Jame's O'Barr Shares His Opinion on The Crow

Jame's O'Barr Shares His Opinion on The Crow

The 20th anniversary of The Crow is upon us, and the Dallas Observer was able to nab an interview with James O'Barr, the creator of one the most beloved graphic novels.

By nailbiter111 - Jul 26, 2011 10:07 AM EST
Filed Under: The Crow
Source: blogs.dallasobserver.com


Wow! The Crow is twenty years old? Unbelievable, I remember picking up the original print like it was yesterday. This is one of my favorites, and most cherished comics in my collection. To call it just a revenge tale would be incorrect, it's also a book that promotes the power of the loving memories you shared with the departed.

To honor the 20th anniversary, O'Barr is putting out a special edition. He is adding scenes, sequences and artwork never seen before. The new scenes are something he wanted to add originally, but they were too difficult to put on paper. He was worried that they would exploit the death of his fiancee, which was inspiration for The Crow.

I'll be picking up this special edition and look for to seeing the all new artwork that O'Barr has included.


The following is an excerpt from the Dallas Observer interview:

With The Crow being so personal, did it trouble you to see it become so commercialized with a number of sequels, a TV show and now a remake
of the first movie?

I have kind of divorced myself from all of that. I was heavily involved with the first film, and Brandon was my friend. I kind of feel like I made my movie, and I really have nothing else to say with that character or that scenario. It was never designed to be a Star Trek or James Bond franchise, which is what they keep trying to turn it into. Initially, I thought that they would cheapen the first film by making these bad sequels but in reality all they did was make it look that much better.

Remaking The Crow, a film that is only 15 years old, is kind of ridiculous at this point. I don't think anyone sets out to make a bad film, but the first Crow was a $10 million movie. I don't think it matters how much money you throw at it or what stars you put in it -- no one is going to top what Brandon and Alex Proyas did in the first film.

Frankly, I can't think of any actor that is going to have Brandon's physicality and his charisma. I just can't think of anyone that can pull that off. I actually think of Brandon when I think of The Crow now. That's how closely associated it is now with me. He nailed that part, but he really had to sell me on it too. When I first met him, I thought that while he looked perfect and could do all the physical stuff, he was just too nice of a guy. I had a hard time believing that he could be threatening and scary. So he took that as a challenge to prove me wrong.

I still remember thinking, "Wow, this is Bruce Lee's son!" But Brandon never played on that at all. This was the first movie he made where he felt like he wasn't in his father's shadow. I spent two years traveling around the world promoting The Crow to get people to see if for the right reason because he was proud of the film.

So when people always ask me what I think about what Hollywood has done with my book, I like to reference a Raymond Chandler quote that they haven't done a [frick]ing thing to my book, it's still sitting right there on the shelf like it always was! Read the source material -- films are a whole different genre, and invariably a book is going to be better because it has more depth. Its not going to be constrained by a budget or any limitations on the set, it speaks directly to the reader.

I have my book and my film, so I am content with that.

In the past 20 years, I think The Crow has really become somewhat of a rite of passage. I have watched the first fans grow up with me, and all of a sudden there is a whole new group of 16 year-old Goth girls who, I'm like, where did you even hear about this book from? This has happened with three different generations now, so it's like when you turn 16 you have to read The Crow and own the first three Cure albums.

I am glad that even though the book is set in the early '80s, the message is still valid: As long as someone is loved, they will never die.


If you'd like to find out James O'Barr's next project Sundown, please click the link below for the full article.
CANDYMAN And THE CROW Actor Tony Todd Has Passed Away At The Age Of 69
Related:

CANDYMAN And THE CROW Actor Tony Todd Has Passed Away At The Age Of 69

THE CROW Is Now Available On Home Video And We're Celebrating With A Giveaway
Recommended For You:

THE CROW Is Now Available On Home Video And We're Celebrating With A Giveaway

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, ComicBookMovie.com is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. ComicBookMovie.com will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that ComicBookMovie.com, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

1 2
churchgriff
churchgriff - 7/26/2011, 10:44 AM
I love The Crow movie and the original comic. I rewatch the film and reread the book atleast three times a year. It is one of the things that has had a huge influence on my life and has taught me so much about what true love really means.
I will be getting the new edition as soon as possible even though I own four copys of the graphic novel now.
Choppaholic26
Choppaholic26 - 7/26/2011, 10:56 AM
I gotta re-watch this, it's been a while.
MarkCassidy
MarkCassidy - 7/26/2011, 11:00 AM
Very interesting. I didn't even realize O'barr was a fan of Proyas' movie as it did differ pretty significantly from his comic in several ways.
GUNSMITH
GUNSMITH - 7/26/2011, 11:05 AM


"Remaking The Crow, a film that is only 15 years old, is kind of ridiculous at this point. I don't think anyone sets out to make a bad film, but the first Crow was a $10 million movie. I don't think it matters how much money you throw at it or what stars you put in it -- no one is going to top what Brandon and Alex Proyas did in the first film."

BRANDON LEE MADE THE CROW CHARACTER IN FILM, BUT YOU KNOW NICHOLSON DID JOKER AND HEATH TOTALLY BLEW US AWAY...I DUNNO, THE CROW IS BRANDON'S FINAL PEACE..IF YOU DO THE CROW DON'T REMAKE THE SAME THING..DO A DIFFERENT CROW, DIFFERENT NAME SAME "TYPE" OF STORY, LEAVE ERIC DRAVEN ALONE..
GUNSMITH
GUNSMITH - 7/26/2011, 11:09 AM
"SO YOUR HIM...THE AVENGER......THE KILLER OF KILLERS"..

naterator
naterator - 7/26/2011, 11:14 AM
20 years? wow seems like yesterday
Shaman
Shaman - 7/26/2011, 11:15 AM
"no one is going to top what Brandon and Alex Proyas did in the first film."

NUFF SAID.

That film is STILL #1 on my top cbm list.
Boogie138
Boogie138 - 7/26/2011, 11:20 AM
cult film with great filmakers and cast(no offense to the memory of mr lee, but lets not forgot that almost every actor brought their a-game to this) and a great cult comic, that to this day is under-rated. peeps remember the flick, but unless your a "16 year old goth girl" most have skipped by this gem. average comic readers in my neck of the woods are either the mega-event retards or the super indie if you recongnize the name of the publisher it is probably tripe set and both seem uninterested in a "goth" comic. sad but true friends.

reboot: this dosen't need it. i'd be like 15 years from now saying lets reboot 300. different beast entirely.

to this day i am almost positive this movie slipped thru studio cracks. who ever thought this movie would have been a hit? just thinking about the end product screams that a exectutive somewhere was thinking bout his 2pm golf game when that deal got signed lol
sheebz
sheebz - 7/26/2011, 11:22 AM
i miss brandon lee too... :(

Great article nailbiter, I'm glad to read that O'barr is still so loyal to brandon and what he gave to that role.
superbatspiderman
superbatspiderman - 7/26/2011, 11:52 AM
I agree 100% with this guy he is very passionate about what he does and I really respect that. The first Crow movie is great and sort of sad not just because Brandon Lee died but because of the character and how tortured he is. The ending scene of the film when he goes back to his grave always touched me. I think a remake would be good actually if it was done right and not this Bradley Cooper crap. I honestly can't see him as the character. My vote is on Cillian Murphy as the new Crow.
All the sequels of the Crow were horrid as well especially the one with Edward Furlong in it.
Dedpool
Dedpool - 7/26/2011, 12:30 PM
Well said Mr. O'Barr! Well said. Now with that being said I think the problem with Hollywood trying to do Crow films is that they feel there is a formula for them. There isn't other than wrongful deatn leads to ressurection and vengeance! Other than that you can do as you please. Hollywood should read some of the comics that came out telling different taless of the Crow. It should be an anthology series really, with different protagonists and etting and time periods even.
jjmeylar
jjmeylar - 7/26/2011, 12:43 PM
I didn't watch the film until a couple of weeks ago. I had heard of it and was told that I needed to see it, so I watched it on Netflix. I fell in love with it. After that: I decided to watch the second one and actually found it to be fairly entertaining. I refuse to watch the other two films or the TV show, though. If they decide to go through with a new film: I'm just fine with it. Personally: I wouldn't mind them having another non-Eric Draven one, first, though. I'd love to see one with a woman and have her named "Lenore" after the poem by Poe. But even so. I've yet to read the graphic novel, but plan on doing so as soon as I can.
Shaman
Shaman - 7/26/2011, 12:54 PM
Boogie138- Michael Wincott gave his own best performance of his entire life in that film. He was perfect in it, just as much as Brandon was. That made the final showdown MONUMENTAL!!!

jjmeylar- City of Angels was entertaining for what it was. But i just can't see it as a worthy sequel none the less. The rest that was produced after COA was absolute garbage, and that comes from a big Mark Dacascos fan. I'm still okay with a reboot/remake. But i know full well it won't top Brandon's and Proyas'. It had a chance when Norrington was attached (god i love his Blade film) but since he left, it lost it's only leg. Cooper on his own isn't strong enough to support it. They'll need a miracle and i feel it's too little, too late. It already happened with Brandon's and lightning doesn't strike twice.
SaintCrow
SaintCrow - 7/26/2011, 1:04 PM
God Bless Brandon
ironpool007
ironpool007 - 7/26/2011, 1:23 PM
You know I can understand James O'Barr's stance being that The Crow was a deeply personal comic for him to write and draw and that he was blown away by Brandon Lee's performance and the direction of Alex Proyas especially when he wasn't expecting Brandon to deliver. That being said, even though he us the creator and knows the story and characters best, I think the right team could come along and blow him away again. Hell, they could even do a closer adaptation of the comic this time. I can understand his opinion because of the quality of the sequels and TV show, but I wish he'd have an open mind.
Natetrix79
Natetrix79 - 7/26/2011, 1:35 PM
It's a perfect movie, it hit on every mark, the actors, the tone , the music(I'm a hip hop & r&b fan and I still bought the soundtrack!), the lighting, the writing(Mother is the name for god on the lips and hearts of all children.) this is one of the greatest movies of all time!!!
Deckline14
Deckline14 - 7/26/2011, 1:43 PM
for me if Brandon didnt do the Crow then we would never of had Heath Ledger do the Joker as he did. If you watch both with a open mind you can see where Heath got the inspiration. In relation to re-making or just doing another film they need to STOP the idea and just appreciate what the first was! for me it is a cult classic and will always remain that way!
RockNRollCC
RockNRollCC - 7/26/2011, 2:27 PM
if they're going to do a new film, to do it the absolute right way, to pay repect to Bradon, get David Fincher to direct, base the script very closely to the original graphic novel, and cast either Jared Leto or Joseph Gordon Levitt as The Crow.

If they get some unknown director, with Bradley Cooper as Eric Draven, I will murder Hollywood. It shouldnt even be done if it's with these two...
ikaiyoo
ikaiyoo - 7/26/2011, 2:41 PM
The Crow is my most cherished run of comics I own. Along with the hardback with O'barrs band, the crow soundtrack that is all the songs in the comic and my graphic novel I have had forever that is missing both covers and the preface.

The comic touched me so much because of its power and energy, and because you knew why it was written.

The only way to really remake this is to tell the story in the comic. not the essence of that story... the actual story. No supernatural plot. a man who wills himself from the brink of death long enough to exact revenge on the bastards that destroyed his life.
montana2rice
montana2rice - 7/26/2011, 3:07 PM
Mother is the name for God on the lips and hearts of all children...

technodrome518
technodrome518 - 7/26/2011, 3:16 PM
The Crow will always be one of the BEST CBM EVER MADE. I was 7 or 8 the first time I saw the movie, and watched it every year since then.
TravD37
TravD37 - 7/26/2011, 3:33 PM
O' Barr is right...leave it alone let it be the classic it always has been.
Then again if everything is just right they could do it..you never know
Rubbers
Rubbers - 7/26/2011, 3:54 PM
@ ikaiyoo - I completely agree.

Had for the original movie -- anybody else who tries to even tries to paint their face like The Crow looks like an complete idiot. Lee was born to play this role; he owned it!

The soundtrack, the acting, the cinematography, the dialog, and Brandon Lee himself can never be duplicated, remade, or outperformed! All other actors who tried to follow Lee's lead by playing The Crow failed miserably because they didn't understand that becoming The Crow is more than just sobbing out loud, hopeless facial expressions, or throwing a temper tantrum by playing revenge.

Lee understood that playing the Crow was an art form in itself. Acting is one thing, but body language was a part of the act no one else got right. Lee spoke like, moved, and fought exactly how The Crow should have. It was almost like he studied silent films to prepare for the role. It's too bad this film is look upon as only a cult classic because, imo, it undermines him performance. The film, in many ways, is a visual masterpiece.
SciFiNut
SciFiNut - 7/26/2011, 3:58 PM
People said the exact same things about Burton's Batman. If we followed these rules everyone is preaching, there'd be no Batman Begins or Dark Knight.

Its been a long time and the original is severely dated. Severely. I say give 'em a shot.
Ghostt
Ghostt - 7/26/2011, 4:23 PM
Leave the Crow alone. Not every movie has to be remade for fugs sake.

take away Brandon Lee from this movie and it is no longer a good movie. It turns into a shitty movie like Daredevil.

Look, they are talking Mark Walberg and Bradley Cooper for this role. Make me puke. Brandon Lee was skilled in martial arts and had Ledger's acting chops, who has that right now?
GUNGRAVE1
GUNGRAVE1 - 7/26/2011, 4:34 PM
The crow is wonderful the first one is the best.
drykillogic22
drykillogic22 - 7/26/2011, 4:59 PM
This movie is #1....Period...Leave Eric Draven alone.
The TV show was bad enough..But I still watched it..lol
BFGLOOM
BFGLOOM - 7/26/2011, 5:06 PM
This had a chance when we knew Norrington was directing/writing. Then the rumored Draven was either Charlie Hunnam or Ben Foster. Now we have an average director but a good writer if you saw his adaptation of watchmen. Its page for page novel onscreen. As far as Bradley Cooper.....FAIL. Also don't see him playing LUCIFER in Paradise Lost but he's wrong for the novel version of Eric. Things keep changing about this reboot so who knows.
Whovian
Whovian - 7/26/2011, 5:30 PM
I was working a Wizardworld show in Dallas a few years ago and had the priviledge of sitting by J. O. Barr and seeing the number of people dropping by his table to talk about the Crow. I remember thinking that it would be amazing to create a character that speaks to so many people, over so many years. The Crow is always relevent and classic. RIP- Brandon Lee.
gangbuster
gangbuster - 7/26/2011, 6:23 PM
James said it all! Is it too much to hope that Hollywood would listen?
HellScorpion
HellScorpion - 7/26/2011, 6:59 PM
The sequels aren't anywhere as bad as people make them out to be. Personally I'd like to see another sequel...
odie00
odie00 - 7/26/2011, 7:59 PM
the sequels suck. actually i liked city of angels with vincent perez. i felt that one was the closest to the first movie which would make sense considering that one was a direct sequel. the other 2 were very bad, especially with edward furlong he was bad. theres a reason he isnt in many movies. i was a kid when i first saw the original come out and now im 24. brandon lee was the man in that movie. its too bad he died at a young age 28 just like heath ledger, while doing a comic book movie. how crazy is that? he was my first choice as nightwing which would have been awesome to see him as.
odie00
odie00 - 7/26/2011, 7:59 PM
the sequels suck. actually i liked city of angels with vincent perez. i felt that one was the closest to the first movie which would make sense considering that one was a direct sequel. the other 2 were very bad, especially with edward furlong he was bad. theres a reason he isnt in many movies. i was a kid when i first saw the original come out and now im 24. brandon lee was the man in that movie. its too bad he died at a young age 28 just like heath ledger, while doing a comic book movie. how crazy is that? he was my first choice as nightwing which would have been awesome to see him as.
1 2
View Recorder