play Basil Karlo?

A couple of updates on DC Studios' Clayface movie here, and it sounds like Speak No Evil director James Watkins is still the top choice to helm the project...

By MarkCassidy - Feb 16, 2025 07:02 PM EST
Filed Under: Batman

There have been some conflicting reports regarding the upcoming Clayface movie doing the rounds over the past week or so, with Deadline claiming that Jeff Wadlow is in contention to direct, and THR disputing the filmmaker's potential involvement while adding that J.A. Bayona has met with DC Studios about the gig.

Speak No Evil director James Watkins is the one name the trades do agree on, and according to MTTSH, he is still the "clear favorite and top choice" to helm the project.

The scooper also claims the recent rumor that James McAvoy is in talks to play the lead is not accurate, as casting has not begun just yet.

The script by Mike Flanagan is reportedly complete, but he is unavailable to direct due to his commitments to a Carrie TV series and the new Exorcist movie. The project has been given an official release date of September 11, 2026.

Based on comments from James Gunn, the movie will be set in the DCU, as opposed to The Batman director Matt Reeves' "BatVerse."

"Exciting news out of [DC] Studios today as [Clayface], a DCU story from a script by Mike Flanagan, has been OFFICIALLY greenlit. Clayface premieres in 2026."

DC Studios co-CEO Peter Safran shared a few new details on the Flanagan script, noting that Clayface is indeed going to be a full-on horror movie in the same vein as David Cronenberg's The Fly. THR recently provided some intriguing updates, and it sounds like the movie is also going to take more than a little inspiration from Coralie Fargeat's body horror hit, The Substance.

"Clayface, you see, is a Hollywood horror story, according to our sources, using the most popular incarnation of the villain – a B-movie actor who injects himself with a substance to keep himself relevant only to find out that he can reshape his face and form, becoming a walking piece of clay.".

Clayface has a reported budget of $40 million, and is looking to shoot in a variety of locales, including Vancouver, Toronto, and New Jersey or Atlanta.

Alan Tudyk recently provided the voice of Clayface in James Gunn's animated Creature Commandos series, meaning there's a chance he could also play the character in live-action at some point.

What do you make of these updates? Do you have any interest in a solo Clayface DCU film? Who would you like to see direct? Drop us a comment down below.

CLAYFACE: J.A. Bayona - Not Jeff Wadlow - In The Mix To Direct; New Details On THE SUBSTANCE-Inspired Plot
Related:

CLAYFACE: J.A. Bayona - Not Jeff Wadlow - In The Mix To Direct; New Details On THE SUBSTANCE-Inspired Plot

KICK-ASS 2 Director Jeff Wadlow In The Mix To Helm CLAYFACE; Reason Why Mike Flanagan Won't Direct Revealed
Recommended For You:

KICK-ASS 2 Director Jeff Wadlow In The Mix To Helm CLAYFACE; Reason Why Mike Flanagan Won't Direct Revealed

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
TheShape9859
TheShape9859 - 2/16/2025, 7:16 PM
Hard pass on McAvoy
TheLobster
TheLobster - 2/16/2025, 8:15 PM
@TheShape9859 - why?
MisterKite
MisterKite - 2/17/2025, 4:38 AM
@TheShape9859 - I have to agree. While I really like McAvoy, I can't help but feel that any portrayal of this character would just seem like a repeat of his role in Split.
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/16/2025, 7:17 PM
I haven’t seen any of Watkins work so far (though Speak No Evil from its trailers seemed decent imo) but if he gets it then I would be willing to give him a shot if Mike Flanagan is not available to direct it!!.

The McAvoy thing sounds like it was pure speculation/fancast that got turned into a rumor considering he had worked with Watkins recently on Speak No Evil…

However. It was stated by the trades that DC Studios might have a shortlist of actors they feel would fit the role but want the director they choose to weigh in their input aswell before going in talks with someone so McAvoy could be on that list and if so then would be a great pick imo!!.

User Comment Image
BlackStar25
BlackStar25 - 2/16/2025, 7:18 PM
Loved Speak No Evil! Great choice if true
Repian
Repian - 2/16/2025, 7:27 PM
Matt Dillon
User Comment Image
User Comment Image
TheLobster
TheLobster - 2/16/2025, 8:13 PM
@Repian - great pick!
KurtCrawler
KurtCrawler - 2/16/2025, 8:14 PM
@Repian - ah shit thats perfect
DrDReturns
DrDReturns - 2/17/2025, 12:14 AM
@Repian - "The House That Jack Built"
'Nuff said
Malatrova15
Malatrova15 - 2/16/2025, 7:28 PM
Just Call my friend Billy Zane
harryba11zack
harryba11zack - 2/16/2025, 8:09 PM
@Malatrova15 - hed be great
DrDReturns
DrDReturns - 2/17/2025, 12:15 AM
@harryba11zack - Great one :-)
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/16/2025, 7:28 PM
Also if that premise is true then while there may be some similarities to The Substance, it seems moreso influenced by one of Basil Karlo’s comic origins aswell as Matt Hagen’s in Batman:The Animated Series to me!!.



User Comment Image

In the comics, Matt Hagen is a treasure hunter but in the show he’s given Basil Karlos backstory of being an actor who had been disfigured prior to the story.
Nonameforme
Nonameforme - 2/16/2025, 7:29 PM
Brad Pitt via 12 monkey would be wild.
incredibleTalk
incredibleTalk - 2/16/2025, 7:33 PM
How about streaming a show on WB/Max first to build up your characters like Marvel/Disney does?



User Comment Image
Feralwookiee
Feralwookiee - 2/16/2025, 7:42 PM
@incredibleTalk - This is WB/DC we're talking about here.
User Comment Image
McMurdo
McMurdo - 2/16/2025, 7:48 PM
@incredibleTalk - are you being sarcastic? Have you watched Agatha. How bout Ms Marvel. Or Falcon and Winter Soldier.
incredibleTalk
incredibleTalk - 2/16/2025, 8:08 PM
@McMurdo - loved them all bro...you maybe giving out Oscars but all I want is to see my favorite characters come to the big and small screen!

User Comment Image
Nolanite
Nolanite - 2/16/2025, 8:14 PM
@incredibleTalk - how about no.
Clayface is a well known character and deserves a movie.

Nolanite out
McMurdo
McMurdo - 2/17/2025, 7:02 PM
@incredibleTalk - damn. Wish I loved all that shit too man. It's been a big letdown for me outside Wandavision and Guardians 3. Loki s1 was solid too.
Forthas
Forthas - 2/16/2025, 7:50 PM
This roll out of the DC universe has been the most uninspired, boring, and feckless effort at building a universe I have seen. It makes me long for the Universal Monsterverse.
tvor03
tvor03 - 2/16/2025, 7:58 PM
@Forthas - I agree. Literally nothing interests me. I thought James Gunn was a horrible choice to head DC Studios when it was announced. And nothing he has done as made me change my mind.
Forthas
Forthas - 2/16/2025, 10:49 PM
@tvor03 - Well...If Superman goes south there is literally no one else to blame but Gunn. They have already looked past his first DC film that no one went to see, Peacemaker which WB seems to want to hide its ratings and the boneheaded decision to basically tank four DCEU films by announcing they would soon be irrelevant. Somehow after all of that he becomes head of DC...go figure.
DrDReturns
DrDReturns - 2/17/2025, 12:25 AM
@Forthas - It appears very aimless and haphazard.

Growing up, I collected both DC and Marvel but I am primarily more concerned with characters than with publishing companies.
Batman, Superman, Green Lantern, Spider-Man, Daredevil and Hulk were my go-to's.

All this to say that I want these characters to succeed, but I can't fake my excitement.
Gunn has me nervous...
Forthas
Forthas - 2/17/2025, 12:50 AM
@DrDReturns - It really makes no sense to me why he is not focusing on the main DC characters (although I understand Batman). These side D list characters are not moving the needle.
DrDReturns
DrDReturns - 2/17/2025, 1:27 AM
@Forthas - Agreed.

To even use more popular characters, such as individuals from Batman's Rogues Gallery, in solo pictures is just confounding. These characters work so well BECAUSE of Batman. To have them exist without their protagonist makes no sense to me.

Yeah, sure. "Joker" 2019 was successful, but I believe that was lightning in a bottle.
After all, just look at its sequel ;-)
Repian
Repian - 2/16/2025, 7:52 PM
I have another role for James McAvoy in the Batman universe. He is the leader of a religious cult that comes to Gotham City. He is a master manipulator and his followers live and die for him. Ra's Al Ghul is his name as the leader and Ra's is the head.
User Comment Image
soberchimera
soberchimera - 2/16/2025, 8:00 PM
@Repian - Please, no more whitewashing of Ra’s.
MakeAmericaGrea
MakeAmericaGrea - 2/16/2025, 8:02 PM
@soberchimera -

Race swapping is okay.
RegularPoochie
RegularPoochie - 2/18/2025, 9:59 AM
@Repian - oooor, John Wycliffe?
bobevanz
bobevanz - 2/16/2025, 8:01 PM
After the success of The Substance they'll have plenty of choices in the actor pool
TheLobster
TheLobster - 2/16/2025, 8:15 PM
I’m down with McAvoy but I would hope for a more exciting Director..
TheFox
TheFox - 2/16/2025, 8:26 PM
Any director but Jeff Wadlow.

Z
MCUKnight11
MCUKnight11 - 2/16/2025, 8:41 PM
If there has to be spinoffs, I think Fries or Dent are more deserving. They could honestly be best picture nominees with the right crew.
User Comment Image
User Comment Image
Repian
Repian - 2/16/2025, 8:58 PM
@MCUKnight11 - I'm just going to say three things...

HBO Max Show, Bryan Fuller and if Jason Momoa is Lobo, Patrick Wilson is Harvey "Two Face".

User Comment Image
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/16/2025, 9:08 PM
@MCUKnight11 - sure , those could be fun too..

Gunn said it was Flanagan’s pitch & script that made him decide to greenlighting Clayface so if someone comes in and does something similar then we could get those too
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/16/2025, 9:16 PM
@MCUKnight11 - I think a Bane origin film could be fun too!!.

User Comment Image
RedEyeJedi5
RedEyeJedi5 - 2/16/2025, 9:46 PM
@MCUKnight11 - giancarlo esposito for fries
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 2/16/2025, 10:10 PM
@RedEyeJedi5 - I dig it.

Christoph Waltz could make an interesting Mr Freeze too.

User Comment Image
1 2

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder