REVIEW: Kick-Ass 2 #4

REVIEW: Kick-Ass 2 #4

Is Kick-Ass 2 #4 worth your money? Find out here in this review of the book.

Review Opinion
By JohnWilbanks - Sep 30, 2011 04:09 AM EST
Filed Under: Other

I am a little torn by the comic I just read. Yes, it was a great read, but only after I had a chance to look back on it and take myself far, far, far away from any kind of moral decencies. You see the comic I just read had so many scenes of utterly disgusting and reprehensible acts that your moral compass would have to be pointing in the opposite direction of a normal person to like it. Then again those acts do culminate into the catalyst for bringing back one of the main characters. WARNING – some of the panels shown will be graphic.

First let me start off with the art. John Romita, Jr. was born to draw this book. I could not imagine this book or its predecessor being as successful drawn by another artist. The way he doesn’t make his characters overly “super heroic” really adds to the realism of the book. Of course the art is something that has been consistently good with Kick-Ass and Kick-Ass 2. Romita, Jr. is already an artist that should be in the Comic Book Hall of Fame. After all, you can’t tell the story of comic books without mentioning him. (Note to self, someone really needs to start a Comic Book Hall of fame).

The art alone should make you buy the book. Whether Romita, Jr. is drawing Captain America and Hawkeye handing down a beating to some Skrulls or drawing a dog castrating a man, he is always at the top of his game.



Now on to the writing… Millar is far and away one of the best writers in comics. There is no denying that whatever he touches seems to be up there with some of the greatest comics of all time. He isn’t an Alan Moore type of writer, but he uses today’s vernacular and pop culture to craft an exciting story that is relevant to today’s teenage/young adult type comic readers.

After gushing over Millar and Romita, Jr. you would think that I would absolutely be in love with this book. You are probably right too, but in saying that it scares me a little bit because of some of the things that happen in this book.

Two things obviously stick out in this book that really has me second-guessing continuing on with this story. This is spoiler territory so do not continue on if you plan on reading this book and want to stay oblivious to the storyline. Staying on board? Well let’s get to it.

This book is absolutely filled with violence. That is not surprising because historically each and every issue is filled with violence. The problem I have is the manner in which this issue shows it. In one scene Red Mist or as he is known now “The Mother F#$%#r”, without hesitation mows down a group of six to seven year olds, just to make a statement. Not only to his group of villains, but to the reader as well. Maybe if this scene were not actually shown on page, it would not be as bad. It would have been better to show a panel with just Red Mist from the torso up pointing the gun with onomatopoeia all around. Instead we get the following panel…



The second moment is one that is not shown in panel (thank goodness), but is inferred by scenes before and after the event. It is a rape scene where The Mother F#$%#r and his band of villains kill Katie Deauxma’s family (and entire neighborhood) and then partake in raping her. As I said before, at least the raping scene is inferred and not seen on panel.

Although these scenes are appalling, they do serve the story well by telling just how twisted and vengeful The Mother F#$%#r has become since his Red Mist days. He really has it in for Kick-Ass since the death of his Father.

After the horrible events of the day, the Police get IP addresses from the FBI of all the heroes and villains. (Why they Tweet and post on Facebook is beyond me. It is just another one of those things were Millar likes the pop culture references I guess. They decide to round up everyone. While Kick-Ass and his friends are visiting Katie in the hospital (secretly), The Mother F#$%#r texts Dave that he should not worry about his girlfriend (Katie) and should worry about his Dad. Dave quickly leaves the hospital to run home.

Dave arrives home to find the Police have arrested his Dad for being the superhero Kick-Ass. Dave’s Dad has taken the fall for his son. Then the book gives us a big “To Be Continued”…

I have sworn not to buy this book again because of the scenes mentioned, but to be honest I will keep reading. Millar continues to appall me, but at the same time give me a story that I must see to conclusion. If you are a fan of Kick-Ass you will love it. If you are a fan of violence you will love it. If you just like a good “Super Hero” story, you might want to steer clear of this one. I am not going to rate this one because I honestly can’t give a particular rating to it. It both repulses me and intrigues me at the same time. (If that is possible)

John Arturo

New Academy Rules State Generative AI Use Will Not Impact Oscar Eligibility
Related:

New Academy Rules State Generative AI Use Will Not Impact Oscar Eligibility

David Zaslav Received Raise Of Millions Despite WB's Hard Times
Recommended For You:

David Zaslav Received Raise Of Millions Despite WB's Hard Times

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

zemus
zemus - 9/30/2011, 5:03 AM
I too and was left at the same crossroads after reading this book.

I have a huge pull list and I have a lot of friends who read them once I am done. I have been told by 1 or 2 of them they don't need me to drop kick-ass off to them anymore.

What this issue told me is that they are unlikely to make a movie with this story.
JohnWilbanks
JohnWilbanks - 9/30/2011, 5:09 AM
I agree, a movie done page for page on this book will never see the light of day.
DarthDan
DarthDan - 9/30/2011, 5:12 AM
Damn... I was a fan of the comics. Can't hadle the raping bullshit.
JohnWilbanks
JohnWilbanks - 9/30/2011, 5:15 AM
You know ten years ago this wouldn't bother me as much as it does now. After kids, you just read and watch things with a different view on life...
VictorHugo
VictorHugo - 9/30/2011, 5:23 AM
When i was a teen, i read "Marshal Law" and found awesome and groundbreaking, now i find it revoltingly disgusting.
Ichaos
Ichaos - 9/30/2011, 5:33 AM
Outside of being dowright disgusting acts the acts of violence and rape are VERY lazy shock value gimmicks on the writers part. Comics of that level should be kept separate from the regular comics if you ask me. Kids buy these things to and as a kid eons ago I never went with a parent to my local comic store.
Sparrowsabre7
Sparrowsabre7 - 9/30/2011, 6:01 AM
Wasn't Katie NOT Kick Ass's girlfriend in the comics? Did they just change the comic to match the movie? Not that I mind, I found the original comic to be pretty disgusting and while the movie was very violent too it didn't make me feel ill to read it. Violence in comics is fine, but we don't need a close up of a dude's head exploding...
Sparrowsabre7
Sparrowsabre7 - 9/30/2011, 6:07 AM
I think Millar has gone too far with some of the stuff he's done lately. Like Nemesis forcing a gay man to rape his sister. It's just messed up. This Millar is not the man who wrote Ultimates 1 and 2.

It's like Frank Miller all over again, I mean what was Batman and Robin All Star? At least that wasn't as disgusting as some of this though...
comicb00kguy
comicb00kguy - 9/30/2011, 6:35 AM
Millar has long shown a fetish for not just depicting degenerate, despicable, and repugnant acts of violence and perversion in his comics, but reveling in them. The events discussed in this article should come as no surprise to anyone even vaguely familiar with Millar's work.

I have a friend who is about as amoral as anyone you'll ever meet, and he was so disgusted with the scene mentioned here- killing the kids and raping the girl- that he tore up the book and threw it in the trash- and this is a guy who's done four tours in Iraq and Afghanistan and has seen acts of brutality far beyond what most of us will probably ever see.

That said, I thoroughly enjoyed the Kick Ass movie, but it sounds like they're really going to have to tone this thing down to get a sequel made. Millar can be a very good and innovative writer if he'd just get his mind out of the sewer for a little while.
AC1
AC1 - 9/30/2011, 7:04 AM
That's just sick! How horrible.

Hopefully a movie leaves out these bits, like how the first Kick Ass skipped stuff like Dave's dad shagging that lady which was in the comics.
VictorHugo
VictorHugo - 9/30/2011, 7:10 AM
Millar should be interned in Arkham Asylum together with Victor Zsasz.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 9/30/2011, 7:16 AM
Man, I'm over Millar's hyperviolence... I guess the "OMG, so edgy and dark and gritty" kids will eat this shit up...
DarthDan
DarthDan - 9/30/2011, 7:29 AM
@ John - Yeah, since my daughter was born it feels like a parental switch in my brain got flipped.
JYCowboy
JYCowboy - 9/30/2011, 7:53 AM
If a film was made of this book, the story would be altered much like in the original Kick Ass.

Katy sealed her fate in the first book when she rejected Dave after revealing his identity. This was compounded with texting pics of her giving a BJ to her new boyfriend.

In Kick Ass the film, they fall in love and the hero gets the girl. In Kick Ass 2, if made for film, Katy would be saved by another girl being raped by mistake or her escaping the attack. The kids would still die securing Red Mists ultimate fate.

Further, Red Mist might be distanced from the violance by using his crew protecting the little redeeming innocecse he has to that point. In the end, however, he would still loose.

Its not hard to see how Hollywood would handle this story. We all have seen changes just like this.
MaddMonkk
MaddMonkk - 9/30/2011, 9:01 AM
The controversial issues here don't add to the story. They are graphic just for shock value. If any of these unspeakable acts were related to the character then I could see where it is relevant. The movie "seven" is my best example the violence fit the story, this doesn't. I don't like this turn Millar has gone down, he is better than this. It's time for him to take a nap, drink some tea, and rethink his stories.
UltimaRex
UltimaRex - 9/30/2011, 9:21 AM
1: I hate to be the one to tell you all this, but the "Millerworld" comics are supposed to be what would happen if comic-book tropes got picked up by the "real world". You put a mess load of psychotic-but-trying-to-help "heroes" and plain old psychotic "villains" in NYC and things will get Serbian War real fast. Still, the moralists still have Superior...

2: The Kick-Ass 2 movie will NOT be like the comic. I think that's safe to say by now.
DR3D
DR3D - 9/30/2011, 9:42 AM
Never been a big fan of Millar, but his stuff as a whole is tame compared to Ennis, but Millar is going down a dark road.

TrueBlue
TrueBlue - 9/30/2011, 9:50 AM
This is why I don't like Millar. I liked the first Kick-Ass, even though it had scenes that really bothered and angered me. Like when Big Daddy revealed who he really was. But this is going too far. I don't think I'm going to pick this series up. Seems to me Millar needs to rely more on Shock Factor than writing skills. This is how he ruined the Ultimate Marvel universe
Comickid65
Comickid65 - 9/30/2011, 11:10 AM
I also picked up issue #4 on wednesday. I am a huge fan of kick-ass and have every issue. yes this issue was by far the most intense. all i gotta say is kick-ass better wreck havoc on the motherf***er! and I cant wait for hit-girl to take on that new big bitch!!
boyblunder
boyblunder - 9/30/2011, 11:12 AM
I really really enjoyed this book. it was quite a shock with those scenes however and the it is an appalling act, it truly was written as a point to further the story, i dont think it was unnesscary, and tho this would never work in a movie version of the comic, it certaintly worked well in the comic. this is what would happen if you get some people who actually veiw themselves as super villians in the real world. they would do truly evil evil things, and i think it was a perfectly done, even tho brutally. it showed instantly what i think millar was trying to illustrate through his riding: the super hero/ super villian fad is not cute anymore (in terms of the Kick-Ass universe). its a new act for the kick-ass universe, that shows with well intentioned naive people, also comes derranged phsycotics.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 9/30/2011, 11:27 AM
@MrEko as would Red Mist, for calling uneeded attention to crime.

Great points, dude.
AutobotCommander84
AutobotCommander84 - 9/30/2011, 12:16 PM
In my opinion, the movie is WAY better than the book.
Superheromoviefan
Superheromoviefan - 9/30/2011, 2:30 PM
I think it tried too much to be violent. Comics like Watchmen show much more violent and sex, but it do it how it should happen.

@AutobotCommander84 - Agree
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 9/30/2011, 9:31 PM
@knossis he's not obligated.But when you get into the artistic medium (or sports for that matter) you open yourself to criticism. Saying "why don't you do it better" is not a good point.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 10/1/2011, 10:23 PM
@knossis i see your point. still don't think a "do it yourself" or "do it better" is a good point. Since i'm not an artist and all that. ;)

I lived in Brazil for a good part of my life, man. You should see what TV is like around Carnaval. :P

I understand it's my choice to read it. that's why I said I'm tired of hyper violence everywhere.
rbfn04
rbfn04 - 10/2/2011, 10:51 AM
@MrEko when you go. Up north you'll find, how shall I put it, women more open to one night stands. Down south (specially a state called Rio Grande do Sul) you'll find the most beautiful women you've ever seen.
ghvghgfhjhgfghj
ghvghgfhjhgfghj - 10/5/2011, 7:49 AM
Will you people please stop bitching. The whole idea of Kick-ass is that its a realistic take on the super hero genre. Red mist is what i expect a real super villian to be like. There are people out there who have done worse things to children than whats been done in this comic.
Superheromoviefan
Superheromoviefan - 10/11/2011, 7:58 PM
@ghvghgfhjhgfghj - These people who have done worse things to children than whats been done in this comic they have done it private. Not in public.
vincentomoh
vincentomoh - 10/12/2011, 6:57 AM
Will Katie break up with Carl now?
BabyAddams
BabyAddams - 9/7/2012, 4:57 AM
As if none of you have ever seen last house on the left, or I spit on your grave, or boys don't cry? Why is rape in comic form suddenly more shocking than in film? It's just another form of media. The reason Kick Ass is so good is that it feels REAL. And if super villains were real, they wouldn't be monologuing bank robbers they'd be terrorists using any means possible to strike fear and destroy lives to gain power. This is what warlords do, and that's essentially what The Mother[frick]er is now. People seem to be so used to comics only telling certain types of stories that fans get a bit up in arms when other ones are told?
BabyAddams
BabyAddams - 9/7/2012, 4:59 AM
Also, the hunger games do a scene in which children are brutally killed, and that was described fairly graphically, not danced around. In slum dog millionaire kids were horrifically tortured so they'd get more money when out begging. If it's ok in that book and in films why is it not ok in a comic?
View Recorder