The Titanic 10th CBM Fight Club

The Titanic 10th CBM Fight Club The Titanic 10th CBM Fight Club


Feature Opinion
By PollMaster - May 10, 2011 12:05 PM EST
Filed Under: Silver Surfer
Source: DCMU

The result of the previous CBM Fight Club Poll:

258 Votes (58.64%)

CBM Fight Club Official Standing:
Win/s: 2

Lose/s: 1

Draw/s: 0

Other Conquests:
Thing | Destroyer

129 Votes (44.33%)

CBM Fight Club Official Standing:
Win/s: 1

Lose/s: 0

Draw/s: 0

Other Conquests:

233 Votes (52.13%)

CBM Fight Club Official Standing:
Win/s: 3

Lose/s: 1

Draw/s: 0

Other Conquests:
Wonder Woman | Captain Marvel | Superman

CBM Fight Club RULES!!!
You can base your vote on any version of the character (but preferably use the main comics continuity or live adaptation). For those not familiar with the character I have provided a short feature for each character, you can find it below the character's profile picture (click it and it will bring you to a different page consisting a short bio of the character and a list of his powers and abiliDraws). This is NOT A POPULARITY CONTEST (That is worth repeating -NOT A POPULARITY CONTEST), please decide logically, you can defend your vote in the comment section, and you can even include descriptive detail on how one character takes down his opponent.

Consider each fight as the FIRST MEETING of the two characters (even if they exist in the same universe, try to treat this fight as their first encounter, which means there are no prior knowledge of the other's power set and abiliDraws, as well as knowing their strengths or weaknesses).

These fights are Chance Encounters, the FIGHTS are NOT PLANNED, so there are no preparation time. But the characters are outfitted with their regular equipments, weapons, and other stuffs that are closely associated to the character.

Consider the character's personality and how the character will act on the given situation (will he fight dirty, will he be honorable, etc…). The characters can use anything in their present surrounding for their advantage.

Today's Fights

LOWER CARD- "Revival Survival"
Requested by:


Medieval Armoury


[HAWKMAN feature]

CBM Fight Club Standing:
W-0 L-0 D-0


CBM Fight Club Standing:
W-1 L-1 D-0

MIDDLE CARD- "Hell Blazers"
Requested by:


Rose Red Mansion


[GHOSTRIDER feature]

CBM Fight Club Standing:
W-0 L-0 D-0

[HELLBOY feature]

CBM Fight Club Standing:
W-0 L-0 D-0

MAIN EVENT- "Big Bang"
Requested by:


Downtown New York


[DR MANHATTAN feature]

CBM Fight Club Standing:
W-0 L-0 D-0


CBM Fight Club Standing:
W-2 L-1 D-0

Voting ends on the next installment of CBM Fight Club.

If you have a CBM FIGHT CLUB request be sure that the characters you chose has a LIVE ADAPTATION (these include Computer Generated characters but in a live movie adaptation and not a purely CG movie).

Thanks guys! See you in the next installment of CBM Fight Club.

-This has been PollMaster bringing you the imaginary fights of your life.
SILVER SURFER Solo Project Rumored To Be Moving Forward Following THE FANTASTIC FOUR Debut

SILVER SURFER Solo Project Rumored To Be Moving Forward Following THE FANTASTIC FOUR Debut

SILVER SURFER Series From FANTASTIC FOUR Director Matt Shakman Rumored To Be In Development
Recommended For You:

SILVER SURFER Series From FANTASTIC FOUR Director Matt Shakman Rumored To Be In Development

DISCLAIMER: is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and... [MORE], and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

Herosave - 5/10/2011, 12:47 PM
Odin vs Darkseid...
ThePuzzler - 5/10/2011, 12:55 PM
hawkeye vs green arrow

Mr. Fantastic vs Plastic man

Skynet vs ULTRON
Treebeard - 5/10/2011, 1:03 PM
Doc Manhattan! all the way! haha
kooldeath - 5/10/2011, 1:07 PM
I want to see some villians against each other. Green Goblin vs the Joker,bullseye vs deathstroke, How about Surpeme vs Hyperion or at least do some know your comic character on Constantine, Surpeme, Hyerpion ( thank thats him ) ,Majestic ..(ithink that was the character )oh Ghost rider vs Spawn , Spawn vs hellboy,
Daiman hellstorm vs John Constantine, Surpeme vs Gladiator vs Majestic VS Superman, Hihlander vs The Crow..
WrathOfOTB - 5/10/2011, 1:12 PM
I hope Silver Surfer makes an epic comeback!
kooldeath - 5/10/2011, 1:12 PM
@AVS..the crossover was voted on by the fans at the time when they did the Marvel vs DC. ANd there is no way Superman could be the Silver Surfer .. but the fans on here voted it so. And doesnt Dr Manhattan have almost the same abilies as the Surfer .. Im not too sure on Dr.'s powers or level of power.. maybe he should be know your comic character next artical.

Starheart - 5/10/2011, 1:28 PM
Hawkman vs. Captain America: This is a good fight, actually. Hawkman's damage soak is insane; the guy has taken blows from Black Adam thanks to the Nth Metal he carries. And his mace is powerful enough to damage beings like Black Adam and Despero. Cap's shield has likewise endured an insane level of punishment and can hurt people vastly more powerful than he. Hawkman is physically stronger, more mobile, and has more equipment, but Cap is the better fighter and strategist. I think Hawkman has the edge in the first encounter, but follow up fights fall to Steve.

Ghost Rider vs. Hellboy: I'm not familiar with Hellboy outside the movies, but I do know my GR. The guy can regenerate nigh instantly and is virtually impossible to kill or defeat permanently. Since Hellboy is a demon, Hellfire might not effect him as direly as others, but who knows how the Penance Stare would effect him? I think GR should have an edge, but I can't commit to that fully without reading more Hellboy.

Manhattan vs. Surfer: Honestly, at the risk of angering a lot of Watchmen fans, Dr. Manhattan when compared to other heroes outside of the Watchmen universe can be a tad overrated. Virtually everything that Doc has done, the Silver Surfer has done before in comics due to the Power Cosmic. Manhattan also has no experience fighting other beings with power, let alone someone on the scale of Norrin Radd, whereas the Surfer has fought beings such as Galactus and beyond. If Manhattan was in the mainstream DCU or in Marvel, he wouldn't be nearly as powerful as he seemed in the Watchmen universe if we're honest. So my vote goes to Surfer.
FanBoyBlack - 5/10/2011, 1:39 PM
Can you do:

Graviton vs Magneto


Darkseid vs Thanos
SpiderBat209 - 5/10/2011, 2:03 PM
1. Captain America: His Shield would clip off Hawkman's wings and make some Popeye's chicken out of em'! Mmmmm. :)

2. Ghost Rider: 2 words...PENANCE STARE!

3. Dr. Manhattan: Surfer would take one look at that blue weenie, vomit, and fly away! (Cuz, Norin Radd is all about the poon-tang!) :D
TruePunishment - 5/10/2011, 2:22 PM
@ SpiderBat, more like Surfer takes one look at that blue weenie and gets jealous because he doesn't have one of his own.
SageMode - 5/10/2011, 2:44 PM
Captain America vs Hawkman: This would be an interesting match to see. But being that Cap has gotten the upperhand against guys that are more powerful than Hawkman, id say Captain.

Ghost Rider vs Hellboy: Ghost Rider definitely.

Dr. Manhattan vs Silver Surfer: Surfer
SpiderBat209 - 5/10/2011, 2:47 PM
Surfer Tucks! Or Tapes it to his inner thigh! XD

Either one, SURFER RULES! :D
BlackAngel - 5/10/2011, 3:05 PM
It's too bad these things are about popularity instead of logic.
cable23 - 5/10/2011, 3:25 PM
Seriously?!? Captain America is beating Hawkman. The guy is practically immortal and has been fighting for over hundreds of years. Hawkman would own Captain America with his mase. Ghost Rider would lose to Hellboy since he is the devils son. Dr. Manhattan would win because his powers are limitless and he can instantly reassemble his body.
supersteveprime18 - 5/10/2011, 3:56 PM
im glad to finally see some1 get the uppper hand on surfer here, i think some of you guys on here rate him too highly.

To be honest i cant see any1 in the dc or marvel universe's standing a chance against Dr. Manhattan
PurplePhantom - 5/10/2011, 4:03 PM
Rorschach vs. Batman
Or better yet, Nite Owl II vs. Batman
PurplePhantom - 5/10/2011, 4:05 PM
Rorschach vs. V

Ozymandias vs. Captain America
HammerGod - 5/10/2011, 4:10 PM
Cap or hawk i'm not sure
Ghost rider
I'm not sure of the last one

I would like to see some of these
Black Adam vs Hyperion
Doctor Strange vs Dr fate
Black Bolt vs Darkseid
Cyborg vs Ironman
Kurse vs Doomsday
Evil Ernie vs Spawn
PurplePhantom - 5/10/2011, 4:17 PM
@HammerGod I actually like Doctor Strange vs Dr Fate! Thats such a good match up!

Hit Girl vs. Robin
robvillain - 5/10/2011, 4:25 PM
roland deschain v. jonah hex
CarlsinCharge - 5/10/2011, 4:28 PM
The comedian vs Deadpool or punisher

Joker vs superman

Luthor vs Batman

alboulder - 5/10/2011, 6:53 PM
I know this battle doesn't fit the guidelines of this but who wouldn't want to see
Thanos vs. Darkseid
superbatspiderman - 5/10/2011, 7:13 PM
Dr. Manhattan wins cuz he has a bigger wang. Ghost Rider would probably beat Hellboy, and Cap can beat Hawkman.
thechosenone - 5/10/2011, 7:16 PM
Love these polls!

Doctor Octopus Vs Lady Deathstrike

Phoenix Vs Green Lantern

White Queen Vs Rasputin

Ghost Rider Vs Spawn

Joker Vs Doctor Doom

Red Skull Vs Sebastian Shaw

Sabertooth Vs Bane

Dormammu Vs Loki

Galactus Vs Parallax

Juggernaut vs Doomsday

RolandD - 5/10/2011, 8:08 PM
And Thor defeats Superman because. . ., because. . . ., because? Oh, yeah, because he has a movie out currently. Superman-superiour intellect, strength, speed, heat vision and can handle Mjolinor. Superman FTW.
ADParker - 5/10/2011, 9:30 PM
Having seen a few comments implying that Superman in powerful enough to lift Mjölnir; I think that needs clearing up:

That is not a matter of raw power or strength; Superman can lift Thor's hammer for the same reason that Captain America can, and The Hulk can't, as well as at times Thor himself has been unable to: Their "Nobility of spirit," or in the words inscribed on the weapon itself:
"Whosoever holds this hammer, if he be worthy, shall possess the power of Thor."
SageMode - 5/10/2011, 9:54 PM

JGreenbeastofOH - 5/11/2011, 5:06 AM
nightwing vs daredevil

sabertooth vs killer croc

Ares vs orion

hercules vs wonder woman

Minato - 5/11/2011, 7:00 AM
Anyone who thinks Superman can defeat Thor needs their head checked. Most peoples arguement is that Superman is faster or smarter than Thor. Ive gone over both of these statements thru research and neither is true. Thor is as fast as Superman if not the slight edge Supes has wouldnt be enough to grant him an advantage. Thor is as smart as Supes esspecially in combat thru his thousands and thousands of years of combat. In any storyline supes isnt much older than 30 or 40 max. Superman and Thor are evenly matched in Speed Strenght Fighting Ability Durability Stanima and Nobility. The advantage Thor has comes from his ablity to travel interdemensionally. Which means if he takes supes to a red sun or basically anywhere without a yellow sun Thor gains a serious advantage. Not to mention Thor with the Odin force would step on Clark like a roach.

I wanna see
She Hulk vs Wonder Woman
Black Panther vs Batman
Xavier vs Jonnz
JackBauer - 5/11/2011, 7:14 AM
@avs72885 & kooldeath - In the Marvel vs. DC crossover Thor fought and defeated the big red cheese, Captain Marvel. That battle wasn't fan voted. Superman took out the Hulk in a battle that was supposed to be decided by fan votes, but DC refused to participate unless Superman won no matter what the outcome of the voting determined. The same thing happened with the Batman/Captain America fight.
Starheart - 5/13/2011, 11:15 AM
As far as Superman/Thor goes...

Superman, generally, has the physical edge as it comes to strength and durability, but not to the point where it clearly outmatches or eclipses Thor's own. His speed is faster than Thor by a good deal, but Thor also has shown the ability to hit faster than light moving objects and beings such as Gladiator, Hyperion (both Superman clones/homages), the Silver Surfer, and Beta Ray Bill's ship, Scuttlebutt.

The way I see it:

Strength: Superman by a small margin.
Durability: About the same, with Thor having a greater resistance to elemental and magical sources of damage, and Superman having a greater sense of durability to blunt force and piercing damage.
Speed: Superman clearly, but Thor has reflexes to ensure him not being overwhelmed.
Energy Projection/Manipulation: Thor clearly.
Versatility: Thor clearly.
Intelligence: Superman.
Wisdom: Thor.
Fighting Skill/Ability: Thor to a minor degree.

All in all, the JLA/Avengers fight, at best, supports Superman barely beating Thor, as Superman even acknowledged that Thor is possibly the toughest opponent he's ever faced. Follow up battles could likewise go either way after a hard fought battle. And no, Superman can't just "take" Mjolnir from Thor. For those who actually READ the crossover, Thor allowed Mjolnir to be wielded by Superman so he could breach Krona's defenses, and once the crisis was averted, the enchantment prevented Superman from lifting up Mjolnir to give to Thor. In other words, Superman can use Mjolnir if Thor lets him, so in a fight between the two, he's not going to somehow be "worthy".
View Recorder