Comic Book Movie Showdown

Comic Book Movie Showdown

Three very different superhero films are due to hit theaters next summer. Though it's very likely they will all score big at the box office, which will take the top spot. There can be only one...

Editorial Opinion
By multipurposeponi - Apr 27, 2010 10:04 AM EST
Filed Under: Other



What a great time to be a comic book movie fan! 2011 will undoubtedly be the most important year for superhero films; ever. Who would've thought that a little over ten years after Bryan Singer's X-Men revitalized Hollywood's interest in super-powered crime fighters, we would be getting a summer filled with big-budget blockbusters that won't showcase Batman, Superman or Spider-Man.

Marvel Studios has their one-two combo of Thor and The First Avenger: Captain America scheduled to be released only two months apart. DC Entertainment isn't sitting around waiting for Chris Nolan to finish off his Batman trilogy; their epic space adventure Green Lantern will be released right between the two Marvel films. Think of it as the cream in a superhero Oreo cookie (I f*cking love Oreos).

After getting over the sheer excitement that these films are actually becoming a reality, you should take a step back and understand the inevitable risk that both studios are taking. Marvel Studios has close to a billion dollars vested into their first three independent projects, Iron Man, The Incredible Hulk and Iron Man 2 already released plus their two currently in production. Thor and Captain America are the final two pieces to their Avengers movie puzzle; a film that fans that could revolutionize the ensemble cast standard. If, for whatever reason, these films don't dominate their respective release timeframes and fail to meet certain set box office expectations, it's very likely Marvel will be hesitant to go full force on the The Avenger.

It shouldn't be hard for them to make their mark, should it? Two highly-marketed superhero films being released back to back should definitely accrue plenty of worldwide interest.

But wait. . . there's more. Enter DC's Green Lantern movie; which is the first time Warner Bros is top billing a superhero that isn't the Man of Steel or the Dark Knight. You can guaran-damn-tee that if this film doesn't blow their box office expectations out of the water, the hope for Flash, Wonder Woman or (dare I say) Justice League movies is slim to none.

These three movies couldn't be MORE different from each other. Not only their characters and story lines, but their target audience. It's a given that every fanboy and girl will flock to theaters to see these films, but we make up a small portion of ticket sales. You have the Action movie genre (Indiana Jones), the Fantasy genre (Lord of the Rings), the Science Fiction genre (Star Trek) and many others; not including the random moviegoers who will see a film just because of the actors in it. How can you accurately gauge the possible success of a film when there has yet to be an official film clip or even promotional image released for it? You can't; but you use the information available to make a few educated assumptions. You'd be kidding yourself if you don't think the studios do that already.

I haven't taken the time to sit back and analyze the data yet. But I can't think of a better way to do it than alongside the members of the ComicBookMovie community. Below I've amassed what I believe to be the current information that can be used to hypothesize which of these three films will come out on top during the summer 2011 season. Now that you have the details, which do you think will reign supreme?


THOR

Date: May 6th, 2011
Budget: est. $150 million US
Theater Release: Conventional, IMAX

Synopsis
The Mighty Thor, a powerful but arrogant warrior whose reckless actions reignite an ancient war. Thor is cast down to Earth and forced to live among humans as punishment. Once here, Thor learns what it takes to be a true hero when the most dangerous villain of his world sends the darkest forces of Asgard to invade Earth.

Director:
Kenneth Branagh

Main Cast:
Chris Hemsworth
Natalie Portman
Anthony Hopkins
Tom Hiddleston

Target Genres:
Comic Book
Fantasy
Action

Largest Opening Weekend Gross (May)
Spider-Man 3 $151,116,516
Shrek the Third $121,629,270
Spider-Man $114,844,116





Green Lantern

Date: June 17th, 2011
Budget: est. $200 million US
Theater Release: Conventional, 3D, IMAX

Synopsis
A test pilot named Hal Jordan is granted a green ring that bestows him with otherworldly powers. It also gives him membership in an intergalactic police force called the Green Lantern Corps, tasked with keeping peace within the universe.

Director:
Martin Campbell

Main Cast:
Ryan Reynolds
Mark Strong
Blake Lively
Peter Sarsgaard

Target Genres:
Comic Book
Science Fiction
Action

Largest Opening Weekend Gross (June)
Transformer: Revenge of the Fallen $108,966,307
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban $93,687,
WALL-E $63,087,526

*Don't get confused by the names, this fan poster on the left was made before the full cast was officially announced.





The First Avenger: Captain America

Date: July 22nd, 2011
Budget: est. $160 million US
Theater Release: Conventional, IMAX

Synopsis
A sickly young man by the name of Steve Rogers volunteers to participate in an experimental military program during World War II that turns him into the Super Soldier known as Captain America.

Director:
Joe Johnston

Main Cast:
Chris Evans
Sebastian Stan
Hugo Weaving
Hayley Atwell

Target Genres:
Comic Book
War/Military
Action

Largest Opening Weekend Gross (July)
The Dark Knight $158,411,483
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest $135,634,554
Spider-Man 2 $88,156,227



Information courtesy of The Numbers, Marvel and Warner Bros





THE 4:30 MOVIE Interview: Filmmaker Kevin Smith On How His Passion For The Theater Shaped New Film (Exclusive)
Related:

THE 4:30 MOVIE Interview: Filmmaker Kevin Smith On How His Passion For The Theater Shaped New Film (Exclusive)

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking
Recommended For You:

THE FRANCHISE: Trailer For Max Series Starring Daniel Brühl Reveals Chaos Inside World Of Superhero Filmmaking

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2 3
ElBicho
ElBicho - 4/27/2010, 11:03 AM
I think Thor takes it with Cap and GL battling it out for 2nd place...
GusGalaxy
GusGalaxy - 4/27/2010, 11:04 AM
all three definitely sound great, can't wait to see em, although, my personal favorite is green lantern.
selinakyle
selinakyle - 4/27/2010, 11:04 AM
Thor comes out on my birthday...nice. I cant pick a movie.
HelaGood
HelaGood - 4/27/2010, 11:04 AM
Im totally pulling for THOR!! not sure caps will do as well as the other two.

and thanks, MPP for using my thor poster. :)
DogsOfWar
DogsOfWar - 4/27/2010, 11:07 AM
Nice job Multi. We will see an Avengers movie regardless of BO performance of Thor & Cap unless they post The Losers type numbers. We know that ain't gonna happen.

Avengers starts shooting in February with pre-production gearing up later this year. Too much will be invested at that point-no turning back so to speak.

I say Cap wins this. He is the most universally recognized of the 3 above.
JLanphear
JLanphear - 4/27/2010, 11:10 AM
Green Lantern will pull out the win. The support for it is unanimous, and everyone seems to be excited for what is sure to be an amazing film. Not to mention the current popularity of Green Lantern being at a peak thanks to the Blackest Night storyline. Lastly, it's a superhero film in space. Kids are going to FLOCK to this film, and their parents won't be far behind looking a good time.
seanxvito
seanxvito - 4/27/2010, 11:10 AM
Green Lantern will take the gold...followed by Cap and then Thor...mostly b/c as a superhero there's a lot of folks out there who have no idea who Thor is...alot of people know about the old norse myths involving Thor, Odin, Loki, etc. but as a comic book hero Thor's popularity didn't really increase all that much. Cap will get the support of military folks and old war vets like my dad. but Green Lantern will win out in the end b/c of the epic-ness of space battles. especially if they plan on taking it to the next level and have Green Lantern Corps. fighting all over the "known universe"
SHHH
SHHH - 4/27/2010, 11:10 AM
I know who will be makin an a$$ load of ca$h....
JiMb0
JiMb0 - 4/27/2010, 11:13 AM
the fan made GL poster used says "let those worship evil's light", missing the "who". oops!
superdog
superdog - 4/27/2010, 11:16 AM
green lantern will win. it has a grander scope and a more accessable idea than thor. and even though more people may know captain america he is a grounded person on earth. no epic space battles or cgi. as avatar proved thats what brings out the people. plus theres no question that reynolds is a bigger star than evans or hemsworth, so it will have the star power. i say lantern, cap, thor.
jazzman
jazzman - 4/27/2010, 11:16 AM
@MultiPurposePoni

do you have high res images of that Cap and Green Lantern poster looks sick
elcaballerooscuro92
elcaballerooscuro92 - 4/27/2010, 11:18 AM
wow! it's really hard to answer that poll, i can't choose one
JiMb0
JiMb0 - 4/27/2010, 11:18 AM
haha, dammit!
WolvieCBM
WolvieCBM - 4/27/2010, 11:21 AM
Awesome stuff @Multi. I hope Thor does well at the box office.Same thing with Cap and Green Lantern. But let's not forget that Lantern is being released in 3-D which will probably take load of cash at the box office...
Ranger14
Ranger14 - 4/27/2010, 11:24 AM
Funny how people see things differently. I would think Thor is more universally recognized than Captain America. He has the benefit of being in the comics, Norse Mythology and Adventures in Babysitting! ;-)

I would think that the strong cast in Thor will make it the winner at the box office.
Hawksblueyes
Hawksblueyes - 4/27/2010, 11:26 AM
I can make an arguement for any one of them coming out on top. I think Cap will surprise people with the age bracket seeing the movie.

It's going to get many older people to the movies that haven't heard Captain America's name in years.
rsalas
rsalas - 4/27/2010, 11:27 AM
It's gonna be great summer next year that's for sure. I love all three characters but I gonna go with Captain America taking this one. It'll be close but with the success of the two Iron Mans and Thor and people knowing these all tie in to an Avenger movie I can see people going out of their way to catch this next chapter to get themselves ready for The Avengers.
DogsOfWar
DogsOfWar - 4/27/2010, 11:30 AM
Let's not forget Green Hornet has been moved to 2011 so they are in the running too, right?

right?

helloooo?

anyone?
Hawksblueyes
Hawksblueyes - 4/27/2010, 11:32 AM
Dogs: No.
PS3geek1
PS3geek1 - 4/27/2010, 11:32 AM
who cares on which movie comes on top... its just going to be awesome seeing all the movies next year... I am a cbm geek here... I just can't wait until these movies come out...
tazmaniak
tazmaniak - 4/27/2010, 11:34 AM
I think Thor will take it.Mostly because it's connected to Iron MAN/Avengers.Now, while it is true that Green Lantern may be the most popular of the characters on this site, we're all mostly comic book fans.The average movie going public probably doesn't know much about him.And even though I'm excited for Captain America, alot of people I know are actually turned off by the period setting.I've got to imagine other people also feel this way.So, I really think Thor is going to be the victor of the three.
HelaGood
HelaGood - 4/27/2010, 11:34 AM
@Ranger thats what i was thinking as well...
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 4/27/2010, 11:37 AM
No way of knowing jack shit until we at least see some trailers, but based on cast, genre and director, I'm thinking I might lean towards Thor personally..
Vafrous
Vafrous - 4/27/2010, 11:37 AM
Thor,Cap and then Lantern...
CorndogBurglar
CorndogBurglar - 4/27/2010, 11:42 AM
ask me again when i've seen previews of them all. Cap and GL have me a little worried. but in all honesty, i think GL has the biggest chance of sucking hard. they can royally screw that movie up in so many different ways, and some of the things i've heard about it don't have me excited. (CGI costume)
CorndogBurglar
CorndogBurglar - 4/27/2010, 11:47 AM
Cap isn't as popular as most of you think. MOST people (non-comic readers) think of Cap as a giant, corny, tool bag. so don't be surprised if the Cap numbers aren't that great...
Hawksblueyes
Hawksblueyes - 4/27/2010, 11:47 AM
Multi and Gaston: You are forgetting the mythology enthusiasts and Lord Of The Rings (fantasy) crowd for Thor. I think a large portion of his audience will never have known he is in a comic book.
Weapon420
Weapon420 - 4/27/2010, 11:52 AM
I think it'll come down to star power, so it's a safe bet Green Lantern will draw more audience due to Ryan Reynolds popularity with younger female audiences. 2nd would be Captain America with Chris Evans past role in the F4 movies and on top of that the name Captain America should give it enough to hold second best. In 3rd would of course be Thor, though an ensemble cast the star is not very well known and who's only popular role was the first scene in Star Trek so it's safe to assume that this will be to The First Avenger what Incredible Hulk was to Iron Man. Just my opinion, I just know that audiences will go with the bigger name stars. But with that said I hope I'm proven wrong and that either Thor or First Avenger take the #1 spot and have a Marvel year with DC's GL in 3rd, I'm a Marvel guy, DC is too optimistic in it's content and Marvel has a sense of reality in it which I like.
airbeyonder18
airbeyonder18 - 4/27/2010, 11:53 AM
I can't vote on this. I'm really just-I can't make a decision, it's really hard.
Hawksblueyes
Hawksblueyes - 4/27/2010, 11:57 AM
Multi: I feel the same about them. I like all three to the extent that it's difficult for me to imagine a good reason, for even a comic hater, to not see any one of the three movies.
DogsOfWar
DogsOfWar - 4/27/2010, 11:59 AM
Talk about your movie tie-ins. Just announced today

thunderforce
thunderforce - 4/27/2010, 12:00 PM
This is an easy one green lantern will do alot better than the others simply because it will be in 3d . And because of that i think all other marvel movies afterwards will also be in 3d .
1 2 3
View Recorder